The Puna Community Development Plan has presented for the community’s 
consideration the following two mutually-exclusive ‘choices’ regarding 
investment of financial and political resources.

(1) Twentieth Century Suburban Sprawl. 
Invest in widening of Highway 130 to increase capacity for car travel 
between Puna and Hilo. The effect will be to perpetuate Puna’s status 
as a ‘bedroom community,’ with residents reliant on travel beyond the 
District to access most government, commercial, and social services, as 
well as for employment, arts, and entertainment. Daily lives of Puna 
residents will be ever more oriented outside the District, and less 
toward their community and each other. 
There are multiple examples across the USA going back at least 20 
years or more where highways have been widened for the purpose of 
increasing capacity for car travel between a ‘bedroom community’ and a 
distant center. Typically, after no more than 10 and as little as 5 
years, the capacity of additional lanes is exceeded and congestion has 
returned. In a phrase, “Widening a highway to relieve congestion is 
like loosening your belt to reduce your weight!”
(2) Twenty-First Century Community Building.
Invest in development of infrastructure and services necessary for 
village and town centers in Puna. The effect will be to empower the 
Puna community to be more self-reliant. Puna residents will access most 
public, commercial, and social services within Puna; doing so by 
driving short distances or not driving at all. 
Makuu Market, which began 5 years ago opening one day per week with 
minimal infrastructure, is now a phenomenal success and proof positive 
that a community gathering place can increase local economic activity 
and social interaction within, and to the benefit of, the Puna 
community.
Entrepreneurs are building customer and business relationships in 
fresh food production, prepared food service, creative and healing 
arts, and more. There is a substantial and flourishing market for re-
using resources (household goods, tools, clothing, books, etc).
The social interactions as well as the market transactions on one day 
per week for 5 years at Makuu Market (and farmers markets in Pahoa and 
Volcano) help build 7-days-a-week community relationships and social 
support networks across the entire District.

As a Puna resident, my ‘choice’ is Twenty-First Century Community 
Building.
Furthermore, there is abundant evidence collected throughout the PCDP 
process that this same ‘choice’ is overwhelmingly preferred by the 
broader community.


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to