Aloha James,

Thanks for your clear framing of this.
Would you please send same to the Puna CDP participants list?
That's where there's the most people to see it.

As I expect you know, the second choice will also be much cheaper, 
especially in the long run.

cheers,
John S.

james weatherford wrote:
> The Puna Community Development Plan has presented for the community’s 
> consideration the following two mutually-exclusive ‘choices’ regarding 
> investment of financial and political resources.
> 
> (1) Twentieth Century Suburban Sprawl. 
> Invest in widening of Highway 130 to increase capacity for car travel 
> between Puna and Hilo. The effect will be to perpetuate Puna’s status 
> as a ‘bedroom community,’ with residents reliant on travel beyond the 
> District to access most government, commercial, and social services, as 
> well as for employment, arts, and entertainment. Daily lives of Puna 
> residents will be ever more oriented outside the District, and less 
> toward their community and each other. 
> There are multiple examples across the USA going back at least 20 
> years or more where highways have been widened for the purpose of 
> increasing capacity for car travel between a ‘bedroom community’ and a 
> distant center. Typically, after no more than 10 and as little as 5 
> years, the capacity of additional lanes is exceeded and congestion has 
> returned. In a phrase, “Widening a highway to relieve congestion is 
> like loosening your belt to reduce your weight!”
> (2) Twenty-First Century Community Building.
> Invest in development of infrastructure and services necessary for 
> village and town centers in Puna. The effect will be to empower the 
> Puna community to be more self-reliant. Puna residents will access most 
> public, commercial, and social services within Puna; doing so by 
> driving short distances or not driving at all. 
> Makuu Market, which began 5 years ago opening one day per week with 
> minimal infrastructure, is now a phenomenal success and proof positive 
> that a community gathering place can increase local economic activity 
> and social interaction within, and to the benefit of, the Puna 
> community.
> Entrepreneurs are building customer and business relationships in 
> fresh food production, prepared food service, creative and healing 
> arts, and more. There is a substantial and flourishing market for re-
> using resources (household goods, tools, clothing, books, etc).
> The social interactions as well as the market transactions on one day 
> per week for 5 years at Makuu Market (and farmers markets in Pahoa and 
> Volcano) help build 7-days-a-week community relationships and social 
> support networks across the entire District.
> 
> As a Puna resident, my ‘choice’ is Twenty-First Century Community 
> Building.
> Furthermore, there is abundant evidence collected throughout the PCDP 
> process that this same ‘choice’ is overwhelmingly preferred by the 
> broader community.
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

-- 
John Schinnerer, MA WSD
------------------------------------------
- Eco-Living -
Whole Systems Design Services
People - Place - Learning - Integration
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://eco-living.net
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to