>>>>> "D" == Derek Balling <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:

>> > Um... AmigaOS contained a window system, user interface, applets,
>> and > system tools.

D> No it didn't. My AmigaOS system booted fine and multi-tasked nicely
D> without screwing around with the GUI. (Well, one of them did, the
D> other I used the GUI on). It was, therefore, not part of the OS,
D> but an application that ran on top of the OS.

You either don't know much about your Amiga, or you didn't read what I
said.

The Amiga OS contains a window system.  You used it.  (Trust me,
you couldn't avoid using it.  Even booting without a workbench or
startup sequence, you were in a windowed UI with one big window and
some gadgets on the background screen and on the main window.)

The Amiga OS contained a UI.  In fact, it contained more than one.
You were using the CLI.  (Command Line Interface).  That's a user
interface.  

You were also using the GUI, but using it with one big window with text
inside it.  On the Amiga OS, the kernel would have probably been the
Exec.  Are you asserting that all the rest of the stuff on the OS 2.04
disks and in the OS 2.04 ROM aren't part of the operating system?


D> The SunOS boxes in my office don't use a GUI. Are they not using
D> any Operating System?

You are using a user interface, if not a graphical one.  Does anyone
ever telnet in?  Do people ever use the shell?

D> Because by the definition of an operating system,

That's _exactly_ what we're discussing here.  I'm saying your
definition has absolutely no basis in reality.  Please quote me
someone who says that the OS equals the kernel and nothing more.

Remember: "system"=="many programs".  


-- 
Alan Shutko <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> - By consent of the corrupted
Anyone can make an omelet with eggs.  The trick is to make one with none.


-- 
  PLEASE read the Red Hat FAQ, Tips, Errata and the MAILING LIST ARCHIVES!
http://www.redhat.com/RedHat-FAQ /RedHat-Errata /RedHat-Tips /mailing-lists
         To unsubscribe: mail [EMAIL PROTECTED] with 
                       "unsubscribe" as the Subject.

Reply via email to