Hi Prema! 

I agree that technology can inhibit social inequality, but it really depends
on how the technology is used. The kind of technology I'm talking about is
bio-mimicry, cradle to cradle products, permaculture, backyard farming, and
the usual small scale decentralized renewable energy grid to promote local
living economies that is appropriately scaled to the bioregions, or
micro-regions of a place.  

Again social inequality...what does that mean?  Is this defined from a
dominant western industrial thinking?  If a family lives and owns some land,
growing their own food, fishing, spending all kids of time together, but
don't have access to internet, doesn't have much money, does that mean
there's inequality?  In traditional sense, we might say they are in poverty,
because they are not generating income above the poverty line.  That's how
our society measure inequality right now.  

Subsistence living, living off the land (owning a land) and having tight
family units can meet many fundamental human needs such as affection,
understanding, subsistence, creativity, leisure, protection, identity and
freedom to be on their own. Sure they have not been meeting human needs of
participation, because it's not accessible to them, but you can find out
plenty of information at the Maku'u market.  What is our economy and
government for anyways?  I think this harks back to the founding idea of
United States..."life, liberty and pursuit of happiness."  Are we living
this ideal in the modern age?  

Anyhow, I agree with Prema, that this internet thing is not accessible to
everyone, but during the previous Puna CDP, nothing of this sort ever
existed.  At least it's another layer of community forum, besides the
steering committee meeting, community meetings, working group (this forum
did not exist before), and the small group meetings (another new layer of
forum).  So, we have three additional layers or dimension of outreach and
engagement methodology that did not exist before.  I know it's not perfect
and it has felt really chaotic...but might that be something?  Some of the
residents of Puna are taking on the status quo or old paradigm of State DOT
and outdated concepts from the County code.  That's definitely something.  

Have a great weekend!

Alex



-----Original Message-----
From: Prema [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: Friday, November 16, 2007 12:58 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: 'james weatherford'; 'Puna Working Group report evaluation list'
Subject: Re: process is the problem


>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>I was talking to Tom Osdoba, he was the sustainability coordinator 
>for city of Vancouver for many years and suggested there were three 
>barriers and opportunities for transition to ecological and social 
>sustainability.
>
>Current barrier and opportunities for transition to sustainable practices:
>
>1. Economy - current market - need market change 2. People - current 
>mindset - need to shift people's mindset 3. Government - current 
>institutional barrier - needs to alter the institutional barrier.
>
>James, you suggested government is the problem.  We have all the 
>technology and know-how in the world right now to make the shift 
>towards better quality of life and start to deal with issues of 
>social inequality, identity conflict, climate change, diminishing 
>availability of natural resources (including the erosion of 
>ecosystem service and biodiversity worldwide, fisheries collapse, 
>water shortages, etc.), population growth and peak oil...and one of 
>the biggest barriers to this change happening is institutional 
>(international, national, regional, state, local).



Aloha Alex.

Unfortunately, technology will NOT solve problems of social 
inequality.  Rather, technology has a tendency to inhibit social 
inequality.  We see this in these County e-mail groups, which appear 
to be populated, primarily, by people at the top of the current 
community pyramid, i.e. County personnel, CDP Steering Committee 
members and those CDP Working Group members who were savvy enough to 
figure out how to use these HCRC e-mail groups.

Furthermore, the people who depend on these HCRC e-mail groups to 
know what is happening with the CDP are misled, if they don't attend 
the meetings.  At this point, it is pointless to attend any meetings 
until after the CDP Steering Committee completes the editing of John 
Whalen's report.  Once John Whalen releases his final report to the 
community, then (hopefully) the ball is back on the "community" side 
of the court.


>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>Well, Abe Lincoln said...our democratic government should be, of the 
>people, by the people, for the people.


Abe Lincoln is also infamous for "freeing the slaves," but I won't go 
there . . .



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>In a democracy, individual rights must be balanced with collective 
>responsibility.  One of those responsibilities, in my opinion, is to 
>keep our local government in check and balance. Your engagement is 
>in essence the revitalization of this concept.



Checks and Balances don't work with the CDP process.



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>Puna CDP was launched with a mind set of participation and 
>collaboration, but the institutional barrier started to get in the way.



The Puna CDP is a result of poor planning.  Period.  But, that's to 
be understood because it was something new.  No shame.  No blame.



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>Does the steering committee format, encourage or discourage collaboration?



Collaboration with whom?



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>The whole transparent system (i.e. sunshine law) was a direct 
>reaction to the old boy back room dealing.  It was a reactive 
>solution, not a proactive solution.  The last things we want to do 
>is to create more county council like forum that is rigid, 
>intimidating, and frustrating to many people.  I know the intent is 
>to encourage citizen involvement, but in reality, it discourages any 
>form of meaningful citizen involvement.



Until the public complained about the inconsistencies of the Puna CDP 
Steering Committee hearing public input, there was no reliable 
citizen involvement.  The Hawaii Sunshine Law was created to protect 
the public's right to know and participate in government 
business.  The Hawaii Sunshine Law is NOT the problem.

Also, it is not correct to compare the Puna CDP to the County Council 
because the Council understands and abides by the 5 Ps: Proper 
Preparation Prevents Poor Participation.  As much as Councilmembers 
may not like sending out meeting notices, providing up-to-date 
information on resolutions/bills and listening to public testimony, 
they still DO it and they do it in a way that is consistent and open 
for public participation.



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>In other countries, such as Brazil has overcomes these barriers to 
>create a better forum for civic engagement, sometimes referred to as 
>Deliberate Democracy.  The actual tax payers in the government 
>jurisdiction decide how to allocate the Capital Improvement Related 
>Projects.  The process is inclusive, educational, and very 
>accessible.  This concept has been institutionalized for over 30 
>years (this began in 1970's).



I expect a "democracy" to afford EVERY citizen of a nation to 
participate in its government, regardless of whether or not they pay 
taxes to the government.



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>At the national level in U.S.A., our current representative 
>democracy has been high-jacked by special interest group and one way 
>information medium of television with 10 second sound 
>bites...according to Al Gore and I concur.
>
>One top of that, legal tools and loopholes (in extreme litigious 
>society we created) gives distinct advantage to those with wealth 
>and power to avoid transparency and accountability.
>
>Internet is changing things, but as Naomi Campbell suggested, what 
>we have is a government ideology based on "Corporatism" (similar to 
>that 1930's Italian ideology).



I only know one Naomi Campbell.  She is a high-fashion model.  Is 
this the same person?  I'd like to see the reference, please.



>At 12:00 PM 11/16/2007, Alexander Frost wrote:
>
>With the sustainability movement all over the world, the changes are 
>coming at the local levels from a bottom up process.



The Puna CDP bottom-up-process has been hijacked by consultants and 
steering committee members with special interests.

When a landowner, Bill Walters, can get more out of the Puna CDP 
Steering Committee, than members of the public that ought to tell us 
something.

I'm not knocking Bill because if it is true that he supports PMAR 
from Kapoho to Hilo, then (personally) he is my hero.

I'm jes saying that when Bill shows up at a meeting to give public 
testimony, all ears are open and people are furiously writing down 
what he says because he is a large landowner.  His stuff gets heard 
and acted upon.

On the other hand, I have observed that when the public speaks, we 
seem to be "tolerated" because of the Hawaii Sunshine Law.  Our 
comments don't always get recorded and/or acted upon.

Out of time . . .


forward!
devotion, prema


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to