Re: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Guys,I am sorry for this extended focus on Tum Mile...but just wanted to
say..Tum Mile Reprise by Javed Ali...is a real gem guys! I just loved that
song
Pritam has done a good job indeed!
Anish
On Fri, Sep 25, 2009 at 3:36 PM, anvesh anveshred...@gmail.com wrote:
I didnt find Tum Mile to be as great. Its an OK album. As far as awards go,
no album this year is even nearer to Delhi 6 standard. So Delhi 6 is the
obvious winner for me.
Though there are other albums which have been brilliant as well. I
absolutely loved kaminey.
Dev D and Gulaal are also superb,. If i have to make a top5 list this year,
it would be
1. Delhi 6
2. Kaminey
3. Blue
4. Dev D
5. Gulaal
On Fri, Sep 25, 2009 at 5:16 PM, ichord purev...@yahoo.com wrote:
I never said I would be happy if Tum Mile won over D6. That's only your
interpretation. And yes, I didn't have D6 or any other ARR soundtrack in
mind. I never said I wish Pritam to win over ARR. I said that I would be
happy if Pritam won an award for any of his soundtracks this year, esp.
since he's never won an award before. Would I be disappointed if D6 or any
other ARR soundtrack lost? Yes. I don't know why you would question that.
Let's put this to rest. I'm tired of defending myself again and again over
the same thing when I don't need to. Your apologies are accepted and don't
worry yaar, with email, such misinterpretations happen all the time.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com,
Indmov Buff indmovb...@... wrote:
Chord, I don’t think my post was in response to what you
think “is a lack of blind devotion†or rather appreciation for other
composers. I’d like to think that I am also a fan of
good music and not blindly devoted Rahman’s only.  I’ve said it to
friends before and in this
forum too†I look forward to seeing SEL win at the awards someday. I
look forward
to seeing Amit Trivedi win someday and yes even Pritam (if he can stay
away
from other people’s property in the relevant soundtrack) and I’ll be
happy for
them too. What got my attention was that you’d particularly mentioned
“this yearâ€
which I think will automatically make anyone think of Pritam’s
contenders this
year and it broke my heart to think that you would be happy if Tum Mile
(which
you are yet to listen to) won over Delhi
6. But like you said, I am perhaps reading too much into it. You
probably didn’t
have Delhi 6 in
mind when you wrote “this year†. Apologies.Â
--- On Thu, 24/9/09, ichord purev...@... wrote:
From: ichord purev...@...
Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com
Date: Thursday, 24 September, 2009, 6:36 PM
Â
Prakash,
Thanks for clarifying on my behalf and yes, you are right, there is
nothing obscure here.
Indmovbuff,
Please don't read too much into my post and generate unwarranted
conclusions. I am a huge ARR fan as you know, but I'm also a music lover. I
also don't believe in blind devotion. I never said in my post that I would
be happy if for instance Tum Mile won best soundtrack instead of D6. I said
I would be happy for Pritam. Would I be disappointed being a Rahman fan?
Sure! I would be! But, I think I can have two feelings at the same
time...being happy for another composer who makes good music and who works
hard, but also being disappointed that my favorite composer didn't win it.
Music is music to me. Good music is good music to me. I am an ARR fan first
and foremost, but I also appreciate other's works. Do I believe that D6
deserves to win best music for the year? Yes! Why? Because I don't think any
soundtrack this year no matter how good will top it!
Guys, please be careful in how you interpret posts. Maybe I should have
clarified like I did above, but honestly, I didn't anticipate anyone to feel
shocked by what I said! My appreciation for another composer and happiness
for their accolades DOES NOT make me less of an ARR fan, in case some of you
think that way.
--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Prakash Balaramkrishna
prakysnaky@ ... wrote:
There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a
talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite
the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e.
Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case
of misinterpretation if i am not wrong.
Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they
are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the
most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can
judge pure music!
_ _ __
From: indmovbuff indmovbuff@ ...
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Sent: Thursday
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
IMO great work of Delhi 6's caliber does not need help of movie becoming a hit. Dil se is an example. i hope this repeats again. i will be more disappointed if he loses this time than if he lost it last year as D6 is way ahead of all 5 albums he gave last year, in fact in last many years. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purev...@... wrote: I don't wish Pritam to win the award. D6 deserves it handsdown, but remember, awards are also based on movie popularity. D6 sank commercially, so that's why I'm concerned. I want AR to win the award, but if he didn't and Pritam or any other composer won, I would be happy for them, but at the same time, disappointed that ARR didn't win. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Jahanzeb jahanzebtippu@ wrote: if Pritam wins best music award to me it would be the biggest blunder since IMO no album this year can be better than Delhi 6. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purevibz@ wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
Re: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Chord, I don’t think my post was in response to what you think “is a lack of blind devotion” or rather appreciation for other composers. I’d like to think that I am also a fan of good music and not blindly devoted Rahman’s only. I’ve said it to friends before and in this forum too– I look forward to seeing SEL win at the awards someday. I look forward to seeing Amit Trivedi win someday and yes even Pritam (if he can stay away from other people’s property in the relevant soundtrack) and I’ll be happy for them too. What got my attention was that you’d particularly mentioned “this year” which I think will automatically make anyone think of Pritam’s contenders this year and it broke my heart to think that you would be happy if Tum Mile (which you are yet to listen to) won over Delhi 6. But like you said, I am perhaps reading too much into it. You probably didn’t have Delhi 6 in mind when you wrote “this year”. Apologies. --- On Thu, 24/9/09, ichord purev...@yahoo.com wrote: From: ichord purev...@yahoo.com Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Thursday, 24 September, 2009, 6:36 PM Prakash, Thanks for clarifying on my behalf and yes, you are right, there is nothing obscure here. Indmovbuff, Please don't read too much into my post and generate unwarranted conclusions. I am a huge ARR fan as you know, but I'm also a music lover. I also don't believe in blind devotion. I never said in my post that I would be happy if for instance Tum Mile won best soundtrack instead of D6. I said I would be happy for Pritam. Would I be disappointed being a Rahman fan? Sure! I would be! But, I think I can have two feelings at the same time...being happy for another composer who makes good music and who works hard, but also being disappointed that my favorite composer didn't win it. Music is music to me. Good music is good music to me. I am an ARR fan first and foremost, but I also appreciate other's works. Do I believe that D6 deserves to win best music for the year? Yes! Why? Because I don't think any soundtrack this year no matter how good will top it! Guys, please be careful in how you interpret posts. Maybe I should have clarified like I did above, but honestly, I didn't anticipate anyone to feel shocked by what I said! My appreciation for another composer and happiness for their accolades DOES NOT make me less of an ARR fan, in case some of you think that way. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Prakash Balaramkrishna prakysnaky@ ... wrote: There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e. Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case of misinterpretation if i am not wrong. Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge pure music! _ _ __ From: indmovbuff indmovbuff@ ... To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win for this, hands down. I will be disappointed (and not insecure)as Rahman fan and more importantly a fan of good music, if he doesn't. DevD comes a good second in the race. I am not denying Tum Mile a place in the top 5 soundtracks so far this year. It's good and I've taken to Pritam's music in the recent past (despite all the plagiarism) but I m not going to say I'd be happy if it wins an award over a Delhi 6 or a DevD or even a Kaminey. And no, this has nothing to do with insecurity. P.S: Sorry about the rant, but you do genuinely puzzle me with such posts. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, ichord purevibz@ . wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
I never said I would be happy if Tum Mile won over D6. That's only your interpretation. And yes, I didn't have D6 or any other ARR soundtrack in mind. I never said I wish Pritam to win over ARR. I said that I would be happy if Pritam won an award for any of his soundtracks this year, esp. since he's never won an award before. Would I be disappointed if D6 or any other ARR soundtrack lost? Yes. I don't know why you would question that. Let's put this to rest. I'm tired of defending myself again and again over the same thing when I don't need to. Your apologies are accepted and don't worry yaar, with email, such misinterpretations happen all the time. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Indmov Buff indmovb...@... wrote: Chord, I donât think my post was in response to what you think âis a lack of blind devotionâ or rather appreciation for other composers. Iâd like to think that I am also a fan of good music and not blindly devoted Rahmanâs only.  Iâve said it to friends before and in this forum tooâ I look forward to seeing SEL win at the awards someday. I look forward to seeing Amit Trivedi win someday and yes even Pritam (if he can stay away from other peopleâs property in the relevant soundtrack) and Iâll be happy for them too. What got my attention was that youâd particularly mentioned âthis yearâ which I think will automatically make anyone think of Pritamâs contenders this year and it broke my heart to think that you would be happy if Tum Mile (which you are yet to listen to) won over Delhi 6. But like you said, I am perhaps reading too much into it. You probably didnât have Delhi 6 in mind when you wrote âthis yearâ. Apologies. --- On Thu, 24/9/09, ichord purev...@... wrote: From: ichord purev...@... Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Thursday, 24 September, 2009, 6:36 PM  Prakash, Thanks for clarifying on my behalf and yes, you are right, there is nothing obscure here. Indmovbuff, Please don't read too much into my post and generate unwarranted conclusions. I am a huge ARR fan as you know, but I'm also a music lover. I also don't believe in blind devotion. I never said in my post that I would be happy if for instance Tum Mile won best soundtrack instead of D6. I said I would be happy for Pritam. Would I be disappointed being a Rahman fan? Sure! I would be! But, I think I can have two feelings at the same time...being happy for another composer who makes good music and who works hard, but also being disappointed that my favorite composer didn't win it. Music is music to me. Good music is good music to me. I am an ARR fan first and foremost, but I also appreciate other's works. Do I believe that D6 deserves to win best music for the year? Yes! Why? Because I don't think any soundtrack this year no matter how good will top it! Guys, please be careful in how you interpret posts. Maybe I should have clarified like I did above, but honestly, I didn't anticipate anyone to feel shocked by what I said! My appreciation for another composer and happiness for their accolades DOES NOT make me less of an ARR fan, in case some of you think that way. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Prakash Balaramkrishna prakysnaky@ ... wrote: There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e. Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case of misinterpretation if i am not wrong. Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge pure music! _ _ __ From: indmovbuff indmovbuff@ ... To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win
Re: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
I didnt find Tum Mile to be as great. Its an OK album. As far as awards go,
no album this year is even nearer to Delhi 6 standard. So Delhi 6 is the
obvious winner for me.
Though there are other albums which have been brilliant as well. I
absolutely loved kaminey.
Dev D and Gulaal are also superb,. If i have to make a top5 list this year,
it would be
1. Delhi 6
2. Kaminey
3. Blue
4. Dev D
5. Gulaal
On Fri, Sep 25, 2009 at 5:16 PM, ichord purev...@yahoo.com wrote:
I never said I would be happy if Tum Mile won over D6. That's only your
interpretation. And yes, I didn't have D6 or any other ARR soundtrack in
mind. I never said I wish Pritam to win over ARR. I said that I would be
happy if Pritam won an award for any of his soundtracks this year, esp.
since he's never won an award before. Would I be disappointed if D6 or any
other ARR soundtrack lost? Yes. I don't know why you would question that.
Let's put this to rest. I'm tired of defending myself again and again over
the same thing when I don't need to. Your apologies are accepted and don't
worry yaar, with email, such misinterpretations happen all the time.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com,
Indmov Buff indmovb...@... wrote:
Chord, I don’t think my post was in response to what you
think “is a lack of blind devotion†or rather appreciation for other
composers. I’d like to think that I am also a fan of
good music and not blindly devoted Rahman’s only.  I’ve said it to
friends before and in this
forum too†I look forward to seeing SEL win at the awards someday. I
look forward
to seeing Amit Trivedi win someday and yes even Pritam (if he can stay
away
from other people’s property in the relevant soundtrack) and I’ll be
happy for
them too. What got my attention was that you’d particularly mentioned
“this yearâ€
which I think will automatically make anyone think of Pritam’s
contenders this
year and it broke my heart to think that you would be happy if Tum Mile
(which
you are yet to listen to) won over Delhi
6. But like you said, I am perhaps reading too much into it. You probably
didn’t
have Delhi 6 in
mind when you wrote “this year†. Apologies.Â
--- On Thu, 24/9/09, ichord purev...@... wrote:
From: ichord purev...@...
Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com
Date: Thursday, 24 September, 2009, 6:36 PM
Â
Prakash,
Thanks for clarifying on my behalf and yes, you are right, there is
nothing obscure here.
Indmovbuff,
Please don't read too much into my post and generate unwarranted
conclusions. I am a huge ARR fan as you know, but I'm also a music lover. I
also don't believe in blind devotion. I never said in my post that I would
be happy if for instance Tum Mile won best soundtrack instead of D6. I said
I would be happy for Pritam. Would I be disappointed being a Rahman fan?
Sure! I would be! But, I think I can have two feelings at the same
time...being happy for another composer who makes good music and who works
hard, but also being disappointed that my favorite composer didn't win it.
Music is music to me. Good music is good music to me. I am an ARR fan first
and foremost, but I also appreciate other's works. Do I believe that D6
deserves to win best music for the year? Yes! Why? Because I don't think any
soundtrack this year no matter how good will top it!
Guys, please be careful in how you interpret posts. Maybe I should have
clarified like I did above, but honestly, I didn't anticipate anyone to feel
shocked by what I said! My appreciation for another composer and happiness
for their accolades DOES NOT make me less of an ARR fan, in case some of you
think that way.
--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Prakash Balaramkrishna
prakysnaky@ ... wrote:
There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a
talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite
the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e.
Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case
of misinterpretation if i am not wrong.
Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are
extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most
important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge
pure music!
_ _ __
From: indmovbuff indmovbuff@ ...
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM
Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all
praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I
remember one in which you implied that rahman
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
if Pritam wins best music award to me it would be the biggest blunder since IMO no album this year can be better than Delhi 6. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purev...@... wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Might be 'Tum mile' is good one.but no album can match the music of 'Delhi -6' this year. It is just out of the world music.I am not hoping for awards though for it as movie did not do well. But the songs..OMG..I still listen 'Arziyaan','Rehna tu' and 'Dil gira daffatan' daily without fail. It is one of the masterpiece by AR and you can watch AR's soul through it.. Regards Yogesh --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Jahanzeb jahanzebti...@... wrote: if Pritam wins best music award to me it would be the biggest blunder since IMO no album this year can be better than Delhi 6. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purevibz@ wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win for this, hands down. I will be disappointed (and not insecure)as Rahman fan and more importantly a fan of good music, if he doesn't. DevD comes a good second in the race. I am not denying Tum Mile a place in the top 5 soundtracks so far this year. It's good and I've taken to Pritam's music in the recent past (despite all the plagiarism) but I m not going to say I'd be happy if it wins an award over a Delhi 6 or a DevD or even a Kaminey. And no, this has nothing to do with insecurity. P.S: Sorry about the rant, but you do genuinely puzzle me with such posts. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purev...@... wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
Re: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e. Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case of misinterpretation if i am not wrong. Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge pure music! From: indmovbuff indmovb...@yahoo.com To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win for this, hands down. I will be disappointed (and not insecure)as Rahman fan and more importantly a fan of good music, if he doesn't. DevD comes a good second in the race. I am not denying Tum Mile a place in the top 5 soundtracks so far this year. It's good and I've taken to Pritam's music in the recent past (despite all the plagiarism) but I m not going to say I'd be happy if it wins an award over a Delhi 6 or a DevD or even a Kaminey. And no, this has nothing to do with insecurity. P.S: Sorry about the rant, but you do genuinely puzzle me with such posts. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, ichord purev...@.. . wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Agreed Yogesh, D6 is tops for me. I hope it wins. But if it doesn't, it's not the end of the world, even though I would be greatly disappointed. I feel ARR is beyond awards, however,and these types of awards are also based on movie popularity, not just how good the music is. If another deserving composer won, I would be happy for them, but feel bad ARR missed out. That's all my post was about! --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, yogesh2783 yogesh2...@... wrote: Might be 'Tum mile' is good one.but no album can match the music of 'Delhi -6' this year. It is just out of the world music.I am not hoping for awards though for it as movie did not do well. But the songs..OMG..I still listen 'Arziyaan','Rehna tu' and 'Dil gira daffatan' daily without fail. It is one of the masterpiece by AR and you can watch AR's soul through it.. Regards Yogesh --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Jahanzeb jahanzebtippu@ wrote: if Pritam wins best music award to me it would be the biggest blunder since IMO no album this year can be better than Delhi 6. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purevibz@ wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
I don't wish Pritam to win the award. D6 deserves it handsdown, but remember, awards are also based on movie popularity. D6 sank commercially, so that's why I'm concerned. I want AR to win the award, but if he didn't and Pritam or any other composer won, I would be happy for them, but at the same time, disappointed that ARR didn't win. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Jahanzeb jahanzebti...@... wrote: if Pritam wins best music award to me it would be the biggest blunder since IMO no album this year can be better than Delhi 6. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, ichord purevibz@ wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Roger that! There's still 3 months to go for the year to end. Awards are waaay far off now. I liked 'Tum Mile', and it definitely is one of the best scores this year. AR has won so many awards in his lifetime, he'd care less about not winning another. But yeah, I do hope the deserving one wins. Delhi6 DEV D are top contenders this year. But I am hoping AR would win a National award soon. Cheers! --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Prakash Balaramkrishna prakysn...@... wrote: There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e. Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case of misinterpretation if i am not wrong. Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge pure music! From: indmovbuff indmovb...@... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win for this, hands down. I will be disappointed (and not insecure)as Rahman fan and more importantly a fan of good music, if he doesn't. DevD comes a good second in the race. I am not denying Tum Mile a place in the top 5 soundtracks so far this year. It's good and I've taken to Pritam's music in the recent past (despite all the plagiarism) but I m not going to say I'd be happy if it wins an award over a Delhi 6 or a DevD or even a Kaminey. And no, this has nothing to do with insecurity. P.S: Sorry about the rant, but you do genuinely puzzle me with such posts. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, ichord purevibz@ . wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Prakash, Thanks for clarifying on my behalf and yes, you are right, there is nothing obscure here. Indmovbuff, Please don't read too much into my post and generate unwarranted conclusions. I am a huge ARR fan as you know, but I'm also a music lover. I also don't believe in blind devotion. I never said in my post that I would be happy if for instance Tum Mile won best soundtrack instead of D6. I said I would be happy for Pritam. Would I be disappointed being a Rahman fan? Sure! I would be! But, I think I can have two feelings at the same time...being happy for another composer who makes good music and who works hard, but also being disappointed that my favorite composer didn't win it. Music is music to me. Good music is good music to me. I am an ARR fan first and foremost, but I also appreciate other's works. Do I believe that D6 deserves to win best music for the year? Yes! Why? Because I don't think any soundtrack this year no matter how good will top it! Guys, please be careful in how you interpret posts. Maybe I should have clarified like I did above, but honestly, I didn't anticipate anyone to feel shocked by what I said! My appreciation for another composer and happiness for their accolades DOES NOT make me less of an ARR fan, in case some of you think that way. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Prakash Balaramkrishna prakysn...@... wrote: There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e. Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case of misinterpretation if i am not wrong. Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge pure music! From: indmovbuff indmovb...@... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win for this, hands down. I will be disappointed (and not insecure)as Rahman fan and more importantly a fan of good music, if he doesn't. DevD comes a good second in the race. I am not denying Tum Mile a place in the top 5 soundtracks so far this year. It's good and I've taken to Pritam's music in the recent past (despite all the plagiarism) but I m not going to say I'd be happy if it wins an award over a Delhi 6 or a DevD or even a Kaminey. And no, this has nothing to do with insecurity. P.S: Sorry about the rant, but you do genuinely puzzle me with such posts. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, ichord purevibz@ . wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam
Re: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Yogesh hits the nail on the head. Delhi 6 can be however beautiful, the movie did not do well and with that, so did the music so that chances of awards for it this year might be slim. Have you all not wondered why Yuvraaj was not even nominated last year for a music award even though it was so magical? The film was a flop and thus its music did no live on. Also what is happening with Ada? Why did Drona win best newcomer for music over Amit Trivedi's Aamir? The point is that when music is not popular as well, its chances of recognition will go down. That said, just want to say that post Slumdog Millionaire, the outside world is looking at the talent of Indian. It is thus nice to see that other music directors are attempting do good work and aim for standards set by Rahman himself. TUM MILE is really excellent stuff, and instead of hating and quarrelling over it, think people should try to appreciate it for what it is. Hard work must be rewarded regardless of who it is (hoping pritam did hard work for this) and I have no problems if Pritam or Sohail Sen or Amit Trivedi or someone else who is also derserving wins it...as long as they are deserving. Music should not be a divider, it should unite everyone. --- On Thu, 9/24/09, ichord purev...@yahoo.com wrote: From: ichord purev...@yahoo.com Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Thursday, September 24, 2009, 2:49 PM Agreed Yogesh, D6 is tops for me. I hope it wins. But if it doesn't, it's not the end of the world, even though I would be greatly disappointed. I feel ARR is beyond awards, however,and these types of awards are also based on movie popularity, not just how good the music is. If another deserving composer won, I would be happy for them, but feel bad ARR missed out. That's all my post was about! --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, yogesh2783 yogesh2783@ ... wrote: Might be 'Tum mile' is good one.but no album can match the music of 'Delhi -6' this year. It is just out of the world music.I am not hoping for awards though for it as movie did not do well. But the songs..OMG.. I still listen 'Arziyaan',' Rehna tu' and 'Dil gira daffatan' daily without fail. It is one of the masterpiece by AR and you can watch AR's soul through it.. Regards Yogesh --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Jahanzeb jahanzebtippu@ wrote: if Pritam wins best music award to me it would be the biggest blunder since IMO no album this year can be better than Delhi 6. - Jahanzeb --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, ichord purevibz@ wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong contender for the best music director of thr year with this one. On that note, Rahman has done a good job with blue, but i fear the music is not catching on as it normally does. Other recent brillian scores are RUSLAAN, WHATS YOUR RASHEE and LONDON DREAMS, the latter two also being very strong contender along with pritam. Plagarism charges have been made against pritam before, hope it does not happen with TUM MILE as wll. Its nothing short of magical. --- On Wed, 9/23/09, Anish Gupte musimax2000@ wrote: From: Anish Gupte musimax2000@ Subject: [arr] Tume mile (Non-Arr) To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2009, 10:28 AM Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
Re: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Hey guys, I have heard Tum Mile and its a really good album. Pritam has this knack of coming up with really wonderful soundtracks every now and ...and even if the songs are copied..Pritam does a great job on them..i dont know if Tum Mile songs have been copied or not ( I hope they are not...coz it would be a shame and would dilute the beauty of this album). Having said that..I do agree with most ppl in this thread in that Delhi 6 is the best album this year (so far, and i dont think there will be any better ones)I know A.R.rahman is way beyond awards and all ...except fr oscars of course..but still the best music of the year is undoubtedly that of Delhi-6. (Esp Rehna Tu..aah what a gem!!!) Anish. On Thu, Sep 24, 2009 at 2:36 PM, ichord purev...@yahoo.com wrote: Prakash, Thanks for clarifying on my behalf and yes, you are right, there is nothing obscure here. Indmovbuff, Please don't read too much into my post and generate unwarranted conclusions. I am a huge ARR fan as you know, but I'm also a music lover. I also don't believe in blind devotion. I never said in my post that I would be happy if for instance Tum Mile won best soundtrack instead of D6. I said I would be happy for Pritam. Would I be disappointed being a Rahman fan? Sure! I would be! But, I think I can have two feelings at the same time...being happy for another composer who makes good music and who works hard, but also being disappointed that my favorite composer didn't win it. Music is music to me. Good music is good music to me. I am an ARR fan first and foremost, but I also appreciate other's works. Do I believe that D6 deserves to win best music for the year? Yes! Why? Because I don't think any soundtrack this year no matter how good will top it! Guys, please be careful in how you interpret posts. Maybe I should have clarified like I did above, but honestly, I didn't anticipate anyone to feel shocked by what I said! My appreciation for another composer and happiness for their accolades DOES NOT make me less of an ARR fan, in case some of you think that way. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com, Prakash Balaramkrishna prakysn...@... wrote: There is nothing obscure about chord's post. He just says Pritam is a talented composer and he would be happy for him if we wins an award despite the notoriety. I don't think he even dreamt of such a line of thought i.e. Tume Mile as a Competition to Delhi 6 while making that post. Again a case of misinterpretation if i am not wrong. Further there seems to be too much fuss about awards. Although they are extremely important as a recognition for an artist, they are not the most important parameter. To quote from AR's recent interview No award can judge pure music! From: indmovbuff indmovb...@... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com Sent: Thursday, September 24, 2009 10:04:43 PM Subject: [arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr) Chord, you really puzzle me with such posts. 90% of your posts are all praise for Rahman's music and then occasionally you have these shockers. I remember one in which you implied that rahman didn't deserve a Filmfare for Guru and that filmfare were biased towards him. This one implies that you won't be disappointed if Pritam wins best music for Tum Mile, a soundtrack you haven't still even given a listen to. You obviously have a right to your opinion but some of your posts (amongst some gems) puzzles me about your view on Rahman's music. Personally, I haven't listened to anything better than Delhi 6 this year and I think Rahman should win for this, hands down. I will be disappointed (and not insecure)as Rahman fan and more importantly a fan of good music, if he doesn't. DevD comes a good second in the race. I am not denying Tum Mile a place in the top 5 soundtracks so far this year. It's good and I've taken to Pritam's music in the recent past (despite all the plagiarism) but I m not going to say I'd be happy if it wins an award over a Delhi 6 or a DevD or even a Kaminey. And no, this has nothing to do with insecurity. P.S: Sorry about the rant, but you do genuinely puzzle me with such posts. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, ichord purevibz@ . wrote: If Pritam wins best music award this year, I 'll be happy for him. He's actually a nice guy from what I can fathom and his music is very popular. I have yet to listen to Tum Mile, but I hear it's really good from a lot of sources. ARR fans don't need to feel insecure if an award goes to someone else. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, vedavid manick vedavid_manick@ wrote: Hey everyone, In the few times i have posted i have noted that I am a rahman fan becasue I am a fan of great music. I could not agree more that TUM MILE is one of the best albums of this year. Pritam has put himself as a strong
[arr] Re: Tume mile (Non-Arr)
Really need to check this one out. Hearing lots of great reviews on it. Pritam is a really talented guy, I gotta give him credit. He sure know how to make hits!! --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Anish Gupte musimax2...@... wrote: Guys u must check out this soundtrack by Pritam...TUM MILE Its a wonderful album ..Tum Mile and Dil Ibaadat are really beautiful songs...listening to the others now...they seem good too... Anish.
