Aloha Clive, Larry, Stephanie et al,

Mahalo for your comments, and Larry for answering my question on whether the
Steering Committee will have input to the transportation survey.  I'm glad
to hear that Stephanie and Jon will be there.  Perhaps I should clarify what
I meant about not letting the bureaucrats divide us.

The survey is only one tool used, as Larry put it, in gathering public
opinion, but it's a powerful one.  I believe there are many thousands of
Puna residents who know practically nothing about the alternatives proposed
by the Transportation Working Group.  Before I read those reports, I hadn't
considered alternatives to the State widening Highway #130 and was resigned
to that happening.  So I'm concerned about the public being well-informed
when they sit down to check off boxes on a survey form.

I don't share the view that state and county bureaucrats will be happy to
implement the land use and transportation proposals from the PCDP working
groups.  My experience is that bureaucrats resist change and new ideas.  If
the public is divided, then the bureaucrats don't have to do things
differently.  They change their mindset only under heavy pressure from the
public and/or from their bosses.  Naming specific administrators at the
County level, that would be the mayor and the planning director.  So far, I
haven't read anything in the island papers about Harry Kim or Chris Yuen
looking forward to supporting and carrying out the new approaches the
Working Groups have presented.  They talk about support for the process
without sounding to me like they're committed to rolling up their sleeves
and making those new approaches happen.  At this point, of course, they
could claim it's too early in the process.  (We saw how long the mayor took
to respond to the Punalu'u community's situation.)

Before an uninformed public is surveyed, our process could use some articles
in the newspapers about what has been proposed by the Working Groups and
considered by the Steering Committee.  I'm disappointed that the
transportation consultant didn't analyze each of the PMAR proposals and
clearly state their pros and cons so the Steering Committee would have that
as a tool before they complete their own work.

Coinciding with more media coverage should be public meetings in Puna where
both Harry Kim and Chris Yuen show up to give their support and publicly
commit to do what it is in their power to implement the community's plan.
The surveys should come after the media attention and those public meetings,
not before.  (And perhaps there should be one more series of small group
meetings to encourage the public's involvement.)

Stephanie commented that she has heard only unity from the public in support
of the PCDP so far, "excluding nimby types and imby types."  That's a huge
exclusion.  All of us fall into those categories at one point or another.
Nothing is more divisive than recommending solutions to a problem without
thoroughly addressing concerns of the people who will be most affected by
them.

Bett Bidleman

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to