Kim -
Your comments are thoughtful and realistic. You make lots of good points. I
hope that you get listened to seriously.
Rene> Date: Thu, 4 Oct 2007 16:24:53 -0700> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [EMAIL
PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]> CC: [email protected]> Subject:
[Puna-WG-eval] Comments on SC agenda items for tonite...> > > > Kim Tavares
Comments on Lennard> “Notes on Working Paper #1:” – kdt-20071004> > > > > >
Page 1, Paragraph 3: > > > > > > > I disagree with this statement as it appears
to have> conveniently moved “close to urban centers, jobs, etc.” ahead of
“close to the> ocean” in factoring in where “people” choose to live. A high
number of the increased population over> the last few years are either
part-time residents or fully retired. They’re largely not looking for jobs,
they> want to invest money in oceanfront property, or as close to it as they
can> get. The rest of the people who choose> to live near services, resources,
stores and such, mostly can’t afford vehicles> and big land. > > > > > > I
agree that auto-dependent shopping and big box stores that> require several
acres for buildings and parking, will not help Puna communities> and that we
should avoid or even ban this sort of commercial development. The lack of these
stores and monumental> developments is a good tool for slower growth. > Slower
growth is a better plan for Puna. > It’s too volatile to be densely populated.
County is still rebuilding infrastructure> from an earthquake a year ago. How
would> we handle a hurricane right about now, or another earthquake? Or what if
the volcano really decided it wanted> the geothermal well head and Pahoa? >
We’re not even close to ready to accommodate the sparse population that> we
have now. > > > > > > Growth Mgmt Policies, Page 2:> > > > > > All great
general information, but here we need to start> talking about specifics. As
mentioned> above, Puna development should not encourage increasing densities.
It should do the opposite, but it should still> accommodate the equivalent of
those populations that already exist, in addition> to the potential based on
current build-out and permits in progress. > > > > > > The vision for village
centers should probably not be> projected for all current subdivisions, just
the most densely populated ones> with small (less than one acre) lot sizes, and
some 1-acres subdivisions too. > > > > > > Growth Mgmt Policies, Page 3:> > > >
> > I agree that County should seek State legislation allowing> County to hold
lands that would otherwise be auctioned off for unpaid> taxes. I actually made
that suggestion> at the very first sc meeting. I’m glad> to see it reiterated.
Details need to be> worked out of course, such as, whether community
associations will be> reimbursed (paid) for outstanding roads maintenance
assessments due. When it goes to auction, the community can> put in a claim. It
should not lose that opportunity.> > > > > > I also agree that the County
should seek State legislation> allowing it to increase conveyance tax on
fast-turnover properties. It should also look implement laws> preventing
speculation building. Selling> and re-selling land has never been destructive,
because usually they’re not> pre-built, they’re still forested. The>
development that sometimes happens, and has mostly happened in the last few>
years, has produced a number of unoccupied homes where forests once stood, as>
it happens once every decade or so. Sometimes builders live in them for a year
or> two, but ultimately, it becomes un-sellable, and empty.> > > > > > Page 6,
Paragraph 1, Town Centers: > > > > > > If the first sentence is true, why is
this the first time> anyone has brought it up? Since I don’t> believe it’s
true, or that the Puna CDP needs to concern itself with this> concept, the
first two paragraphs of this page are really moot. By the third paragraph, it
is clear that> this line of thought is focusing on construction workers.
Instead, there should also be some kind of> disclosure that if you come here
for the construction boom, for work, you> should know that it will bust. It
can’t> be construction all the time. It is not> the County’s responsibility to
keep them busy. > Creating more building projects to keep construction workers
busy, only> creates more of a need, on a temporary basis. > It makes the
problem bigger, not smaller. > > > > > > Page 7, last paragraph: > > > > > > >
Why just Pahoa? Why shouldn’t planning in other parts of> Puna proceed with
community participation too?> > > > > > > > > Kim Tavares Comments on Wayne>
Yoshioka PB Americas Transportation Report for 2007-2012 – kdt-20071004> > > >
> > > > > Overall, I see a need for two separate discussions, “Puna”> and “Puna
Mauka”. Inevitably, transportation discussions open and become> immediately
dominated by the traffic in “Puna” (makai). That’s good, because it IS the
primary> traffic issue in Puna today. It needs> immediate solutions, however
that doesn’t help Puna Mauka planning. It may actually hurt Puna Mauka
planning,> since it isn’t getting equal time or focus. > What’s happening is
that we are reacting to crisis in lower Puna, and> planning for upper Puna, as
an aside, the way lower Puna was already done (poorly),> and so we’re repeating
history instead of learning from it. It deserves equal time and focus. In
summary, the document is okay as long as> it is not the primary planning tool
for the Puna CDP, and only used as an index> for what’s already been explored.
A> land-use map would do much better in furthering a CDP plan the public can
more quickly> buy in to (or reject). We should be> getting out of ambiguous
planning and into specific placement for various> non-commercialized
infrastructure needs first, before we look at new roads,> routes, and those
kinds of futuristic planning schemes. > > > > > > 2007-2012> > > > > > What
makes each proposed road on the map important, who will> use it, where does it
go, what emergencies would it cover? > > > > > > Bus routes and Bus Stop
Benches, Shelters> > > > > > We in upper Puna know our traffic patterns today,
and have> some good suggestions for improving transportation from now until
2012. Most> of it involves a better bus schedule, and bus shelters at the
stops. This area gets more rain than just about any> other place on the island
after all, and invisible bus stops are unsafe.> > > > > > Proposed Routes
Encourage High Density Populations in LOW> SERVICE AREAS> > > > > > Some of the
proposed routes in this report don’t make an> ounce of sense, unless we are
planning for full build-out accommodated by the> economic boom and ecological
disaster, the Superferry will bring to Puna mauka. I don’t think we should be
doing that now in> this CDP, because I don’t think it’s full build-out isn’t
inevitable. It hasn’t happened yet, but this plan will> accommodate it. We need
better laws to> prevent the disaster and more public testimony / meeting time
to work out the> details. Developers and planners are> losing sight of the fact
that there will always be people looking to move away> from the crowd so they
can raise pigs, honeybees or chickens without breaking> the law. It’ll be
expensive to maintain> protection around organic farms with traffic driving by
all day blowing> poisonous fumes. > > > > > > Roads Before Infrastructure is
Counter-productive to> Sustainable Development> > > > > > We have not yet
established how the rest of the infrastructure> will be, and we ARE letting the
transportation options guide the future growth> of this district. That’s not
what I’ve> subscribed to doing here for my neighborhood. > Where are the
schools, improved County services, or infrastructure best> placed? Let’s figure
that out first, before encouraging> people to fill-in the subdivisions. We>
want to work on a land use plan and an implementation schedule that includes>
transportation improvements. We should> not be working on transportation as the
basis for planning everything> else. > > > > > > Emergency Route Does NOT Lead
to Emergency Services> > > > > > Why is there no new subdivision connection
from Stainback to> Waiakea? I know, it’s not Puna. But we are trying to figure
out emergency> routes. In an emergency, Stainback> highway would turn into a
parking lot, and it will clog Highway-11 – the way> the map is configured.
Nobody going to Hilo will want to turn> RIGHT when they hit Highway-11. How is>
that traffic going to all turn left past two lanes of highway? It’s not a
horrible route, but going up to> Waiakea will make a cleaner route for
ambulances, since there’s only a small> hope of a hospital up here by 2012. By>
the time PMAR phase 2 gets on the map, 2030, there probably will be less need>
for it. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
____________________________________________________________________________________>
Yahoo! oneSearch: Finally, mobile search > that gives answers, not web links.
> http://mobile.yahoo.com/mobileweb/onesearch?refer=1ONXIC>
_______________________________________________> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing
list> [email protected]>
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
_________________________________________________________________
Boo! Scare away worms, viruses and so much more! Try Windows Live OneCare!
http://onecare.live.com/standard/en-us/purchase/trial.aspx?s_cid=wl_hotmailnews
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation