On Thu, Dec 23, 1999 at 08:21:13PM -0500, Jerry Winegarden wrote:
> 
> I had surmised that I could possibly talk them into an external.  I also
> checked out the modem manufacturer's page (where they admit they don't
> have a driver, but ask if anyone's done it yet) and noticed that they
> make an external version, too.  One option may be to purchase an 
> external, since it might be compatible with what's on the other end.
> (Are the ADSL specs clear enough that it won't matter whose box you
> use?)

Bellsouth is now using 3 different protocols for ADSL: the most common
is bridged DHCP, but are moving to PPPoE and PPPoA in some markets.
You will *need* to know this first. I don't think you have a choice on
this. At the very least, you have to cancel existing service and then
re-sign. The device is important in this regard. Check at:

 http://navasgrp.home.att.net/tech/cable_dsl.htm
 http://www.dslreports.com/

for info on various devices, or someone in the newsgroup would
probably know.
 
> I had also surmised that it might be possible to get someone to write a 
> driver (with the right incentive), especially since it sounds like the
> company,Efficient Networks (efficient.com) , might be forthcoming with the 
> specs, if they are looking for someone to do it.
> 
> I'm just looking forward to the connection!  I'll get it done somehow,
> since it's definitely worth it!  

Very nice indeed!
 
> As far as the motivation for internal cards goes:
>       I think that the support issues might be worse than the garbage
> traffic.  In the case of an external, I know that GTE says:  "If the
> three lights [on the external modem] are on, then the circuit is working,
> so the problem is with your machine(s).  How is this accomplished with
> an internal?  Since both the card AND the driver AND the computer's OS
> must be functioning properly, how can you tell?  How can you divorce
> the hardware from host pc's software?  (Or is this some sort of trade
> secret? :-)  How to avoid finger pointing?

I didn't say I agree with this, but this is the rationale. I don't know
how they troubleshoot this with the internal. Probably thru some
Windowsism. I've always preferred external modems for the reasons you
mention. Easy to see whether what its doing. Mine (Alactel 1000) has
an off switch too. BTW, they won't help you much if you are running
Linux. They don't object, but are not trained for it. On the other
side of it, there are a lot with it connected to a hub. I get a lot of
that and it can be very annoying. I'd bet if I pull up tcpdump now
there's at least 5, if not 10, on my subnet like this. 

Good luck!

-- 
Hal B
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
--
            Linux helps those who help themselves


-- 
To unsubscribe: mail [EMAIL PROTECTED] with "unsubscribe"
as the Subject.

Reply via email to