> Igor, as you said, you spend a lot of time thinking about this stuff:
> what would you say the general rule is?
> 
> -greg

Oh, I'm certainly not getting into a flame war about the correct way to
depict stereochemistry!!! :) I've seen people far more knowledgeable
than me having arguments about this until these days at the InChI
steering committee meeting. This is probably an argument that has been
going on for decades with no resolution.

I'm interested in the subject only insofar as it relates to my Optical
Structure Recognition Application (OSRA) - and I've certainly seen all
kinds of drawing styles. While some of them are quite likely
unconventional or even incorrect, OSRA should be able to recognize them
and should be allowed to produce output SDF or SMILES that match the
input drawing as closely as possible. So for me the best resolution
would be to allow the programmer (in python or c++) to create the
molecular object the way he sees fit and not to force him to adhere to
an arbitrary limitation.

Igor


Reply via email to