As provided in the Agriculture Working Group (WG) Report:: “Goals for Puna Agriculture 1.Local livelihood opportunities based on wholly-sustainable agriculture supplying local markets. 2.Rewarding individual agricultural enterprise. 3.Community land stewardship commitment. 4.Enhanced green infrastructure and a clean rural landscape.” The Working Papers seem to laying a foundation for addressing some parts of Goals #3 and #4. Suggestions and recommendations are being presented in the Working Papers regarding land use “to discourage subdivision for agricultural lands into small lots.” Whatever is implemented, the core concern of the WG regarding land use is to “shift options in favor of agriculture versus sprawl on parcels of essential agricultural land.” This core concern is the basis of Recommendations #3 and #4. If “district-wide rezoning” can successfully progress the WG’s Goals, that is good. If not, that is a problem. As for a “…expanded role for the county…” the WG called for “the County Government to commit to unambiguous, proactive involvement in the expansion of agriculture on the island.” So, the consultant, Steering Committee, and Planning Dept. need not wonder about more commitment and involvement by the County. In addition to rezoning, tax relief and tax reform (Recommendation #2) must also be addressed. Existing tax discounts notwithstanding, change is needed to achieve the above four Goals. Working Paper #2 does not acknowledge Agriculture Working Group Goals #1 and #2 where agriculture is defined as an economic and social development priority, not just a matter of land use regulation. Too often, “urban planners” put agriculture at the periphery of community development – a miscellaneous item to be dealt with through land use planning. In the case of Puna, this is not satisfactory. In feedback from the PCDP small group meetings, “a clear preference is expressed for local, wholly sustainable farming.” The Consultant has failed to embrace a central role for agriculture in Puna Community Development. This central role was reflected in feedback from small group meetings and in the Agriculture Working Group report. It would be hoped that the Steering Committee and the Planning Department will embrace a central for agriculture in Puna Community Development. Recommendations #6 and #7 are NOT about “the expenditure of county funds to support state (UH) programs and operations.” It is an insult to the Agriculture Working Group to misrepresent the situation as such. As stated in the WG report, “…among members of the working group (most of whom are directly involved in farming) there was considerable agreement with there being a need for better opportunities for local entrepreneurs to gain the training and skills to take up farming and associated work.” An agriculture scholarship at Hawaii Community College is specifically directed at that identified need in Recommendation #6. An agriculture scholarship is recommended to help STUDENTS! Every semester college students and their families patch together from various sources the necessary funds (loans, grants, scholarships, work, and savings) to pay for an educational opportunity. An agriculture scholarship would demonstrate in clear terms the County’s commitment to a central rol for agriculture, and reciprocal commitment may be expected on the part of scholarship recipients. The WG also recommended a Sustainable Agriculture Research and Development Fund as "Seed funding to leverage public and private investment that will enable local agriculture to supply local markets." This too is a vivid demonstration of the County’s commitment to agriculture. It is disingenuous obfuscation to dismiss WG recommendations #6 and #7 on the basis of the real or relative size and/or content of the budget for any level or agency of government. In terms of an “…expanded role for the county…”, the WG called for “the County Government to commit to unambiguous, proactive involvement in the expansion of agriculture on the island.”
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
