Kim Tavares Comments on Lennard
“Notes on Working Paper #1:” – kdt-20071004
Page 1, Paragraph 3:
I disagree with this statement as it appears to have
conveniently moved “close to urban centers, jobs, etc.” ahead of “close to the
ocean” in factoring in where “people” choose to live. A high number of the
increased population over
the last few years are either part-time residents or fully retired. They’re
largely not looking for jobs, they
want to invest money in oceanfront property, or as close to it as they can
get. The rest of the people who choose
to live near services, resources, stores and such, mostly can’t afford vehicles
and big land.
I agree that auto-dependent shopping and big box stores that
require several acres for buildings and parking, will not help Puna communities
and that we should avoid or even ban this sort of commercial development. The
lack of these stores and monumental
developments is a good tool for slower growth.
Slower growth is a better plan for Puna.
It’s too volatile to be densely populated. County is still rebuilding
infrastructure
from an earthquake a year ago. How would
we handle a hurricane right about now, or another earthquake? Or what if the
volcano really decided it wanted
the geothermal well head and Pahoa?
We’re not even close to ready to accommodate the sparse population that
we have now.
Growth Mgmt Policies, Page 2:
All great general information, but here we need to start
talking about specifics. As mentioned
above, Puna development should not encourage increasing densities. It should
do the opposite, but it should still
accommodate the equivalent of those populations that already exist, in addition
to the potential based on current build-out and permits in progress.
The vision for village centers should probably not be
projected for all current subdivisions, just the most densely populated ones
with small (less than one acre) lot sizes, and some 1-acres subdivisions too.
Growth Mgmt Policies, Page 3:
I agree that County should seek State legislation allowing
County to hold lands that would otherwise be auctioned off for unpaid
taxes. I actually made that suggestion
at the very first sc meeting. I’m glad
to see it reiterated. Details need to be
worked out of course, such as, whether community associations will be
reimbursed (paid) for outstanding roads maintenance assessments due. When it
goes to auction, the community can
put in a claim. It should not lose that opportunity.
I also agree that the County should seek State legislation
allowing it to increase conveyance tax on fast-turnover properties. It should
also look implement laws
preventing speculation building. Selling
and re-selling land has never been destructive, because usually they’re not
pre-built, they’re still forested. The
development that sometimes happens, and has mostly happened in the last few
years, has produced a number of unoccupied homes where forests once stood, as
it happens once every decade or so. Sometimes builders live in them for a year
or
two, but ultimately, it becomes un-sellable, and empty.
Page 6, Paragraph 1, Town Centers:
If the first sentence is true, why is this the first time
anyone has brought it up? Since I don’t
believe it’s true, or that the Puna CDP needs to concern itself with this
concept, the first two paragraphs of this page are really moot. By the third
paragraph, it is clear that
this line of thought is focusing on construction workers. Instead, there
should also be some kind of
disclosure that if you come here for the construction boom, for work, you
should know that it will bust. It can’t
be construction all the time. It is not
the County’s responsibility to keep them busy.
Creating more building projects to keep construction workers busy, only
creates more of a need, on a temporary basis.
It makes the problem bigger, not smaller.
Page 7, last paragraph:
Why just Pahoa? Why shouldn’t planning in other parts of
Puna proceed with community participation too?
Kim Tavares Comments on Wayne
Yoshioka PB Americas Transportation Report for 2007-2012 – kdt-20071004
Overall, I see a need for two separate discussions, “Puna”
and “Puna Mauka”. Inevitably, transportation discussions open and become
immediately dominated by the traffic in “Puna” (makai). That’s good, because
it IS the primary
traffic issue in Puna today. It needs
immediate solutions, however that doesn’t help Puna Mauka planning. It may
actually hurt Puna Mauka planning,
since it isn’t getting equal time or focus.
What’s happening is that we are reacting to crisis in lower Puna, and
planning for upper Puna, as an aside, the way lower Puna was already done
(poorly),
and so we’re repeating history instead of learning from it. It deserves equal
time and focus. In summary, the document is okay as long as
it is not the primary planning tool for the Puna CDP, and only used as an index
for what’s already been explored. A
land-use map would do much better in furthering a CDP plan the public can more
quickly
buy in to (or reject). We should be
getting out of ambiguous planning and into specific placement for various
non-commercialized infrastructure needs first, before we look at new roads,
routes, and those kinds of futuristic planning schemes.
2007-2012
What makes each proposed road on the map important, who will
use it, where does it go, what emergencies would it cover?
Bus routes and Bus Stop Benches, Shelters
We in upper Puna know our traffic patterns today, and have
some good suggestions for improving transportation from now until 2012. Most
of it involves a better bus schedule, and bus shelters at the stops. This area
gets more rain than just about any
other place on the island after all, and invisible bus stops are unsafe.
Proposed Routes Encourage High Density Populations in LOW
SERVICE AREAS
Some of the proposed routes in this report don’t make an
ounce of sense, unless we are planning for full build-out accommodated by the
economic boom and ecological disaster, the Superferry will bring to Puna mauka.
I don’t think we should be doing that now in
this CDP, because I don’t think it’s full build-out isn’t inevitable. It
hasn’t happened yet, but this plan will
accommodate it. We need better laws to
prevent the disaster and more public testimony / meeting time to work out the
details. Developers and planners are
losing sight of the fact that there will always be people looking to move away
from the crowd so they can raise pigs, honeybees or chickens without breaking
the law. It’ll be expensive to maintain
protection around organic farms with traffic driving by all day blowing
poisonous fumes.
Roads Before Infrastructure is Counter-productive to
Sustainable Development
We have not yet established how the rest of the infrastructure
will be, and we ARE letting the transportation options guide the future growth
of this district. That’s not what I’ve
subscribed to doing here for my neighborhood.
Where are the schools, improved County services, or infrastructure best
placed? Let’s figure that out first, before encouraging
people to fill-in the subdivisions. We
want to work on a land use plan and an implementation schedule that includes
transportation improvements. We should
not be working on transportation as the basis for planning everything
else.
Emergency Route Does NOT Lead to Emergency Services
Why is there no new subdivision connection from Stainback to
Waiakea? I know, it’s not Puna. But we are trying to figure out emergency
routes. In an emergency, Stainback
highway would turn into a parking lot, and it will clog Highway-11 – the way
the map is configured. Nobody going to Hilo will want to turn
RIGHT when they hit Highway-11. How is
that traffic going to all turn left past two lanes of highway? It’s not a
horrible route, but going up to
Waiakea will make a cleaner route for ambulances, since there’s only a small
hope of a hospital up here by 2012. By
the time PMAR phase 2 gets on the map, 2030, there probably will be less need
for it.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Yahoo! oneSearch: Finally, mobile search
that gives answers, not web links.
http://mobile.yahoo.com/mobileweb/onesearch?refer=1ONXIC
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation