Aloha kakou,

The 40-ft ROW shown on the map was my oversight, which I blame on the crunch to 
finish the Pre-Draft CDP by the deadline while simultaneously trying to pick up 
the pieces of the unfinished transportation element.  The ROW was meant to be 
60 ft, which I agree would be a minimum.  This is sufficient for a single lane 
in either direction, leaving 18 ft on either side for a shoulder and shared 
bike/walkway.  A ROW of 100 feet would be sufficient for a true "parkway" 
consisting of two travel lanes in either direction (if eventually needed), a 
landscaped median, and up to 21 ft on either side for landscaping and the 
shared bike/walkway.  I don‛t recommend a ROW wider than 100 ft, not only 
because this would increase cost and the taking of private properties, but also 
because it is an invitation for transportation agencies to add even more lanes 
in the future.  If a 4-lane Highway 130 is unpopular, imagine how a 6-lane 
"parkway" would be greeted.  

Standards for parkways are variable.  I am not aware that either the State or 
the Feds have a specific minimum ROW width standard for a class of highway 
called "parkway".  There is a variety of Federal highway funding sources, 
including special FHWA funds for context-sensitive design, that permit 
flexibility in road design standards.  To allow for flexibility, therefore, I 
suggest that PMAR be designated a County (rather than State) road, but with 
Federal assistance.  In order to be eligible for Federal funds, PMAR would need 
to be designated as a "major collector" in the State Transportation Plan. It 
would then need to be added to the STIP.  State DOT does not necessarily design 
and build all of the roadway improvements that are listed in the STIP.  Some 
projects are County-initiated, developed and maintained.

There is no reliable way to estimate "litigation costs", especially at such an 
early and conceptual stage as the CDP. Anecdotally, some ROW acquisitions take 
many years, even with use of eminent domain. As mentioned in my previous memo, 
the risk of litigation increases when more landowners, large percentages of the 
area of the parcel, and property improvements are affected.  This is why the 
memo suggests a minimal ROW width that straddles the rear boundaries of 
properties. 

In the next few days I will send a follow-up memo on the alternatives of a 
60-ft and 100-ft PMAR ROW.

John     



-----Original Message-----
From: John Schinnerer [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: Friday, January 18, 2008 11:41 AM
To: Puna CDP Participants
Cc: John Whalen
Subject: ROW width for PMAR and additional cost considerations

Aloha,

John Whalen's memo on draft CDP PMAR recommendations mentions acquiring 
a 40 ft. right of way (ROW) through HPP lots:

http://www.hcrc.info/community-planning/community-development-plans/puna/draft-plan-recommendations/Consultant-memo-to-SC-re-PMAR.pdf/view

I doubt that 40 ft. is going to be allowable for such a use. I'm 
guessing that 60 ft. would be a minimum ROW just for County standards, 
if the County alone could afford to build it, which I think is unlikely.

If State or Federal funding is needed and acquired, their minimum ROW 
standards would apply.

Other existing PMAR proposals (e.g. from Planning Department, Rob 
Tucker, David Fukumoto) suggest 100 - 250 ft. ROWs be acquired.

John W., have you researched the minimum ROW requirements for this type 
of roadway at County, State and Federal levels?

A statement of ROW needs and acquisition costs based on actual ROW 
requirements for the intended roadway use would seem to be an essential 
piece of information for this aspect of the CDP.

Also useful would be an estimate of litigation costs (money and/or 
implementation delays) for the proposed land acquisition, as there will 
be legal challenges from individual HPP lot owners and/or groups thereof 
and possibly from HPPOA itself.

mahalo,
John S.

-- 
John Schinnerer, MA WSD
------------------------------------------
- Eco-Living -
Whole Systems Design Services
People - Place - Learning - Integration
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://eco-living.net

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to