[arr] Re: Couples Retreat track for OSCARS...
Thanks Gayathri for your wonderful and detailed post.. We all can hope for more Awards to ARR Regards Yogesh Pune --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Gayathri Chandrakasan wrote: > > Not necessarily...although we do see most of the popular movies making it to > the nomination lists, but more often than not, it's the dark horses that end > up sweeping the awards! > > It's also the same case with bollywood or most film industries for that > matter. Not all films are nominated based on their popularity or success at > the box-office. If I'm not wrong, a number of our group members had earlier > on expressed their fears that Delhi6 music might not be nominated for the > popular awards due to the film's failure at the box-office. Yuvraaj's failure > at the BO was quoted as one of the examples. > > Their fears are justifiable but there's no harm in hoping. Personally, I feel > that awards (esp music awards) are based more on the popularity of the songs > rather than the success of the film. Yuvraaj did have magical numbers but > were they as popular as all the other ARR's albums? I don't think so..and I > blame it all on the bad marketing of the album. When Subash Ghai did Taal > with ARR, there were immense marketing for the music album as it was their > first collaboration. Moreover, Taal was deemed to revive the careers of > Subash Ghai, Aishwarya Rai, and Akshaye Khanna who until then, had a string > of flops behind them. Therefore, though the movie was hardly watchable, it > was still declared a hit, all thanks to the success of the sensational songs. > > But in the case of Yuvraaj, there weren't much marketing done for the film or > the songs. Yes, we rave about the beauty of the songs here because we hv > heard and fell in love with each one of those numbers, but frankly speaking, > how many non-Rahman fans have actually sat and heard these songs? Not many > going by my guesses. So, I don't think it's apt to use Yuvraaj as a yardstick > in this case. > > Delhi6 was different...the film didn't do well in the BO but the songs have > been garnered with praises from the public (ARR's fan and otherwise). Rehna > Tu & Maasakali were regularly played in all the major radio stations (mainly > due to the repeated request of the listeners). > > If anything, kindly remember that Dilse's ill-fate at the BO in 1998 didn't > seem to affect the popularity of the songs. ARR even went on to win a > filmfare award for the the best music that year. A similar situation might > occur here too. > > Therefore there's no harm in hoping that ARR might bag another award for > Delhi6. Keep your fingers crossed for Delhi6...and CR too:) > > --- On Tue, 9/29/09, yogesh2783 wrote: > > From: yogesh2783 > Subject: [arr] Re: Couples Retreat track for OSCARS... > To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com > Date: Tuesday, September 29, 2009, 10:46 PM > > > > > > > > > > > > > I am having a query..does nomination for Academy Award for > original score depends upon fate of movie [like in bollywood]? > > anyway ,AR deserves another Oscar for CR. > > > > Regards > > Yogesh > > Pune > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "Rivjot" wrote: > > > > > > PLEASE!!! At least wait for movie to come out before making such > > statements. > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Tamiliniyan wrote: > > > > > > > > http://www.cinefund as.com/2009/ 09/25/couples- retreat-music- review > > > > I have a strong feeling that ARR will win oscar next year for his CR > > > scores ... > > > > Yeah..~!~!!! !!! > > > > > > > >
Re: [arr] Re: Couples Retreat track for OSCARS...
Not necessarily...although we do see most of the popular movies making it to the nomination lists, but more often than not, it's the dark horses that end up sweeping the awards! It's also the same case with bollywood or most film industries for that matter. Not all films are nominated based on their popularity or success at the box-office. If I'm not wrong, a number of our group members had earlier on expressed their fears that Delhi6 music might not be nominated for the popular awards due to the film's failure at the box-office. Yuvraaj's failure at the BO was quoted as one of the examples. Their fears are justifiable but there's no harm in hoping. Personally, I feel that awards (esp music awards) are based more on the popularity of the songs rather than the success of the film. Yuvraaj did have magical numbers but were they as popular as all the other ARR's albums? I don't think so..and I blame it all on the bad marketing of the album. When Subash Ghai did Taal with ARR, there were immense marketing for the music album as it was their first collaboration. Moreover, Taal was deemed to revive the careers of Subash Ghai, Aishwarya Rai, and Akshaye Khanna who until then, had a string of flops behind them. Therefore, though the movie was hardly watchable, it was still declared a hit, all thanks to the success of the sensational songs. But in the case of Yuvraaj, there weren't much marketing done for the film or the songs. Yes, we rave about the beauty of the songs here because we hv heard and fell in love with each one of those numbers, but frankly speaking, how many non-Rahman fans have actually sat and heard these songs? Not many going by my guesses. So, I don't think it's apt to use Yuvraaj as a yardstick in this case. Delhi6 was different...the film didn't do well in the BO but the songs have been garnered with praises from the public (ARR's fan and otherwise). Rehna Tu & Maasakali were regularly played in all the major radio stations (mainly due to the repeated request of the listeners). If anything, kindly remember that Dilse's ill-fate at the BO in 1998 didn't seem to affect the popularity of the songs. ARR even went on to win a filmfare award for the the best music that year. A similar situation might occur here too. Therefore there's no harm in hoping that ARR might bag another award for Delhi6. Keep your fingers crossed for Delhi6...and CR too:) --- On Tue, 9/29/09, yogesh2783 wrote: From: yogesh2783 Subject: [arr] Re: Couples Retreat track for OSCARS... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, September 29, 2009, 10:46 PM I am having a query..does nomination for Academy Award for original score depends upon fate of movie [like in bollywood]? anyway ,AR deserves another Oscar for CR. Regards Yogesh Pune --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "Rivjot" wrote: > > PLEASE!!! At least wait for movie to come out before making such statements. > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Tamiliniyan wrote: > > > > http://www.cinefund as.com/2009/ 09/25/couples- retreat-music- review > > I have a strong feeling that ARR will win oscar next year for his CR scores > > ... > > Yeah..~!~!!! !!! > > >
[arr] Re: Couples Retreat track for OSCARS...
I am having a query..does nomination for Academy Award for original score depends upon fate of movie [like in bollywood]? anyway ,AR deserves another Oscar for CR. Regards Yogesh Pune --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "Rivjot" wrote: > > PLEASE!!! At least wait for movie to come out before making such statements. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Tamiliniyan wrote: > > > > http://www.cinefundas.com/2009/09/25/couples-retreat-music-review > > I have a strong feeling that ARR will win oscar next year for his CR scores > > ... > > Yeah..~!~!! > > >
[arr] Re: Couples Retreat track for OSCARS...
PLEASE!!! At least wait for movie to come out before making such statements. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Tamiliniyan wrote: > > http://www.cinefundas.com/2009/09/25/couples-retreat-music-review > I have a strong feeling that ARR will win oscar next year for his CR scores > ... > Yeah..~!~!! >
