On Sat, 2003-01-04 at 05:55, Ed Wilts wrote:
> On Sat, Jan 04, 2003 at 03:05:10AM -0600, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> 
> > There is nothing in the GPL that treats providing source code on a website
> > as an exception to providing a written offer at the time of distribution
> > of GPL covered packages on CD-ROM media provided only in binary format.
> > The distributor must provide the written notice in addition to providing
> > the source code.
> 
> I believe that both Cliff and I conceded that point - the written offer
> does not seem to have been made and therefore there is a license
> violation.

I still question whether they left it out or not (or rather, what
qualifies as a written offer).  As I pointed out to "fluke", I believe
every package installed has a directory in /usr/share/doc which
typically includes the README file from the original authors.  Each of
these typically has instructions for downloading the most recent version
of the source.  Again, IANAL, but that could be argued to have been
enough to satisfy GPL requirements.

> However, both Cliff and I also argued that nowhere in the GPL does it
> say that the offer for a CD-ROM must be made - just a software medium.
> If the written offer is for the user to download the sources from their
> FTP site, Red Hat may (IANAL) be compliant.
> 
> > But for purposes of this thread lets get back to if leaving out both the
> > source code and written notice for over 50% of 2002 is acceptable behavior
> > from a self-proclaimed friend to Free Software and "Open Source."  Is it
> 
> They've left out the written notice.  I'm not convinced they've left out
> the source code requirement.
> 
> Feel free to pursue this issue with Red Hat's legal department.  They
> must provide the written offer to be compliant with the GPL.  

I doubt "fluke" has much of a case anyway, unless he's the author of
some package included by RedHat.

It seems that the crux of fluke's argument is that

1.  They left out the written notice.
2.  When notified, they waited half a year to fix it.

As you say, I *might* be willing to concede 1).  However, I'm not sure
where we can be certain of 2).  Even supposing that we can verify that
the Dell systems shipped for the entire year did not have this notice,
how can anyone be sure whether this is Redhat's or Dell's fault? 
Granted, RH acknowledged the error, but the lack of change in shipped
systems doesn't necessarily mean that they didn't respond immediately. 
Redhat may have immediately notified Dell and provided said notices and
Dell may have disregarded them or put them off.  I can easily see how
this could happen as the errata would have probably required Dell to
repackage a lot of inventory.

Anyway, I suspect we've both been eaten by a troll <wink>.

-- 
Cliff Wells, Software Engineer
Logiplex Corporation (www.logiplex.net)
(503) 978-6726 x308  (800) 735-0555 x308

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part

Reply via email to