Yes, let's improve and develop Government Beach Road. Make it extremely 
accessible. Then in not too many years we will be bemoaning the fact that we 
now have Alii Drive East.
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: John Lockwood 
  To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list 
  Cc: Rob Tucker ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
  Sent: Sunday, January 20, 2008 6:22 AM
  Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] Re :ROW width for PMAR and additional cost 
considerations


  Prema:

          Thanks much for your efforts to "keep 'em honest"...........  Thank 
goodness you are representing the Working Group recommendations, which you guys 
formulated after so well, after so much work and thought.  The "Government 
Beach road" would be an excellent secondary route, and provide wonderful access 
to presently unknown coastal beauty - but all the planners are focused on are 
straight roadways for the efficient transport of autos, and largely ignore the 
need to focus on sustainability and the need to focus on people - not cars.....

          Yes - the lack of discussion about roundabouts does indeed pain Marti 
and me - though the County seems to have little interest in trying to alter the 
State bureaucratic processes in place....

          I regret I have had so little time to do other than kibbitz from the 
sidelines, but I will go "to the barricades" with you when needed.

          Aloha,

                   Jack


  At 09:21 PM 1/19/2008, you wrote:

    Aloha Rob,

    On Page 18 thru 21 of the Puna CDP Transportation 
    Working Group Final Report for EXISTING ROADWAYS, 
    the Puna CDP Transportation WG Existing Roadways 
    Task Partnership recommended that Government 
    Beach Road be "transformed into a "scenic byway" 
    and emergency evacuation route."

    Source: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group 
    Final Report - EXISTING ROADWAYS (February 15, 2007)
    < 
http://www.hcrc.info/community-planning/community-development-plans/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-existing-roadways.pdf/view
 >

    Furthermore, I can see how the Railroad 
    Right-Of-Way (ROW) could possibly be nominated 
    for a National Scenic Byway® designation because 
    of it's historical intrinsic quality.

    In his December 2007 Puna CP Pre-Draft document 
    and his January 11, 2007 Memorandum, John Whalen 
    has proposed a PMAR alignment between 15th Road 
    and 16th Road in Hawaiian Paradise Park.

    I do not understand how the consultant's proposed 
    PMAR alignment qualifies as a nominee for a National Scenic Byway® 
designation.

    What are the intrinsic qualities, i.e. 
    archaeological, cultural, historic, natural, 
    recreational and/or scenic qualities, of John 
    Whalen's proposed PMAR, which you think would 
    qualify it as a nominee for a National Scenic Byway® designation?

    Also, is there a hyperlink for the information you provided (below)?


    forward!
    mahalo, prema


    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    At 04:26 PM 1/19/2008, Rob Tucker wrote:

    Aloha to both Johns,

    In my rresearch I found the following Federal 
    program which might be applicable to a PMAR.  It shows an 80% federal 
share....

    FYI,

    Rob Tucjer

    FEDERAL PROGRAM:
    National Scenic Byways Program

    FEDERAL AGENCY:  Federal Highway Administration

    PROGRAM DESCRIPTION  The National Scenic Byways 
    Program provides grants to states with scenic 
    highway programs for  projects on highways that 
    are designated by the U.S. Secretary of 
    Transportation as All-American  Roads or National 
    Scenic Byways, or by the state as scenic byways.

    These roads are designated  for having 
    outstanding scenic, historic, cultural, natural, 
    recreational, and archaeological 
    qualities.   Eligible projects include planning, 
    designing, and developing of scenic byways 
    programs; safety  improvements to scenic byways; 
    pedestrian and bicyclist facilities; rest areas, 
    turnouts, shoulder  improvements, passing lanes, 
    overlooks, and interpretive facilities; 
    improvements that enhance  the area for the 
    purpose of recreation; protection of historical 
    and cultural resources; and developing and providing tourist information.

    TEA-21 expanded the list of eligible activities 
    to include the development and implementation of 
    scenic byway marketing programs.

    STATE RECIPIENTS  WSDOT Program I3 or T.

    DISTRIBUTIONS  Grants to states are at the 
    discretion of the U.S. Secretary of 
    Transportation, based on application  of the 
    states, or at Congressional direction.

    MATCHING REQUIREMENTS  80% federal share; 20% 
    state share.  Federal land management agencies 
    are allowed to provide  the nonfederal share for 
    projects on federal or Indian lands.


    _______________________________________________
    Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
    [email protected]
    https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation 
  
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  John P. ("Jack") Lockwood, Ph.D..  Consulting Volcanologist --- CPG-9806
  P.O. Box 479, Volcano, Hawaii 96785 USA  [Physical Address: 19-4260 Alanui 
Iiwi, Volcano, Hawaii, 96785]
  Tel:   1-808-967-8579,  FAX:  1-808-967-8525
  E-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED],  Web Pages: http://www.volcanologist.com
  
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 



------------------------------------------------------------------------------


  _______________________________________________
  Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
  [email protected]
  https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to