Just before Tony went to work, Greg THomas wrote:
>> 2. The inefficient (eg response code 200) mail transfer
>> dialogue means that there is not that much difference in
overall
> >connection time between a html and non-html mail.
>
>What are you talking about? The messages are almost twice the
size.
>Multiply that by the number of messages on some high-volume lists
and you
>get considerable additional d/l times!
>
Hi Greg, I rarely say something contraversial without checking.
1. The mail transfer dialog does not take place on every line -
see the RFCs.
2. The delays in waiting for a 200-type response from the ISP
frequently exceed the transfer time of the message body for a
PC-Modem-ISP sort of link. Particularly if the message is
typical - 2 to 6k. See my comment at the bottom.
3. On the list-server situation you mention you are talking has
two scenarios.
One is where the list of recipients is, say 200k and the message
body is 2-6K. The issue of html mail is therefore not applicable
here. The extra traffic generated by doubling the size of the
message is, to borrow a phrase from elsewhere on this thread,
about as significant as a fart in a tornado. Email traffic
compared with web traffic is similarly a fart in a tornado. So we
have a fart in a tornado which is itself a fart in a tornado.
The second scenario is where the list-server generates multiple
messages, one for each recipient. Apart from being ripe for
upgrade to a decent system, the situation is not relevent as we
are talking about traffic that is not modem based (I hope!), and
as said before, email traffic does not even register on the
Internet needle.
4. The most common query about time to transfer html mail really
applies to PC-modem-ISP situations. In this situation, with a
decent modem the delays in the 200-type response to the ISP can be
significant, and exceed the transfer time of the mail inthe
message body - especially when compression is on and the message
is of typical size. I have the timings on a 24k modem. I was
concerned about the time taken to transfer mail to certain ISPs
when writing some SMPT software. I tried several ISPs and found
similar responses. Do you want the timings? Out of interest I did
it again on a 1200 bps connection and found that without
compression the time taken to transfer a 4k message was just about
the same as transferring the message header - because of the
200-type dialogue.
Kind regards
Tony Wells
Phenomenal Books
"I have made this letter longer than usual because I lack the
time to make it shorter" - Blaise Pascal.
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
bookstuff: www.phenomenal-books.com
anyotherstuff: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Intnl tel/fax: +44 1524 845559
UK tel/fax: 01524845559
Mobile: (+44) (0) 370 963410
-----Original Message-----
From: Greg Thomas <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: Tony Wells <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: Friday, June 26, 1998 5:21 AM
Subject: Re: HTML-formatted mail
--
PLEASE read the Red Hat FAQ, Tips, Errata and the MAILING LIST ARCHIVES!
http://www.redhat.com/RedHat-FAQ /RedHat-Errata /RedHat-Tips /mailing-lists
To unsubscribe: mail [EMAIL PROTECTED] with
"unsubscribe" as the Subject.