Ceejay, you make an important point.  The Squeezebox is typically going
to display "ARTIST - TITLE - ALBUM".  But if ARTIST is used for the
soloist, then how do we know whose "Symphony No. 9" it is (well,
duh...but not all examples will be so obvious).

Ceejay has enhancement requests to be able to browse the personnel tags
six ways from Sunday, but the question of what to display remains open.

I think that clearly the composer should be shown along with the title
of the work, and the movement.  But we may want to know who the
top-billed performer is, as well -- either the conductor or the
soloist.  So just to throw an idea out there, which may be excessively
complicated:

COMPOSER(artist) - TITLE -[ PART -] ARTIST(album)
or
COMPOSER(artist) - TITLE -[ PART -][ ARTIST -] ALBUM

Values in () are used if the preceding tag is empty, values in [] are
only displayed if the tag exists.  That should give you normal pop
music behavior for tracks without the classical tags, or the desired
classical music display when those tags are present.  

The downside of this scheme is that sometimes pop music does include
the COMPOSER tags.  One track of an album by The Police may have
COMPOSER=Sting, and another may have COMPOSER=A. Summers.  

As for how to add a symphony to the playlist, it would be nice if
slimserver could treat sequential tracks with the same TITLE as a unit.
Instead of the browse tree looking like

ALBUM->TRACK

it could look like

ALBUM->TITLE(->PART)

With the TITLEs sorted in track order.


-- 
John Stimson
------------------------------------------------------------------------
John Stimson's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=218
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=20850

_______________________________________________
ripping mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/ripping

Reply via email to