However, you will find her as a 700.

**************************************
**************************************
Aleta Copeland, MLS
Head of Technical Services
Ouachita Parish Public Library
1800 Stubbs Ave.
Monroe, LA 71201
318-327-1490 ex. 3015

-----Original Message-----
From: Resource Description and Access / Resource Description and Access
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Kathleen Lamantia
Sent: Friday, April 08, 2011 10:08 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [RDA-L] FRBR

You will not find "Austen, Jane 1775-1817" as the 'main entry' on any AACR2
record for a movie version of Pride and Prejudice. - Yes, of course, that's
exactly my point about FRBR/RDA

Kathleen F. Lamantia, MLIS
Technical Services Librarian
Stark County District Library
715 Market Avenue North
Canton, OH 44702
330-458-2723
[email protected]
Inspiring Ideas  Enriching Lives  Creating Community
The Stark County District Library is a winner of the National Medal for
library service, is one of the best 100 libraries in the U.S. according to
the HAPLR rating, and is a Library Journal 5 Star library. 

 


-----Original Message-----
From: Jonathan Rochkind [mailto:[email protected]] 
Sent: Friday, April 08, 2011 11:02 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [RDA-L] FRBR

> Well, it seems to me that Pride and Prejudice is Jane Austen's conception
(work) no matter what form (expression)
> it takes, so I would answer your 2nd question, "is the creator the same?"
with yes.  As to valid alternatives,
> that seems to me to be "cataloger's judgment," so we are left with a
situation in which book and movie will 
> or will not be the same work depending on perception - and that's no way
to run a railroad.

Again, all I can say is that this is not the decision that AACR2 or
historical anglo-american cataloging makes, and FRBR/RDA bases itself off of
anglo-american cataloging tradition. 

You will not find "Austen, Jane 1775-1817" as the 'main entry' on any AACR2
record for a movie version of Pride and Prejudice. 

There are probably reasons that anglo-american cataloging does this, that
people could talk about.  It's a choice.  You're right that we want to be
consistent to 'run a railroad', even though some people might consider the
movie version the same work and some people might not.  So we have to make a
choice. 

The purpose of the FRBR data model is to be explicit about our data
modelling, so we can record our data in a way that software can have access
to semantics to provide flexible interfaces to meet user needs.  The Group 1
W-E-M-I set is NOT the only semantics in data modelled according to FRBR,
and if the movie work is appropriately related to the original text work,
interfaces can still choose to present that relationship to the user in
various ways. If they were simply modelled as the same work, interfaces
would be unable to make that choice, interfaces would HAVE to present them
as "the same". That's another way to look at the "run a railroad issue" --
we need to model our data the same to share it, even though users have
different needs in different contexts. So we should model it with maximum
flexibility for eventual display, by modelling that work A is textual, work
B is a movie, and work B is an adaptation or work A.  That's more
information than simply saying Expression A (movie) and Expression B (text)
are "the same work". 

Reply via email to