On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 5:27 PM, Igor Filippov<[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> Igor, as you said, you spend a lot of time thinking about this stuff:
>> what would you say the general rule is?
>>
>> -greg
>
> Oh, I'm certainly not getting into a flame war about the correct way to
> depict stereochemistry!!! :) I've seen people far more knowledgeable
> than me having arguments about this until these days at the InChI
> steering committee meeting. This is probably an argument that has been
> going on for decades with no resolution.

Ah, you're no fun. ;-)

> input drawing as closely as possible. So for me the best resolution
> would be to allow the programmer (in python or c++) to create the
> molecular object the way he sees fit and not to force him to adhere to
> an arbitrary limitation.

Agreed. And this is how the RDKit handles it: if you use
WedgeMolBonds() it does things "my" way (=one wedged bond per chiral
center), but you are always free to add additional wedging in your own
code.

-greg

Reply via email to