I am sorry to have confused you, Jonathan. I have only been on this listserv for about 6 months, though I have been self-educating about FRBR/RDA for far longer. I am certain that many philosophical discussions about RDA and its basis in FRBR went on long before I got here, and I am consciously trying not to start one of those again because I'm sure they were lengthy.
I have deep philosophical reservations about the basis of RDA in FRBR, as I think that the data-entity relationship model is not the best underpinning for a new cataloging system. Since it (d/e model) was "invented" by programmers, whose worldview usually takes a certain form, I think it's a Procrustean exercise to try to impose it on cataloging practice. To say nothing of how arcane RDA is (I think it's far worse than AACR2 ever was,) and various other irritations both large and small which irk me whenever I read about it. But I also think it's a done deal so far as its adoption goes. I wish it were not so, but there is nothing I can do about it, so I am endeavoring to adapt. I dislike WEMI, but I know I am in the minority. Every once in awhile I try to mention what I perceive as its shaky philosophical base. That's what I was trying to do today. It's WEMI that makes this all so difficult. Of course a book and a movie are different things and they have different main entries. But in FRBR/RDA world, as in Wonderland, things are often not what they seem to be. Kathleen F. Lamantia, MLIS Technical Services Librarian Stark County District Library 715 Market Avenue North Canton, OH 44702 330-458-2723 [email protected] Inspiring Ideas ∙ Enriching Lives ∙ Creating Community The Stark County District Library is a winner of the National Medal for library service, is one of the best 100 libraries in the U.S. according to the HAPLR rating, and is a Library Journal 5 Star library. -----Original Message----- From: Jonathan Rochkind [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, April 08, 2011 12:41 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: [RDA-L] FRBR > No librarian worth his/her salt would, which is my point about FRBR/RDA. I > am NOT arguing in favor of it, > I'm only trying to deal with it as it is - or appears to be, or is trying to > be - thus my reference to Carroll and Kafka.... I am very confused about your point of FRBR/RDA. It does NOT decide that a movie is the same work as the book it's based on -- just like AACR2. You think this was the wrong choice, or the right choice? Regardless, if the point is just deal with it as it is, the important thing is to recognize it makes the same choice here about movies and books as AACR2 did. AACR2 didn't talk about it explicitly in terms of "work", FRBR adds a clear data modelling vocabulary -- to the same choice AACR2 was making, in this case. So what's your point exactly?

