Aloha,

> Unfortunately, technology will NOT solve problems of social 
> inequality.  Rather, technology has a tendency to inhibit social 
> inequality.  We see this in these County e-mail groups, which appear 
> to be populated, primarily, by people at the top of the current 
> community pyramid, i.e. County personnel, CDP Steering Committee 
> members and those CDP Working Group members who were savvy enough to 
> figure out how to use these HCRC e-mail groups.

Prema, if you need assistance using these lists, or have specific 
technical issues with these lists that you would like addressed, please 
state them explicitly. I am not able to respond meaningfully to 
statements such as "...savvy enough to figure out how to use these HCRC 
e-mail groups."

Meanwhile, to recap the technical and membership aspects of the e-mail 
lists:

Using the groups requires only going to a plain HTML web page to 
subscribe, and once subscribed sending an e-mail to an e-mail address to 
communicate with others on the list. I purposely chose the simplest, 
most globally common, open source, non-commercial e-mail list systems 
for these lists. I stated repeatedly when these lists were established 
that anyone having difficulties subscribing or using the lists could 
contact me directly for assistance and in fact a few people have done so 
and received such assistance. Most have apparently not had any problems 
subscribing themselves and using the list(s) to whatever extent they choose.

I subscribed relevant County staff, consultants and Steering Committee 
members because it is part of their job and/or responsibility to be on 
these lists and at least "listen" if not actively participate.

These lists have from the very start been public and open and as 
accessible as such a medium can be, including two separate public 
archives for each list.

Beyond the known issues with technology access in some areas due to 
infrastructure deficiencies in Puna district, the low level of list 
membership and participation relative to Puna's population is in my 
experience typical of any such process and of e-mail lists in general. 
Just as in-person participation has fallen off since the small group 
meetings, online participation has languished as well. And for every ten 
or fifteen list subscribers there will be one or two active participants.

In short the lists are as useful, or not, as people choose to make them.

As Alex mentioned, they are here now when there was nothing before. 
There is a new online information infrastructure around the CDP process 
in all active districts that is making at least some more information 
available to some more people than in past. People can choose to take 
advantage of that, and to seek further improvements, or not.

mahalo,
John Schinnerer
HCRC/CDP tech services


-- 
John Schinnerer, MA WSD
------------------------------------------
- Eco-Living -
Whole Systems Design Services
People - Place - Learning - Integration
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://eco-living.net
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to