Re: [arr] Re: Somebody answer me this...
AR is the only person who can answer your question.All others will be bringing points against you..not the answer.. :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, up84mouli [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: Hi guys, I am gonna get deadly blastings in some replies to this mail but this question is never getting out of my head for quite few days. Thought I will ask you :-) Why does Rahman use Madhusree, Blaaze, Naresh Iyer, Udit Narayanan, Sukhwinder, and such singers who cannot render Tamil that much properly? Is it the lack of good Tamil singers? Is Rahman not aware that people are upset when they listen to such songs? Does Rahman have no choice? Are the producers demanding him to use M'sree, lots of English lyrics, Raps and all such (mostly) unnecessary stuff?? The only benefit I see here is that Rahman can maintain goodwill with that such producers who can give him more projects because if he rejects, they might cry foul and try to bring down his image. Or is it Rahman himself who does this because that is what others do?? Why doesn't he attempt something like this in Hindi? Why doesn't he take a Tamil singer who sings Regeta Hai instead of Rehta hai the proper way? Why cant he create a new style there? Is it because of the fear of producers or is it because Rahman respects Hindi language and bollywood more than kollywood?? Do reply. Thanks guys, Chandra. Connect with friends all over the world. Get Yahoo! India Messenger at http://in.messenger.yahoo.com/?wm=n/
Re: [arr] Re: Somebody answer me this...
hey well nice question but there is one thing when it comes to music not just the accent of the singer is important .. its also the way one sings .. in tamil he has used singers like madhushree udit etc who are not tamilians but yet they sing cos they are really good singers .. 2nd reason is ppl like us .. ie one who listens to these songs .. they appreciate the song and we enjoy .. so in a way wwe allow the singer to grow .. so when Rahman gets a project and he feels Madhushree's , udits or any other singer s style and voice would fit and they culd do justice he goes ahead with them or may be we never knoe whe may have asked some one else to sing and may not have been satisfied and only found it when these singers deliverd .. in hindi yes he can experiment .. and he has asked so many south based singers like SPB sir, Chitra etc to sing but if he has tried any singer who sings ';regatha hai for rehta hai hindi audience ll never encourgae like we do in tamil nadu where any slang of tamil is ok cos its not in Rahman songs we see that style even in others we see udit singing ,m shreya singing .. As for Blazee s rap he s a rap singer and i dont think he has restricted him only 4 tamil .. same with naresh iyer .. his paatshaala was also stylish in RDB .. hope my explanation s ok ! take care Rahman :) need not be always right but the thing is that certain things need to be done only by those ppl concered like choosing who has to sing etc .. and i guess even if Rahman had some other better choice to make for singers ... he has never made a rong choice .. every song has been a class in its own .. have i answered u ?? --- On Sat, 11/29/08, jemsheed [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: jemsheed [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [arr] Re: Somebody answer me this... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, November 29, 2008, 10:49 PM AR is the only person who can answer your question.All others will be bringing points against you..not the answer.. :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, up84mouli [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: Hi guys, I am gonna get deadly blastings in some replies to this mail but this question is never getting out of my head for quite few days. Thought I will ask you :-) Why does Rahman use Madhusree, Blaaze, Naresh Iyer, Udit Narayanan, Sukhwinder, and such singers who cannot render Tamil that much properly? Is it the lack of good Tamil singers? Is Rahman not aware that people are upset when they listen to such songs? Does Rahman have no choice? Are the producers demanding him to use M'sree, lots of English lyrics, Raps and all such (mostly) unnecessary stuff?? The only benefit I see here is that Rahman can maintain goodwill with that such producers who can give him more projects because if he rejects, they might cry foul and try to bring down his image. Or is it Rahman himself who does this because that is what others do?? Why doesn't he attempt something like this in Hindi? Why doesn't he take a Tamil singer who sings Regeta Hai instead of Rehta hai the proper way? Why cant he create a new style there? Is it because of the fear of producers or is it because Rahman respects Hindi language and bollywood more than kollywood?? Do reply. Thanks guys, Chandra. Connect with friends all over the world. Get Yahoo! India Messenger at http://in.messenger.yahoo.com/?wm=n/
[arr] Re: Somebody answer me this...
By the way, if any of you don't know, Udit Narayan is from Nepal. Hindi is not his first langauge. He is same for all of us, whether it is Tamil or Telugu or Marathi or Kannad or Hindi or whatever. Pravinder. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, my_arr [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Who said BlaaZe don't know how to speak Tamil? He can speak fluently.. It's much bigger picture actually than considering whether the singers know Tamil or not.. ARR appreciate the voice and singing skills than whether they know the language or not... You'll be amazed if you see how ARR trains the non-tamil singers to sing in Tamil..He's a perfectionist.. I don't think even the tamil die-hard can do what ARR does to ensure the singers get the words right... ARR is more concerned about getting his songs perfect than any of us.. Do you actually know how much of importance ARR has been giving to lyrics? It's unbelievable that a person who creates magical tunes manage to spend long hours to get the lyrics fit with the song... Am sure ARR knows which singer will suite the tunes.. Udit Narayan has also been singing in Telugu, Marathi, Kannada, Malayalam and other languages... Does it mean he cannot sing in those languages just because he is Hindi? There are also many Tamil singers did well in Hindi e.g Benny Dayal, Karthik, Srinivas and many others.. Why didn't you question on that? You must be proud that ARR has broken the language barriers and it's amazing to see the north and south Indian singers hanging around together during ARR's live tours without any differences... They are united under one banner.. MUSIC... You should appreciate that ARR has made the Hindi singers improving themselves as time goes on... Tamil is not an easy language... For those who mastered it because they are born Tamizhan, they don't find it hard (but some still struggling to speak properly)... It's a great thing when Hindi singers can actually sing in a language not only they don't understand but which is very hard for them.. How many of us speak the language perfectly by the way? Most of us are mixing our mother-tongue with EnglishAre we perfect enough to protect the language? Imagine Marudhani without Madhushree... ARR knows what he's doing.. my_arr --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, up84mouli up84mouli@ wrote: Hi guys, I am gonna get deadly blastings in some replies to this mail but this question is never getting out of my head for quite few days. Thought I will ask you :-) Why does Rahman use Madhusree, Blaaze, Naresh Iyer, Udit Narayanan, Sukhwinder, and such singers who cannot render Tamil that much properly? Is it the lack of good Tamil singers? Is Rahman not aware that people are upset when they listen to such songs? Does Rahman have no choice? Are the producers demanding him to use M'sree, lots of English lyrics, Raps and all such (mostly) unnecessary stuff?? The only benefit I see here is that Rahman can maintain goodwill with that such producers who can give him more projects because if he rejects, they might cry foul and try to bring down his image. Or is it Rahman himself who does this because that is what others do?? Why doesn't he attempt something like this in Hindi? Why doesn't he take a Tamil singer who sings Regeta Hai instead of Rehta hai the proper way? Why cant he create a new style there? Is it because of the fear of producers or is it because Rahman respects Hindi language and bollywood more than kollywood?? Do reply. Thanks guys, Chandra.
Re: [arr] Re: Somebody answer me this...
Hey My dear friend, I think Rahman doing right thing bcoz the singers u mentioned here is too good in their rendition with so much feeling that song demands. When u closely observe the singer's sound ,it is very different. Madhusree and Naresh Iyyer ,if u listen the song Mayilirega from Anbe Aryuire , you will not have doubts. Regarding Blaaze his roots are in Tamil. He is a rapper from Tamilnadu .Instead of using Baba Saigal from Hindi, he uses tAMIL Rapper. --- On Sun, 11/30/08, meena venkat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: meena venkat [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [arr] Re: Somebody answer me this... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, November 30, 2008, 12:32 AM hey well nice question but there is one thing when it comes to music not just the accent of the singer is important .. its also the way one sings .. in tamil he has used singers like madhushree udit etc who are not tamilians but yet they sing cos they are really good singers .. 2nd reason is ppl like us .. ie one who listens to these songs .. they appreciate the song and we enjoy .. so in a way wwe allow the singer to grow .. so when Rahman gets a project and he feels Madhushree's , udits or any other singer s style and voice would fit and they culd do justice he goes ahead with them or may be we never knoe whe may have asked some one else to sing and may not have been satisfied and only found it when these singers deliverd .. in hindi yes he can experiment .. and he has asked so many south based singers like SPB sir, Chitra etc to sing but if he has tried any singer who sings ';regatha hai for rehta hai hindi audience ll never encourgae like we do in tamil nadu where any slang of tamil is ok cos its not in Rahman songs we see that style even in others we see udit singing ,m shreya singing .. As for Blazee s rap he s a rap singer and i dont think he has restricted him only 4 tamil .. same with naresh iyer .. his paatshaala was also stylish in RDB .. hope my explanation s ok ! take care Rahman :) need not be always right but the thing is that certain things need to be done only by those ppl concered like choosing who has to sing etc .. and i guess even if Rahman had some other better choice to make for singers ... he has never made a rong choice .. every song has been a class in its own .. have i answered u ?? --- On Sat, 11/29/08, jemsheed [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: jemsheed [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [arr] Re: Somebody answer me this... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Saturday, November 29, 2008, 10:49 PM AR is the only person who can answer your question.All others will be bringing points against you..not the answer.. :) --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, up84mouli [EMAIL PROTECTED] .. wrote: Hi guys, I am gonna get deadly blastings in some replies to this mail but this question is never getting out of my head for quite few days. Thought I will ask you :-) Why does Rahman use Madhusree, Blaaze, Naresh Iyer, Udit Narayanan, Sukhwinder, and such singers who cannot render Tamil that much properly? Is it the lack of good Tamil singers? Is Rahman not aware that people are upset when they listen to such songs? Does Rahman have no choice? Are the producers demanding him to use M'sree, lots of English lyrics, Raps and all such (mostly) unnecessary stuff?? The only benefit I see here is that Rahman can maintain goodwill with that such producers who can give him more projects because if he rejects, they might cry foul and try to bring down his image. Or is it Rahman himself who does this because that is what others do?? Why doesn't he attempt something like this in Hindi? Why doesn't he take a Tamil singer who sings Regeta Hai instead of Rehta hai the proper way? Why cant he create a new style there? Is it because of the fear of producers or is it because Rahman respects Hindi language and bollywood more than kollywood?? Do reply. Thanks guys, Chandra. Connect with friends all over the world. Get Yahoo! India Messenger at http://in.messenger.yahoo.com/?wm=n/ Are you searching for a reason, to be kind? b Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Groups Links
[arr] Re: Somebody answer me this...
Who said BlaaZe don't know how to speak Tamil? He can speak fluently.. It's much bigger picture actually than considering whether the singers know Tamil or not.. ARR appreciate the voice and singing skills than whether they know the language or not... You'll be amazed if you see how ARR trains the non-tamil singers to sing in Tamil..He's a perfectionist.. I don't think even the tamil die-hard can do what ARR does to ensure the singers get the words right... ARR is more concerned about getting his songs perfect than any of us.. Do you actually know how much of importance ARR has been giving to lyrics? It's unbelievable that a person who creates magical tunes manage to spend long hours to get the lyrics fit with the song... Am sure ARR knows which singer will suite the tunes.. Udit Narayan has also been singing in Telugu, Marathi, Kannada, Malayalam and other languages... Does it mean he cannot sing in those languages just because he is Hindi? There are also many Tamil singers did well in Hindi e.g Benny Dayal, Karthik, Srinivas and many others.. Why didn't you question on that? You must be proud that ARR has broken the language barriers and it's amazing to see the north and south Indian singers hanging around together during ARR's live tours without any differences... They are united under one banner.. MUSIC... You should appreciate that ARR has made the Hindi singers improving themselves as time goes on... Tamil is not an easy language... For those who mastered it because they are born Tamizhan, they don't find it hard (but some still struggling to speak properly)... It's a great thing when Hindi singers can actually sing in a language not only they don't understand but which is very hard for them.. How many of us speak the language perfectly by the way? Most of us are mixing our mother-tongue with EnglishAre we perfect enough to protect the language? Imagine Marudhani without Madhushree... ARR knows what he's doing.. my_arr --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, up84mouli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi guys, I am gonna get deadly blastings in some replies to this mail but this question is never getting out of my head for quite few days. Thought I will ask you :-) Why does Rahman use Madhusree, Blaaze, Naresh Iyer, Udit Narayanan, Sukhwinder, and such singers who cannot render Tamil that much properly? Is it the lack of good Tamil singers? Is Rahman not aware that people are upset when they listen to such songs? Does Rahman have no choice? Are the producers demanding him to use M'sree, lots of English lyrics, Raps and all such (mostly) unnecessary stuff?? The only benefit I see here is that Rahman can maintain goodwill with that such producers who can give him more projects because if he rejects, they might cry foul and try to bring down his image. Or is it Rahman himself who does this because that is what others do?? Why doesn't he attempt something like this in Hindi? Why doesn't he take a Tamil singer who sings Regeta Hai instead of Rehta hai the proper way? Why cant he create a new style there? Is it because of the fear of producers or is it because Rahman respects Hindi language and bollywood more than kollywood?? Do reply. Thanks guys, Chandra.
