[abcusers] Re: 8.3. Accidental directives

2003-07-31 Thread Bryancreer
From Irwin's standard -

 8.3. Accidental directives
 %%propagate-accidentals not | octave | pitch

 When set to not, accidentals apply only to the note
 they're attached to. When set to octave, accidentals
 also apply to all the notes of the same pitch in the
 same octave up to the end of the bar. When set to
 pitch, accidentals also apply to all the notes of the
 same pitch in all octaves up to the end of the bar.

 The default value is pitch.


 but as Richard Robinson points our elsewhere -

All these %%whatever usages are
based on the point that the first character makes it a comment, and thus
anything behind that will be ignored by any ABC application unless it takes
the trouble specifically to look for it.

If this one is ignored, it will affect the playback of tunes. It is a necessary function but it should be part of the abc standard not part of the stylesheet specification.

Bryan Creer






Re: [abcusers] Re: 8.3. Accidental directives

2003-07-31 Thread Richard Robinson
On Thu, Jul 31, 2003 at 01:11:04PM -0400, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 From Irwin's standard -
 
  8.3. Accidental directives
  %%propagate-accidentals not | octave | pitch
 
  When set to not, accidentals apply only to the note
  they're attached to. When set to octave, accidentals
  also apply to all the notes of the same pitch in the
  same octave up to the end of the bar. When set to
  pitch, accidentals also apply to all the notes of the
  same pitch in all octaves up to the end of the bar.
 
  The default value is pitch.
 
 
but as Richard Robinson points our elsewhere -
 
 All these %%whatever usages are
 based on the point that the first character makes it a comment, and thus
 anything behind that will be ignored by any ABC application unless it takes
 the trouble specifically to look for it.
 
 If this one is ignored, it will affect the playback of tunes.  It is a 
 necessary function but it should be part of the abc standard not part of the 
 stylesheet specification.

That's my point about trying to get organised namespaces for these
things. We need a coherent way of organising all the magic words so
that people, and software, can see what sort of things they apply to
and when they can safely be ignored. (And I suppose some of those
spaces should be in the standard, and others off somewhere quieter).

-- 
Richard Robinson
The whole plan hinged upon the natural curiosity of potatoes - S. Lem
To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html