[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
no need to be sarcastic and all guys the initial starting track of both the songs do sound similar... its funny some of u guys dun see it well, if it doesnt for u, its good for u then i must say. Enjoy the songs
Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
This kind of attitude is exactly why some people consider us as people with some sort of a superiority complex or ego. Every time someone says something about ARR copying, we take out our prowess on commercial loops, limited no.of raagas sort of stuff. And if that somehow doesn't work, we will resort to sarcasm. Deep within we know there is some sort of similarity for the songs, yet our ego doesn't allow us to accept that in public. What was the need to mock the discussion starter? There certainly is a similarity which even a deaf man will notice. Does that mean it is a copy? Not necessarily. And at any day I prefer JTYJN song to Bommarillu song. But you can't shut out facts with fake sacrcasm. And by the way, ask your 2 year old to listen to the song Staring at the Sun by U2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuuDjOzXMX0. I am sure he would say he never heard this kind of a song before, but I can assure you we heard the same pattern 2 years back in tamil. Does that mean it is a copy? Who cares, just enjoy the song. But don't ever mock someone for making a criticism that is true. Inman On Sat, May 24, 2008 at 3:21 AM, Pravinder Sheoran [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi (Whoever you are) Nice try man and nice finding. We appreciate your hard work. But i feel sorry for you, because even a 2 year child can tell after listing both songs that nothing is similar. But at least you listened to Rahman Saab's song carefully, which is great. Because unknowingly you did yourself a great favor. If it makes you happy, then we agree for your sake that the song was copied. Please keep listening to Rahman Saab's music carefully and let us know if you find out another such copying. Because people like you really help us in boosting our faith in Rahman Saab more and more every time. God bless you my friend. Pravinder. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, kisisq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
Dinesh,Inman, Sarcasm and all that apart, ARR has reused an interlude of mustafa mustafa as the Kabhi Kabhi song. Its funny some of you guys don't see it. On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 12:12 PM, Dinesh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: no need to be sarcastic and all guys the initial starting track of both the songs do sound similar... its funny some of u guys dun see it well, if it doesnt for u, its good for u then i must say. Enjoy the songs
[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
whoa man. hats of to u and they will mock u saying what r u doing in this group if u ever mentioned that there r similarity between the songs lol hope the people who behave such reads ur mail i couldnt have said it better. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Inman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This kind of attitude is exactly why some people consider us as people with some sort of a superiority complex or ego. Every time someone says something about ARR copying, we take out our prowess on commercial loops, limited no.of raagas sort of stuff. And if that somehow doesn't work, we will resort to sarcasm. Deep within we know there is some sort of similarity for the songs, yet our ego doesn't allow us to accept that in public. What was the need to mock the discussion starter? There certainly is a similarity which even a deaf man will notice. Does that mean it is a copy? Not necessarily. And at any day I prefer JTYJN song to Bommarillu song. But you can't shut out facts with fake sacrcasm. And by the way, ask your 2 year old to listen to the song Staring at the Sun by U2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuuDjOzXMX0. I am sure he would say he never heard this kind of a song before, but I can assure you we heard the same pattern 2 years back in tamil. Does that mean it is a copy? Who cares, just enjoy the song. But don't ever mock someone for making a criticism that is true. Inman On Sat, May 24, 2008 at 3:21 AM, Pravinder Sheoran [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi (Whoever you are) Nice try man and nice finding. We appreciate your hard work. But i feel sorry for you, because even a 2 year child can tell after listing both songs that nothing is similar. But at least you listened to Rahman Saab's song carefully, which is great. Because unknowingly you did yourself a great favor. If it makes you happy, then we agree for your sake that the song was copied. Please keep listening to Rahman Saab's music carefully and let us know if you find out another such copying. Because people like you really help us in boosting our faith in Rahman Saab more and more every time. God bless you my friend. Pravinder. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, kisisq kisisq@ wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
i guess we accept the similarities on discussion but our voice of concern for the usage of word copy, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu was the subject of this conversation which is ridiculous. On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 12:03 AM, Inman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: This kind of attitude is exactly why some people consider us as people with some sort of a superiority complex or ego. Every time someone says something about ARR copying, we take out our prowess on commercial loops, limited no.of raagas sort of stuff. And if that somehow doesn't work, we will resort to sarcasm. Deep within we know there is some sort of similarity for the songs, yet our ego doesn't allow us to accept that in public. What was the need to mock the discussion starter? There certainly is a similarity which even a deaf man will notice. Does that mean it is a copy? Not necessarily. And at any day I prefer JTYJN song to Bommarillu song. But you can't shut out facts with fake sacrcasm. And by the way, ask your 2 year old to listen to the song Staring at the Sun by U2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuuDjOzXMX0. I am sure he would say he never heard this kind of a song before, but I can assure you we heard the same pattern 2 years back in tamil. Does that mean it is a copy? Who cares, just enjoy the song. But don't ever mock someone for making a criticism that is true. Inman On Sat, May 24, 2008 at 3:21 AM, Pravinder Sheoran [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi (Whoever you are) Nice try man and nice finding. We appreciate your hard work. But i feel sorry for you, because even a 2 year child can tell after listing both songs that nothing is similar. But at least you listened to Rahman Saab's song carefully, which is great. Because unknowingly you did yourself a great favor. If it makes you happy, then we agree for your sake that the song was copied. Please keep listening to Rahman Saab's music carefully and let us know if you find out another such copying. Because people like you really help us in boosting our faith in Rahman Saab more and more every time. God bless you my friend. Pravinder. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, kisisq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
Thulasi too agreed it sounded similar lol yeaits not a copy, i agree. but the similarity is there NO DOUBT! and i do hope some members here do act matured by accepting facts and discuss it in main rather than sending me private mails... lol... we can alwiz discuss on ARR's songs here, whether Good or Bad, isnt it?? Or does this group only welcomes GOOD comments?? --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dinesh,Inman, Sarcasm and all that apart, ARR has reused an interlude of mustafa mustafa as the Kabhi Kabhi song. Its funny some of you guys don't see it. On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 12:12 PM, Dinesh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: no need to be sarcastic and all guys the initial starting track of both the songs do sound similar... its funny some of u guys dun see it well, if it doesnt for u, its good for u then i must say. Enjoy the songs
Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
Gomzy.. that was an interesting similarity posted by someone who mushroomed in our group jus for that post :) ok, coming to the point.. i see that similarity but not entirely. lets compare the interlude of mustafa mustafa and the flute piece that resonates in kabhi kabhi aditi song. one can notice that kabhi kabhi song was created with an increasing pitch whilst mustafa mustafa interlude could be considered as flat for comparison purposes. so, there is some difference if not entirely.. what say? On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 1:22 AM, Gomzy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Dinesh,Inman, Sarcasm and all that apart, ARR has reused an interlude of mustafa mustafa as the Kabhi Kabhi song. Its funny some of you guys don't see it. On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 12:12 PM, Dinesh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: no need to be sarcastic and all guys the initial starting track of both the songs do sound similar... its funny some of u guys dun see it well, if it doesnt for u, its good for u then i must say. Enjoy the songs
Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
PLZ STOP THIS TOPIC.AS A RAHMANIAC...WE ARE ENJOYING EACH OF HIS TUNES..AND PLZnbsp; SWITCH OVER.Tq --- On Sun, 5/25/08, Srinivasa Krishnan lt;[EMAIL PROTECTED]gt; wrote: From: Srinivasa Krishnan lt;[EMAIL PROTECTED]gt; Subject: Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, May 25, 2008, 2:57 AM yes.. pls stop this topic and switch over.. On 5/25/08, || V i s h w e s h || lt;[EMAIL PROTECTED] comgt; wrote: I think this thread is stretched long enough... pls move on now... --- Gomzy lt;gomtesh.upadhye@ gmail.comgt; wrote: gt; Dinesh,Inman, gt; gt; Sarcasm and all that apart, ARR has reused an gt; interlude of mustafa mustafa gt; as the Kabhi Kabhi song. gt; Its funny some of you guys don't see it. gt; gt; On Sun, May 25, 2008 at 12:12 PM, Dinesh gt; lt;dinesh.theboss@ hotmail.comgt; wrote: gt; gt; gt; no need to be sarcastic and all guys the gt; initial starting track of gt; gt; both the songs do sound similar... its funny some gt; of u guys dun see gt; gt; it well, if it doesnt for u, its good for u gt; then i must say. gt; gt; gt; gt; Enjoy the songs The search is more important than the destination - a r rahman - -- Regards, V SRINIVASA KRISHNAN
Re: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
he he...cute reply... - Original Message From: Pravinder Sheoran [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Friday, May 23, 2008 9:51:28 AM Subject: [arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE) Hi (Whoever you are) Nice try man and nice finding. We appreciate your hard work. But i feel sorry for you, because even a 2 year child can tell after listing both songs that nothing is similar. But at least you listened to Rahman Saab's song carefully, which is great. Because unknowingly you did yourself a great favor. If it makes you happy, then we agree for your sake that the song was copied. Please keep listening to Rahman Saab's music carefully and let us know if you find out another such copying. Because people like you really help us in boosting our faith in Rahman Saab more and more every time. God bless you my friend. Pravinder. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, kisisq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu (WE AGREE)
Hi (Whoever you are) Nice try man and nice finding. We appreciate your hard work. But i feel sorry for you, because even a 2 year child can tell after listing both songs that nothing is similar. But at least you listened to Rahman Saab's song carefully, which is great. Because unknowingly you did yourself a great favor. If it makes you happy, then we agree for your sake that the song was copied. Please keep listening to Rahman Saab's music carefully and let us know if you find out another such copying. Because people like you really help us in boosting our faith in Rahman Saab more and more every time. God bless you my friend. Pravinder. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, kisisq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu
exteremely funny ... are u trying to get noticed. if so..then u are successful with me. by the way i have heard a lot abt similarities between these two songs. I love appudo song from bommarillu . The similarity ends right after two words...mere two words..appudo ippudo thats it. and i saw someone here posting abt mustaffa song connection to kabhi kabhi. he is right...kabhi kabhi tune can be obeserved in mustaffa song. observe that song after 3:55.. now tell me who copied from whom.. i dont believe devi sri copied from rahman and the reverse is absolutely impossible. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, kisisq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu
The originator might find JTJN is also copied bcs both movies has Genelia D'Souza. if you have to say Aditi song is copied then pls have the Britts to rewrite the meaning of the word copied. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, sreekar8191986 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: exteremely funny ... are u trying to get noticed. if so..then u are successful with me. by the way i have heard a lot abt similarities between these two songs. I love appudo song from bommarillu . The similarity ends right after two words...mere two words..appudo ippudo thats it. and i saw someone here posting abt mustaffa song connection to kabhi kabhi. he is right...kabhi kabhi tune can be obeserved in mustaffa song. observe that song after 3:55.. now tell me who copied from whom.. i dont believe devi sri copied from rahman and the reverse is absolutely impossible. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, kisisq kisisq@ wrote: All Listen to Apudo Ipudo from Bomarillu, Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Zindagi is a direct lift. Disappointing KQ
[arr] Re: Kabhi Kabhi Aditi Copied from Bomarillu
i think the word DIRECT LIFT is alittle too much only the 1st line sounds similar.
