Re: DIS: Agora XX: 5th report
-- Rule 306 (Mutable) A player may transfer . to another player by posting to that effect on the mailing list. History: Enacted by Proposal 306 (omd), Jun. 21 2013 -- I transfer 25 points from omd to FSX. I transfer 20 points from Walker to Yally. I transfer 20 points from Chuck to Michael. I transfer 20 points from ehird to scshunt. I transfer 10 points from myself to Murphy. -Goethe.
Re: DIS: Agora XX: 5th report
On Fri, Jun 21, 2013 at 3:07 PM, Kerim Aydin ke...@u.washington.edu wrote: I transfer 25 points from omd to FSX. I transfer 20 points from Walker to Yally. I transfer 20 points from Chuck to Michael. I transfer 20 points from ehird to scshunt. I transfer 10 points from myself to Murphy. -Goethe. I invoke judgement on whether Rule 304 had the power to repeal itself without that rule change being voted on. I think that all rule changes must be voted on and cannot occur automatically. I propose the following amendment to Rule 306: A player may transfer points to another player by posting to that effect on the mailing list. When this amendment is adopted, for each transfer away from the points' owner by another player since this proposal was submitted, that transfer is reversed if possible. -scshunt
Re: DIS: Agora XX: 5th report
On Fri, Jun 21, 2013 at 12:14 PM, Sean Hunt scsh...@csclub.uwaterloo.ca wrote: On Fri, Jun 21, 2013 at 3:07 PM, Kerim Aydin ke...@u.washington.edu wrote: I transfer 25 points from omd to FSX. I transfer 20 points from Walker to Yally. I transfer 20 points from Chuck to Michael. I transfer 20 points from ehird to scshunt. I transfer 10 points from myself to Murphy. -Goethe. I invoke judgement on whether Rule 304 had the power to repeal itself without that rule change being voted on. I think that all rule changes must be voted on and cannot occur automatically. I propose the following amendment to Rule 306: A player may transfer points to another player by posting to that effect on the mailing list. When this amendment is adopted, for each transfer away from the points' owner by another player since this proposal was submitted, that transfer is reversed if possible. -scshunt AGAINST
Re: DIS: Agora XX: 5th report
On Fri, 21 Jun 2013, Aaron Goldfein wrote: I propose the following amendment to Rule 306: A player may transfer points to another player by posting to that effect on the mailing list. When this amendment is adopted, for each transfer away from the points' owner by another player since this proposal was submitted, that transfer is reversed if possible. -scshunt I vote AGAINST this. (This doesn't actually fix the bug, btw, and the second part of the bug was possible negative points). -Goethe
Re: DIS: Agora XX: 5th report
On Fri, Jun 21, 2013 at 12:19 PM, Kerim Aydin ke...@u.washington.edu wrote: On Fri, 21 Jun 2013, Aaron Goldfein wrote: I propose the following amendment to Rule 306: A player may transfer points to another player by posting to that effect on the mailing list. When this amendment is adopted, for each transfer away from the points' owner by another player since this proposal was submitted, that transfer is reversed if possible. -scshunt I vote AGAINST this. (This doesn't actually fix the bug, btw, and the second part of the bug was possible negative points). -Goethe I also don't think it would even have the desired effect because you put stuff about this amendment into the text of a rule, which makes no sense.
Re: DIS: Agora XX: 5th report
On Fri, Jun 21, 2013 at 8:02 PM, comex com...@gmail.com wrote: On Friday, June 21, 2013, Kerim Aydin wrote: I vote AGAINST this. (This doesn't actually fix the bug, btw, and the second part of the bug was possible negative points). IMHO, only a moron in a hurry would interpret the wording as having either bug. I would invoke judgement on the matter, but I'm exhausted and about to run out of battery :) I invoke judgement on whether or not Goethe's transfers succeeded. -scshunt
