>At 09:46 PM 10/8/2007, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>
>While I agree with all of Kim's points, I agree 
>even more strongly with two points she made at 
>last week's Steering Committee meeting:
>
>1. Any decision on Transportation 
>recommendations should be formulated AFTER land 
>use recommendations have been developed. Having 
>transportation at the top of the priority list 
>has always felt contrived to me; this eminent 
>position was accomplished only by separating the 
>several topics directly related to Land Use. In 
>fact, transportation should be a subset of Land Use.
.



Aloha Hannah,

I don't understand why you believe that 
transportation issues have been set at the top of some kind of priority list.

Actually, if you read what Kim wrote, then it 
would appear that the imaginary line isn't 
between "land use" and "transportation".  Rather, 
it appears to be drawn between North and South, 
i.e. Puna Mauka and Puna Makai, according to what Kim wrote:


.
>Kim Tavares wrote:
>
>“Notes on Working Paper #1:” ­ kdt-20071004
>
>Overall, I see a need for two separate 
>discussions, “Puna” and “Puna Mauka”.
>
>Inevitably, transportation discussions open and 
>become immediately dominated by the traffic in 
>“Puna” (makai).  That’s good, because it IS the 
>primary traffic issue in Puna today.  It needs 
>immediate solutions, however that doesn’t help 
>Puna Mauka planning.  It may actually hurt Puna 
>Mauka planning, since it isn’t getting equal time or focus.
>
>What’s happening is that we are reacting to 
>crisis in lower Puna, and planning for upper 
>Puna, as an aside, the way lower Puna was 
>already done (poorly), and so we’re repeating 
>history instead of learning from it. It deserves equal time and focus.
.



I don't see any reason for anyone to fear that 
Puna Mauka will be neglected in the Puna CDP, 
when more than half of the steering committee members reside in Puna Mauka.

Also, Stephanie Bath, the Steering Committee 
Liaison for the Transportation WG resides in Puna Mauka.

Our goal should be to make sure that ALL issues 
get addressed so that BOTH Puna Mauka AND Puna 
Makai get the help that each needs most.



.
>At 09:46 PM 10/8/2007, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>
>2.  I hope that Mr.Yoshioka,  PB Americas, 
>incorporates SC and other comments into "his" 
>Transportation Report. But as Kim suggested, he 
>has fulfilled his contract, as he understands 
>it. The SC can "accept" the report without 
>"approving" it. Mr. Whalen can work with SC 
>members and the public to craft feasible 
>recommendations that reflect community input. I 
>hope that we can agree on some options that seem 
>to have vocal but also widespread support, such 
>as roundabouts, but I feel it is a waste of time 
>to work on Transportation details until after 
>major Land Use issues have been resolved.
.


I can tell you, for sure, that as a resident of 
Puna Makai and a member of the Puna CDP 
Transportation Working Group, I have NO problem 
with the steering committee resolving the land 
use issues before resolving the transportation issues.  Makes sense to me.

Furthermore, at the end of the Puna CDP Steering 
Committee meeting, my understanding was that the 
next steering committee meeting will focus on 
finally resolving the LAND USE issues.  The 
meeting after that will focus on completing the 
discussion about TRANSPORTATION issues with Mr. Yoshioka.




forward!
devotion, prema


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to