Re: [arr] Lip Sincying

2008-07-28 Thread Rajesh K B 
yes it is true ..just listen to the music carefully.. it will be just the
same as original.. even the whispers u can hear .. it is very hard to
reproduce the original music in a stage..





On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 4:17 PM, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

  Hi,

 Some of my friends pointed out that ARR and some of the other singers do
 Lip syncying for some songs in the Live concert .For eg: Toronto .

 Is this true ?

 Thanks
 Jamshid

Re: [arr] Lip Sincying

2008-07-28 Thread Gomzy 
I am not sure about the center vocals. But yes, the main music ( the samples
and loops) are used
from from records, but instruments like guitars,flute,violins and other
major instruments are Live.
Some of us have been to many of his concerts and we are sure the singing was
Live ( not sure of Toronto though)


On 7/28/08, Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

yes it is true ..just listen to the music carefully.. it will be just
 the same as original.. even the whispers u can hear .. it is very hard to
 reproduce the original music in a stage..





 On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 4:17 PM, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

  Hi,

 Some of my friends pointed out that ARR and some of the other singers do
 Lip syncying for some songs in the Live concert .For eg: Toronto .

 Is this true ?

 Thanks
 Jamshid

Re: [arr] Lip Sincying

2008-07-28 Thread jamshid TC 
But doesn't it make the live singing on the stage to just mere acting, which 
can be done by anybody who sync the lip well for the song ?
 
would the public goto watch the live if they know this beforehand ? I feel bad 
if ARR live shows has this kind of singing.
 
-Jamshid

--- On Sun, 7/27/08, Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

From: Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Lip Sincying
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Sunday, July 27, 2008, 10:44 PM








yes it is true ..just listen to the music carefully.. it will be just the same 
as original.. even the whispers u can hear .. it is very hard to reproduce the 
original music in a stage..
 
 


 
On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 4:17 PM, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote:











Hi,
 
Some of my friends pointed out that ARR and some of the other singers do Lip 
syncying for some songs in the Live concert .For eg: Toronto . 
 
Is this true ? 
 
Thanks
Jamshid

Re: [arr] Lip Sincying

2008-07-28 Thread Gomzy 
Like I said, most of us who are regulars at concerts do not agree. Singing
is LIVE at ARR concerts.
There might be small additional recorded vocals, but NO lip syncing has
happened that we are aware of.


On 7/28/08, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

  But doesn't it make the live singing on the stage to just mere
 acting, which can be done by anybody who sync the lip well for the song ?

 would the public goto watch the live if they know this beforehand ? I feel
 bad if ARR live shows has this kind of singing.

 -Jamshid

 --- On *Sun, 7/27/08, Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED]* wrote:


 From: Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Subject: Re: [arr] Lip Sincying
 To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
 Date: Sunday, July 27, 2008, 10:44 PM

   yes it is true ..just listen to the music carefully.. it will be just
 the same as original.. even the whispers u can hear .. it is very hard to
 reproduce the original music in a stage..





 On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 4:17 PM, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] com[EMAIL 
 PROTECTED]
  wrote:

  Hi,

 Some of my friends pointed out that ARR and some of the other singers do
 Lip syncying for some songs in the Live concert .For eg: Toronto .

 Is this true ?

 Thanks
 Jamshid

Re: [arr] Lip Sincying

2008-07-28 Thread jamshid TC 
Thanks Gomzy for confirming this.. I have been to only one concert ( Bangalore) 
before of Rahman. and i felt its difficult to identify the lip syncing from 
that closeness. But that time i was never heard of anything called Lip 
syncing . and i never bothered. 
 
But after these allegations, i started being a bit skeptical about it and was 
wondering whether they are doing some mixing of of the original and the live 
voice in the concert for a few songs..for eg: Dil se re in LA ( towards the end 
i felt rahman's voice changed) . 
same for pachai nirame by hari haran..
 
I always observed people struggling to perform a Rahman Song in live 
orchestra.May be i doubted this to be true for Rahman himself :-)
 
Thanks
Jamshid

--- On Mon, 7/28/08, Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

From: Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Lip Sincying
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Monday, July 28, 2008, 3:34 AM







Like I said, most of us who are regulars at concerts do not agree. Singing is 
LIVE at ARR concerts.
There might be small additional recorded vocals, but NO lip syncing has 
happened that we are aware of.

 
On 7/28/08, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote: 










But doesn't it make the live singing on the stage to just mere acting, which 
can be done by anybody who sync the lip well for the song ?
 
would the public goto watch the live if they know this beforehand ? I feel bad 
if ARR live shows has this kind of singing.
 
-Jamshid

--- On Sun, 7/27/08, Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote:
 
From: Rajesh K B [EMAIL PROTECTED] com
Subject: Re: [arr] Lip Sincying
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Sunday, July 27, 2008, 10:44 PM






yes it is true ..just listen to the music carefully.. it will be just the same 
as original.. even the whispers u can hear .. it is very hard to reproduce the 
original music in a stage..
 
 


 
On Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 4:17 PM, jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote:











Hi,
 
Some of my friends pointed out that ARR and some of the other singers do Lip 
syncying for some songs in the Live concert .For eg: Toronto . 
 
Is this true ? 
 
Thanks
Jamshid