Re: Larry Lessig on ending anonymity through "identity escrow"

2003-12-08 Thread Declan McCullagh
On Sat, Dec 06, 2003 at 01:59:26PM -0800, Tim May wrote: > This actually fits in with something Lessig is widely known for, his > "technology-custom-law" trichotomy (*). > > (* He may call it something different...I haven't checked in a while. I was reading some of David Friedman's articles ove

Re: Larry Lessig on ending anonymity through "identity escrow"

2003-12-07 Thread Tim May
On Dec 5, 2003, at 3:53 PM, Tim May wrote: Back to the cost issue. Prof. Lessig argues that voluntary identity escrow systems should be "encouraged." How/ Through nattering to people about how they ought to use a more expensive, less flexible system which exposes them to possible danger and whic

Re: Larry Lessig on ending anonymity through "identity escrow"

2003-12-07 Thread Bill Stewart
I think Declan's got the title wrong - Lessig's discussions that he references aren't about ending anonymity through escrowed pseudonymity - they're about replacing some True-Name-based or linkable applications with pseudonymous ones. For instance, one-use credit card numbers instead of regular nu

Re: Larry Lessig on ending anonymity through "identity escrow"

2003-12-07 Thread Tim May
On Dec 5, 2003, at 5:53 PM, Jamie Lawrence wrote: I have nothing against Lessig, but it bugs me that he's considered by some to be one of the Great Cyberspace Thinkers when his ideas are so easily dismissed...and were argued on both sides so many years ago. Larry Lessig ought to read, and think d

Re: Larry Lessig on ending anonymity through "identity escrow"

2003-12-07 Thread Tim May
DO NOT FORWARD THIS MESSAGE TO ANY OTHER LISTS. I AM GETTING TIRED OF SEEING CYPHERPUNKS JUST BE THE DUMPING GROUND FOR STUFF FROM OTHER LISTS. In almost all foreseeable cases, a system which allows identity escrow _cost more_ than a system which does not. This is analogous to the increased co

Larry Lessig on ending anonymity through "identity escrow"

2003-12-05 Thread Declan McCullagh
See also: http://politechbot.com/pipermail/politech/2003-December/000268.html --- Date: Fri, 05 Dec 2003 09:12:16 -0500 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] From: Declan McCullagh <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Larry Lessig replies to Politech over limiting anonymity [fs][priv] --- [Why do I get the feeling that