Okay, I'll clarify a little. I'm not currently using qmailanalog, so I'll try to do it in words. [EMAIL PROTECTED] produced a bounce due to: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: 195.41.46.148 does not like recipient. This bounce was supposed to be sent to [EMAIL PROTECTED] (uid 1014), but was instead sent to [EMAIL PROTECTED], a message which was accepted by [EMAIL PROTECTED] (uid 1044) and forwarded to [EMAIL PROTECTED] The events, as I interpret them, were as follows (in some sort of meta-language): 1.) Mail is sent with following instructions From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 2.) qmail delivers the messages separate from eachother (delivery 2349 & 2350, msg 539092) 3.) qmail reports a failure for delivery 2349, and sends a bounce (delivery 2351, msg 539093) 4.) qmail reports a failure for delivery 2350 (also msg 539092) Here is the interesting part.. 5.) qmail begins a new msg with id 539092 (there has not yet been a second bounce for that mail, only a second report of failure,) delivery 2352 6.) qmail carries out delivery 2352 successfully, and begins the forward to [EMAIL PROTECTED] (delivery 2353) 7.) qmail starts a bounce for msg 539092, although delivery 2352 has been carried out successfully. It bounces the message delivered by delivery 2350, but to the wrong adress. It should have bounced to [EMAIL PROTECTED] but bounced to [EMAIL PROTECTED] I've marked out the different events in the attached log-file. I hope this is clearer, otherwise I guess I'll have to install qmailanalog. Thanks, Henrik. Dave Sill wrote: > Henrik =?iso-8859-1?Q?=D6hman?= <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > >I checked the logs.. > > I can't make sense out these with the funky line wrapping, and without > knowing more about your system (e.g., who are UID's 21 and 1044, and > how is mail to henrik.ohman handled?). Try running "matchup" from > qmailanalog to produce easier-to-read log entries. > > >Hey, wait a moment. The bounce came _after_ the inode had been assigned > >to a new msg? > >Uhh, is this normal? Did something fuck up, and in that case, was it > >qmail or the MUA? > >Could this have happened before, or was it a one-timer? > > I can't really say, since I can't tell what happened, but I can't see > that anything unusual happened. Other than the symptoms you see in the > logs, what happened that you don't think should have happened, or > didn't happen that you think should have happened? > > -Dave
## 1.) Feb 4 11:44:01 gammalinux qmail: 949661041.678271 new msg 539092 Feb 4 11:44:01 gammalinux qmail: 949661041.678902 info msg 539092: bytes 8458 f rom <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> qp 32082 uid 21 ## 2.) Feb 4 11:44:01 gammalinux qmail: 949661041.681663 starting delivery 2349: msg 5 39092 to remote [EMAIL PROTECTED] Feb 4 11:44:04 gammalinux qmail: 949661044.681268 starting delivery 2350: msg 5 39092 to remote [EMAIL PROTECTED] ## 3.) Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.751848 delivery 2349: failure: 195.4 1.46.148_does_not_like_recipient./Remote_host_said:_550_Invalid_recipient:_ Giving_up_on_195.41.46.148./ Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.763374 bounce msg 539092 qp 32085 Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.764177 end msg 539092 Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.765228 new msg 539093 Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.766079 info msg 539093: bytes 9108 f rom <> qp 32085 uid 26 Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.769127 starting delivery 2351: msg 5 39093 to local [EMAIL PROTECTED] Feb 4 11:44:05 gammalinux qmail: 949661045.787893 delivery 2351: success: did_1 +0+0/ ## 4.) Feb 4 11:44:08 gammalinux qmail: 949661048.674722 delivery 2350: failure: 195.4 1.46.148_does_not_like_recipient./Remote_host_said:_550_Invalid_recipient:_<sect [EMAIL PROTECTED]>/Giving_up_on_195.41.46.148./ ## 5.) Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.154927 new msg 539092 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.155801 info msg 539092: bytes 1737 f rom <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> qp 32092 uid 21 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.159059 starting delivery 2352: msg 5 39092 to local [EMAIL PROTECTED] ## 6.) Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.179819 new msg 539093 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.180866 info msg 539093: bytes 1848 f rom <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> qp 32095 uid 10 44 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.184363 starting delivery 2353: msg 5 39093 to local [EMAIL PROTECTED] Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.186468 delivery 2352: success: did_0 +1+0/qp_32095/ ## 7.) Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.196002 bounce msg 539092 qp 32097 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.196804 end msg 539092 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.198004 new msg 539094 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.198872 info msg 539094: bytes 2447 f rom <> qp 32097 uid 26 Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.202550 starting delivery 2354: msg 5 39094 to remote [EMAIL PROTECTED] Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.224028 delivery 2353: success: did_1 +0+0/ Feb 4 11:44:21 gammalinux qmail: 949661061.225800 end msg 539093 Feb 4 11:44:29 gammalinux qmail: 949661069.445899 delivery 2354: success: 131.1 93.178.181_accepted_message./Remote_host_said:_250_ok_949661062_qp_27142/
