[GOAL] Re: Where now for OA in the UK?

2013-11-28 Thread Friend, Fred
eposit model plus the automated request-a-copy-Button will work almost as well, despite Finch's Fool's Gold preference. If I sound weary of this folly, then I have successfully conveyed my sentiments… ;>) Stevan Am 27.11.2013 um 17:20 schrieb Friend, Fred mailto:f.fri...@ucl.ac.uk>

[GOAL] Where now for OA in the UK?

2013-11-27 Thread Friend, Fred
Three recent official documents have presented marginally different views of the future of OA in the UK: the Review of the 2012 Finch Report, the Government Response to the criticisms from Parliament's BIS Committee, and the RCUK's Response to the same Committee. Although all three documents (li

[GOAL] Re: [SCHOLCOMM] Big Deals, Big Macs and Consortial Licensing

2013-11-19 Thread Friend, Fred
Stevan's analysis of the way in which open access was developing alongside licensing is very important. We need to understand the way in which OA developed in order to avoid the kind of distortion of OA that emerges from time to time. I was also going through a time of fluid thinking at the same

[GOAL] Finch Report Review

2013-11-18 Thread Friend, Fred
As a taxpayer I read the 74-page "Review of progress in implementing the recommendations of the Finch Report" with interest, looking for evidence that those who recommend policy to HM Government are making their recommendations in a logical fashion and on the basis of available evidence. What I

[GOAL] Re: Elsevier Keeps Revising Its Double-Talk (But Remains Fully Green)

2013-09-25 Thread Friend, Fred
It is good that Stevan keeps an eye on publisher policies for us, and it is also good that Peter reminds us that universities do have the power to say "no" to publishers. Stevan is correct that the distinction Elsevier and other publishers attempt to draw between mandated and non-mandated self-a

[GOAL] Re: Disruption vs. Protection

2013-09-14 Thread Friend, Fred
This is an excellent contribution from Danny Kingsley, and it would be interesting to have some real information about subscription loss from publishers, and not only from the two publishers she mentions. Very occasionally we do hear stories about a few journals ceasing publication, but the num

[GOAL] Re: [sparc-oaforum] Some Reflection from Wellcome Would Be Welcome

2013-09-11 Thread Friend, Fred
Communication UCL From: Peter Morgan Sent: 11 September 2013 09:54 To: Friend, Fred; Global Open Access List (Successor of AmSci) Subject: RE: [GOAL] Re: [sparc-oaforum] Some Reflection from Wellcome Would Be Welcome Fred, "the mistake came when they supp

[GOAL] Re: [sparc-oaforum] Some Reflection from Wellcome Would Be Welcome

2013-09-11 Thread Friend, Fred
Stevan explains the influence of the Wellcome upon OA policy very well. The Wellcome did an excellent job in making publications from its own researchers OA, but the mistake came when they supported the application of their own policies to taxpayer-funded research. They were over-influenced by p

[GOAL] Re: Gold OA infrastructure

2013-06-04 Thread Friend, Fred
The wide range of activities reported on the gold oa blog illustrate the priority now given to APC-funded gold OA by Government and other Establishment agencies in the UK, and the second-class status being given to repositories and other green OA developments by those same agencies. After many p

[GOAL] The direction of travel for open access in the UK

2013-03-09 Thread Friend, Fred
Open access in the UK is coming to a crossroads. Pointing in one direction are members of the political and scientific Establishment, working hard to convince the UK research community that a preference for APC-paid open access is the way to go, while wishing to travel down another road to open

[GOAL] An open access allegory

2013-03-08 Thread Friend, Fred
A small bird sat on a fence looking out over a landscape with which she was not familiar, looking for the rich pickings she had been told were to be found there. Around her on the fence were a number of other small birds who knew the landscape well and who knew where to find the rich pickings wi