Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Guys lets end this here man...i think this topic has been talked so much tat it has to end here...see when u ppl r itself able to make up some kind of a similarity between these 2 songs(thought they dont sound similar except for tat first two line)do u think d director,d producer and above all our boss who knows so much in music,r sitting der simply to recycle old stuff and give it to us...when v ourself analyse so much in His music wont he do it...may b der r certain ppl who deliberately copy things but i dont think ppl like arr,illayaraja all do things wantedly..dey may b just inspired by it thats all and der is no necessity of copying some stuff for dey have der own talents and dey have proved it en number of timesso pl y all these things...lelts coool down..it was just a mere co incidence...pls ppl v all r arr fans lets not dispute among ourselves for lil things like this...i dint intend to hurt anyone..if i had am sorry..take care.. with regards, Aarthi aravinth aravinth <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hey ARRFANZstop using the word DISAPPOINTED if u r a true fan of ARR then by the end of this discussion u shld hav understood tht the only similarity between those two songs were RAAGA n nothin else...Also it may be jus a coincident, i can give u thosand's of songs like that for example...so this not mean COPY... If u stil cant understand this simple thing then u can urself ask a music expert abt it bye Aravinth.M Chennai.Guy Harish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hei broU've done an excellent job in clearin up this doubt...They're not the same...ARR DIDNT & WONT COPY.!At least this really shows who r the real fans of ARRHaiyo haiyo,ore tamashe po with this people;)Stay happy always guysARR & ARR's Music will always remain pure Yur Fren & ARR Fan; HariRAHMANiacMohamed Yaseer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hi everyone...Hope this will clear the doubt that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's adi ennadi raakkamma.. I have written the musical notes for both songs and attached it with this mail...You will realize that the notes are different but the arrangement are almost the same...I also have attached the midi of both songs which was claimed to be similar...Will upload the part of the real song in gmail account soon...Try to listen to it again and again...Note each and every part of...You guys will be fascinated the difference Hope this will satisfy everyone...We can come to the conclusion that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's songs but both songs appear from the same raaga and A.R Rahman and M.S Visvanathan are great composers Have a wonderful day...riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone was Complaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies.mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... maheesmy_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys...Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it...I am talking generally...No offence to anyone...Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend...--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> Prudhvi, good comments man.> > To the subject,> I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.> > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far.> I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius -can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or wh
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Hey ARRFANZstop using the word DISAPPOINTED if u r a true fan of ARR then by the end of this discussion u shld hav understood tht the only similarity between those two songs were RAAGA n nothin else...Also it may be jus a coincident, i can give u thosand's of songs like that for example...so this not mean COPY... If u stil cant understand this simple thing then u can urself ask a music expert abt it bye Aravinth.M Chennai.Guy Harish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hei broU've done an excellent job in clearin up this doubt...They're not the same...ARR DIDNT & WONT COPY.!At least this really shows who r the real fans of ARRHaiyo haiyo,ore tamashe po with this people;)Stay happy always guysARR & ARR's Music will always remain pure Yur Fren & ARR Fan; HariRAHMANiacMohamed Yaseer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hi everyone...Hope this will clear the doubt that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's adi ennadi raakkamma.. I have written the musical notes for both songs and attached it with this mail...You will realize that the notes are different but the arrangement are almost the same...I also have attached the midi of both songs which was claimed to be similar...Will upload the part of the real song in gmail account soon...Try to listen to it again and again...Note each and every part of...You guys will be fascinated the difference Hope this will satisfy everyone...We can come to the conclusion that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's songs but both songs appear from the same raaga and A.R Rahman and M.S Visvanathan are great composers Have a wonderful day...riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone was Complaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies.mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... maheesmy_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys...Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it...I am talking generally...No offence to anyone...Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend...--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> Prudhvi, good comments man.> > To the subject,> I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.> > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far.> I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius -can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever.> > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied)> > Regards> Arun> > Prudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: Hi All,> > Please be clear about what this group is all about> > Is it about only praising ARR?> > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts..> > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it.> > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment.> > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments.> > I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself.> > I think u got my point.> > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movi
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Hahaha.. You are really a funny person First of all, learn how to use paragraph when you are writing long It's kindoff mixed-up,man You hope everyone will stop talking about musical notes, raaga or something else? Why? Are you afraid that these terms will defeat your arguments Or never even heard of them before? You are talking about similarity in the tunes and don't want to talk about raaga and musical notes? Do you know what builds the tunes .Can you compose tunes without musical notes and Raaga? Or at least give me an example of a song without these terms The attachment of the midi files and musical notes of the songs is a solid proof that A.R Rahman didn't copy Perhaps you are terrified with it.. You just don't learn do you? No one here is trying to force themselves and find excuses.. Why on earth we should do that, man? We had great healthy and motivating discussion and arguments here all this while and you come here from nowhere and saying that we are not open-minded.. Look who's talking If we didn't provide any proof, then you can say that we are closed- minded but we have everything Perhaps you don't have any point to argue anymore but still don't want to give up to show your pride or something Try to listen to the midi and the real song again and again If you still found that the tunes are VERY SIMILAR as you have claimed, then you have to do something with your ears Am sure that there are many ear specialists at South Africa Actually I doubt that you are really from South Africa for some reason What's your name by the way? Just out of curiosity, where do you get original ARR audio cassettes and CDs? You can share anything about ARR in this group but what you did was not sharing but challenging If you have any doubt, you can ask a question but you straight away came up with a hasty statement saying that ARR copies You have came to a conclusion by yourself without any argument and now you feel that you can't share your opinion You said that we shouldn't say anything that ARR does is correct and once again I'm asking you what did he do wrong? I doubt you have implied meaning there We talk and discuss about Raaga and music not to show off but to share with the music lovers.. If you took it wrong, I can't help it . No one here said that he/she's the greatest fan of A.R Rahman.. I just don't understand why you are taking everything in a very negative and evil way I guess you might have some pressure in your life and trying to pour off everything using this matter . Relax, man.. Am sure everything will turn out fine if you can manage yourself Once again I would like to tell you that we are not wrong and not giving any excuses or forcing ourselves.. We don't have to, man . Are trying to say that you are doing that and trying to blame others to cover up? The conclusion is ARR DID NOT COPY MSV There is no doubt that MSV is a great composer but bare in mind that ARR is genius and have no reason to copy, okay? Have a great day --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > i hope evryone stop talking about musical notes,raaga or something > else.I am talking about the similarity in the tunes.dont force > yourself to find any other excuses!.Maybe arr not copy the > song but the tune are very similar.even its two lines but still it > is very similar.i am very new to this group.but i thought all arr > fans is very open minded and i can share anything about a.r > rahman.but some people who thinks they are very good in music and > talk about raaga.they know what they talk is wrong and keep forcing > themself to find other excuses.please change.please dont think i am > not arr fan and for the people i am talking about please dont think > u are the best arr fan.Thank You and Bye. > > disapointed arr fan, > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Guy Harish > wrote: > > > > > > Hei broU've done an excellent job in clearin up this > doubt...They're not the same...ARR DIDNT & WONT COPY.!At > least this really shows who r the real fans of ARRHaiyo > haiyo,ore tamashe po with this people;)Stay happy always > guysARR & ARR's Music will always remain pure > > Yur Fren & ARR Fan; > > HariRAHMANiac > > Mohamed Yaseer wrote: > > Hi everyone...Hope this will clear the doubt that A.R Rahman > didn't copy MSV's adi ennadi raakkamma.. > > > > I have written the musical notes for both songs and attached it > with this mail...You will realize that the notes are different but > the arrangement are almost the same...I also have attached the midi > of both songs which was claimed to be similar...Will upload the part > of the real song in gmail account soon...Try to listen to it again > and again...Note each and every part of...You guys will be > fascinated the difference > > > > Hope this will satisfy everyone...We can
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
i hope evryone stop talking about musical notes,raaga or something else.I am talking about the similarity in the tunes.dont force yourself to find any other excuses!.Maybe arr not copy the song but the tune are very similar.even its two lines but still it is very similar.i am very new to this group.but i thought all arr fans is very open minded and i can share anything about a.r rahman.but some people who thinks they are very good in music and talk about raaga.they know what they talk is wrong and keep forcing themself to find other excuses.please change.please dont think i am not arr fan and for the people i am talking about please dont think u are the best arr fan.Thank You and Bye. disapointed arr fan, [EMAIL PROTECTED] --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Guy Harish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > Hei broU've done an excellent job in clearin up this doubt...They're not the same...ARR DIDNT & WONT COPY.!At least this really shows who r the real fans of ARRHaiyo haiyo,ore tamashe po with this people;)Stay happy always guysARR & ARR's Music will always remain pure > Yur Fren & ARR Fan; > HariRAHMANiac > Mohamed Yaseer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi everyone...Hope this will clear the doubt that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's adi ennadi raakkamma.. > > I have written the musical notes for both songs and attached it with this mail...You will realize that the notes are different but the arrangement are almost the same...I also have attached the midi of both songs which was claimed to be similar...Will upload the part of the real song in gmail account soon...Try to listen to it again and again...Note each and every part of...You guys will be fascinated the difference > > Hope this will satisfy everyone...We can come to the conclusion that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's songs but both songs appear from the same raaga and A.R Rahman and M.S Visvanathan are great composers > > Have a wonderful day... > > > riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone wasComplaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies. > > mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... > > mahees > > my_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that > A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we > can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni > because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys... > > Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing > actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof > his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can > be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence > between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same > raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham > or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is > the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music > itself...Please don't kill it... > > I am talking generally...No offence to anyone... > > Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend... > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar wrote: > > > > Prudhvi, good comments man. > > > > To the subject, > > I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the > way he works then he won't be recognised globally. > > > > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they > don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied > will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far. > > I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are > only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius - > can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him > to copy? > > > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF > was copied or whatever. > > > > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied > from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't > be said as copied) > > > > Regards > > Arun > > > > Prudhvi > wrote: Hi All, > > > > Please be clear about what this group is all about > > > > Is it about only praising ARR? > > > > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows > some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts.. > > > > If someone comes up with some doubt about
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Hei broU've done an excellent job in clearin up this doubt...They're not the same...ARR DIDNT & WONT COPY.!At least this really shows who r the real fans of ARRHaiyo haiyo,ore tamashe po with this people;)Stay happy always guysARR & ARR's Music will always remain pure Yur Fren & ARR Fan; HariRAHMANiacMohamed Yaseer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hi everyone...Hope this will clear the doubt that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's adi ennadi raakkamma.. I have written the musical notes for both songs and attached it with this mail...You will realize that the notes are different but the arrangement are almost the same...I also have attached the midi of both songs which was claimed to be similar...Will upload the part of the real song in gmail account soon...Try to listen to it again and again...Note each and every part of...You guys will be fascinated the difference Hope this will satisfy everyone...We can come to the conclusion that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's songs but both songs appear from the same raaga and A.R Rahman and M.S Visvanathan are great composers Have a wonderful day...riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone was Complaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies.mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... maheesmy_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys...Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it...I am talking generally...No offence to anyone...Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend...--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> Prudhvi, good comments man.> > To the subject,> I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.> > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far.> I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius -can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever.> > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied)> > Regards> Arun> > Prudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: Hi All,> > Please be clear about what this group is all about> > Is it about only praising ARR?> > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts..> > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it.> > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment.> > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments.> > I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself.> > I think u got my point.> > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music.> > Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan?> The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans.> > If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR.> > Regards,> Prudhv
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
hey do u have da notes 2 other arr songs? can u pls upload dem some where o put dem in the group files o pls mail dem 2 me 10z in advance!!!Mohamed Yaseer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hi everyone...Hope this will clear the doubt that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's adi ennadi raakkamma.. I have written the musical notes for both songs and attached it with this mail...You will realize that the notes are different but the arrangement are almost the same...I also have attached the midi of both songs which was claimed to be similar...Will upload the part of the real song in gmail account soon...Try to listen to it again and again...Note each and every part of...You guys will be fascinated the difference Hope this will satisfy everyone...We can come to the conclusion that A.R Rahman didn't copy MSV's songs but both songs appear from the same raaga and A.R Rahman and M.S Visvanathan are great composers Have a wonderful day...riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone was Complaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies.mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... maheesmy_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys...Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it...I am talking generally...No offence to anyone...Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend...--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> Prudhvi, good comments man.> > To the subject,> I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.> > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far.> I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius -can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever.> > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied)> > Regards> Arun> > Prudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: Hi All,> > Please be clear about what this group is all about> > Is it about only praising ARR?> > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts..> > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it.> > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment.> > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments.> > I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself.> > I think u got my point.> > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music.> > Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan?> The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans.> > If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR.> > Regards,> Prudhvi> > arrfanz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:> > > u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything > pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my > account
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
I feel God Father is one of the best albums by AR. It is mind blowing with its deep classical touch, to the very core. The song Theyil Vizhunda is killing me literally, it keeps ringing in my mind even depriving me of sleep ( no kidding ). Just felt like sharing with fellow rehmaniacs. Kiran. PS: I dont care if HE copies or does wat ever to give us the amaizing music. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone wasComplaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies. > > mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... > > mahees > > my_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that > A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we > can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni > because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys... > > Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing > actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof > his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can > be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence > between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same > raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham > or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is > the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music > itself...Please don't kill it... > > I am talking generally...No offence to anyone... > > Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend... > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar wrote: > > > > Prudhvi, good comments man. > > > > To the subject, > > I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the > way he works then he won't be recognised globally. > > > > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they > don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied > will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far. > > I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are > only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius - > can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him > to copy? > > > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF > was copied or whatever. > > > > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied > from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't > be said as copied) > > > > Regards > > Arun > > > > Prudhvi > wrote: Hi All, > > > > Please be clear about what this group is all about > > > > Is it about only praising ARR? > > > > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows > some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts.. > > > > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him > prove it. > > > > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him > produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this > group can comment. > > > > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments. > > > > I can understand that most of the members of this group are > emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself. > > > > I think u got my point. > > > > > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka > Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the > movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i > listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. > Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have > such doubts while listening to others' music. > > > > Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR > fan? > > The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR > fans. > > > > If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he > is no more a fan of ARR. > > > > Regards, > > Prudhvi > > > > arrfanz wrote: > > > > > > u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about > anything > > pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created > my > > account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only > > buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two > > songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to > this > > web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=al
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
illayaraja ,yuvan shankar raja, Harris was copying a whole song, but noone was Complaining them. if rahman copies single line everyone was telling rahman copies.mohamed mahees <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... maheesmy_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys...Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it...I am talking generally...No offence to anyone...Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend...--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> Prudhvi, good comments man.> > To the subject,> I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.> > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far.> I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius -can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever.> > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied)> > Regards> Arun> > Prudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: Hi All,> > Please be clear about what this group is all about> > Is it about only praising ARR?> > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts..> > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it.> > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment.> > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments.> > I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself.> > I think u got my point.> > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music.> > Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan?> The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans.> > If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR.> > Regards,> Prudhvi> > arrfanz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:> > > u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything > pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my > account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only > buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two > songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to this > web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=all&s=&o=225> > Ennadi Rakkamma > Movie Name : Pattikkada Pattanama (1972)> Singer : Sounderarajan T M> Music Director : Viswanathan M S> Lyrics : Kannadasan> Year : 1972> > > the same part is:> kamma karaile :kammakaraile umma kudekkava summa nee veluttukattu> enne di rakkama: adi ennadi rakkamma pallaku paduttu en nenju > kulungguraadi> > rayrai,do u need anymore explaination?> > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" wrote:> >> > You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi> > grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that> > too an old song and we did not even notice.> > Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will > praise> > u just for the sake of it
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
hi and hi againi agree with my_arrit has been happening a lot of late...not only accusations against arr, but also the degrading of other MDs in this group..d best way is to appreciate the good, and discard the bad...it is not at all encouraging to accuse MDs of copyin, and it is not fair to condemn them if several notes sound similar as like my_arr said, sa re ga ma pa da ni, thats all we have... maheesmy_arr <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys...Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it...I am talking generally...No offence to anyone...Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend...--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> Prudhvi, good comments man.> > To the subject,> I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.> > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far.> I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius -can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever.> > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied)> > Regards> Arun> > Prudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: Hi All,> > Please be clear about what this group is all about> > Is it about only praising ARR?> > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts..> > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it.> > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment.> > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments.> > I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself.> > I think u got my point.> > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music.> > Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan?> The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans.> > If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR.> > Regards,> Prudhvi> > arrfanz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:> > > u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything > pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my > account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only > buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two > songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to this > web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=all&s=&o=225> > Ennadi Rakkamma > Movie Name : Pattikkada Pattanama (1972)> Singer : Sounderarajan T M> Music Director : Viswanathan M S> Lyrics : Kannadasan> Year : 1972> > > the same part is:> kamma karaile :kammakaraile umma kudekkava summa nee veluttukattu> enne di rakkama: adi ennadi rakkamma pallaku paduttu en nenju > kulungguraadi> > rayrai,do u need anymore explaination?> > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" wrote:> >> > You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi> > grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that> > too an old song and we did not even notice.> > Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will > praise> > u just for the sake of it. But just stop here.> > so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so> > futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song > from.> > but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Some people tend to get over exited and straight away saying that A.R Rahman copies just because the songs sound similar...Well we can't say if any other music directors use sa re ga ma pa da ni because that's all we have...It's a rotation of these seven keys... Giving a comment is highly appreciated and a healthy thing actually...I never say that arrfanz has no rights to post and proof his point, but just think before using the word copy because it can be highly offencing...Make sure you know the diffrence between 'copy', 'inspire', 'uplifted' and 'appear from the same raaga'...Am not trying to compare whether you have learnt sangeetham or not but please don't come up with funny new terms...Sangeetham is the very basic indian classical music and also the soul of the music itself...Please don't kill it... I am talking generally...No offence to anyone... Have a nice day and enjoy your weekend... --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Arun Kumar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Prudhvi, good comments man. > > To the subject, > I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally. > > I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far. > I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius - can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? > > And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever. > > (In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied) > > Regards > Arun > > Prudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hi All, > > Please be clear about what this group is all about > > Is it about only praising ARR? > > Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts.. > > If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it. > > If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. > > After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment. > > One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments. > > I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself. > > I think u got my point. > > > In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music. > > Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan? > The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans. > > If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR. > > Regards, > Prudhvi > > arrfanz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything > pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my > account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only > buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two > songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to this > web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=all&s=&o=225 > > Ennadi Rakkamma > Movie Name : Pattikkada Pattanama (1972) > Singer : Sounderarajan T M > Music Director : Viswanathan M S > Lyrics : Kannadasan > Year : 1972 > > > the same part is: > kamma karaile :kammakaraile umma kudekkava summa nee veluttukattu > enne di rakkama: adi ennadi rakkamma pallaku paduttu en nenju > kulungguraadi > > rayrai,do u need anymore explaination? > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" wrote: > > > > You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi > > grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that > > too an old song and we did not even notice. > > Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will > praise > > u just for the sake of it. But just stop here. > > so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so > > futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song > from. > > but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever a song by this name. > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" wrote: > > > > > > hai guys!i am arr fan from south africa. > > > just wanna tell u guys that a.r rahman copi
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Prudhvi, good comments man.To the subject, I don't understand why people says 'ARR copies'. If that's the way he works then he won't be recognised globally.I believe ARR would himself be careful in his tunes that they don't resemble any other. Bcoz a single instance to prove he copied will bring down his fame and hardwork he did so far. I read in a reply to this subject that the first lines are only similar. Why will one copy only two lines. ARR is a genius - can any one think he fell in short for two phrases that made him to copy? And I didn't bother to check out the links provided claiming GF was copied or whatever.(In another message someone told Kan pesum vaarthaigal is copied from kuchi kuchi raakama. It's just notes are similar, it can't be said as copied) Regards ArunPrudhvi <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:Hi All, Please be clear about what this group is all about Is it about only praising ARR? Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts.. If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it. If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment. One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments. I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself. I think u got my point. In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music. Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan? The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans. If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR. Regards, Prudhvi arrfanz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to this web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=all&s=&o=225Ennadi Rakkamma Movie Name : Pattikkada Pattanama (1972)Singer : Sounderarajan T MMusic Director : Viswanathan M SLyrics : KannadasanYear : 1972the same part is:kamma karaile :kammakaraile umma kudekkava summa nee veluttukattuenne di rakkama: adi ennadi rakkamma pallaku paduttu en nenju kulungguraadirayrai,do u need anymore explaination?--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" wrote:>> You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi> grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that> too an old song and we did not even notice.> Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will praise> u just for the sake of it. But just stop here.> so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so> futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song from.> but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever a song by this name.> > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" wrote:> >> > hai guys!i am arr fan from south africa.> > just wanna tell u guys that a.r rahman copied the song kamma karaile> > (godfather) from adi ennethi rakkema(old movie).I am also arr fan but > > we must be open minded and not saying that everything he did is > > correct.that shows that we are true arr fan.> >>Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic.Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community.Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.comAdmin: [EMAIL PROTECTED]To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ Jiyo cricket on Yahoo! India cricket Yahoo! Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time. Jiyo cricket on Yahoo! India cricket Yahoo! Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time. Talk is cheap. Use Yahoo! Messenger to make PC-to-Phone calls. Great rates starting at 1¢/min. Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. PC-to-Phone calls for ridiculously low rates. Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Well as I said earlier both songs are from the same Raaga but the tunes are quite different...If you don't believe, try to play the tunes of both songs using any musical instuments (especially flute)... You will have realize that the keys are different but both songs have the same style and arrangement (for the first line of the songs) It is undeniable that M.S Visvanathan is a great composer of his time and also a very kind human being...He has mastered Indian music very well and came up with great different tunes And yes..Kamma Karayilea indeed better than athi ennadi raakkamma.. Take Care. <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: im not here to support him...but yea...the 1st line is exact same..." Kamma Karayile Umma kodukuva , Summa nee valathu kattu "" Adi Ennadi Rakkama Pallaku nedapu, en neju kulunguthadi"only thing the old song is in abit slower tempo u can check it out ur self :http://www.musicindiaonline.com/p/x/c5bgmFRnmt.As1NMvHdW/but nevertheless,Kamma kariyile is a great song...only the 1st 2 lines sound simular...other than that...its original...dun worry... :D:D:D... Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. PC-to-Phone calls for ridiculously low rates. Blab-away for as little as 1¢/min. Make PC-to-Phone Calls using Yahoo! Messenger with Voice. Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS Visit your group "arrahmanfans" on the web. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
im not here to support him...but yea...the 1st line is exact same... " Kamma Karayile Umma kodukuva , Summa nee valathu kattu " " Adi Ennadi Rakkama Pallaku nedapu, en neju kulunguthadi" only thing the old song is in abit slower tempo u can check it out ur self : http://www.musicindiaonline.com/p/x/c5bgmFRnmt.As1NMvHdW/ but nevertheless,Kamma kariyile is a great song...only the 1st 2 lines sound simular...other than that...its original...dun worry... :D:D:D... Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
Re: [arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Hi All, Please be clear about what this group is all about Is it about only praising ARR? Every member in this group (irrespective of whether he knows some sangeetam or not) is free to express his thoughts.. If someone comes up with some doubt about ARR copying, let him prove it. If someone finds some part of a song being copied, let him produce the samples as arrfanz did. After listening to the two samples, the Music Gurus of this group can comment. One need not shout unnecessarily on one's comments. I can understand that most of the members of this group are emotionally attached not only to ARR music but also to ARR himself. I think u got my point. In a similar case, while watching the movie "Chaudhavi ka Chand", i felt as if some of the tabla beats used as a BGM in the movie were being reused by ARR in one of his songs. But when i listened carefully, i understood that it was not exactly the same. Actually we are s used to listening to ARR songs that we have such doubts while listening to others' music. Since i posted this in the group, do u think that i am not a ARR fan? The sole reason we are a part of this grp is... we all are ARR fans. If someone tries to question his originality, it doesnt mean he is no more a fan of ARR. Regards, Prudhvi arrfanz <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to this web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=all&s=&o=225Ennadi Rakkamma Movie Name : Pattikkada Pattanama (1972)Singer : Sounderarajan T MMusic Director : Viswanathan M SLyrics : KannadasanYear : 1972the same part is:kamma karaile :kammakaraile umma kudekkava summa nee veluttukattuenne di rakkama: adi ennadi rakkamma pallaku paduttu en nenju kulungguraadirayrai,do u need anymore explaination?--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote:>> You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi> grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that> too an old song and we did not even notice.> Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will praise> u just for the sake of it. But just stop here.> so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so> futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song from.> but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever a song by this name.> > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" wrote:> >> > hai guys!i am arr fan from south africa.> > just wanna tell u guys that a.r rahman copied the song kamma karaile> > (godfather) from adi ennethi rakkema(old movie).I am also arr fan but > > we must be open minded and not saying that everything he did is > > correct.that shows that we are true arr fan.> >>Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic.Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community.Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.comAdmin: [EMAIL PROTECTED]To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ Jiyo cricket on Yahoo! India cricket Yahoo! Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time. Jiyo cricket on Yahoo! India cricket Yahoo! Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time. Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS Visit your group "arrahmanfans" on the web. To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
Wo wo wo...Give me a break,man...Both songs do have similarities since they are from the same raaga...Have you ever heard the song ennadi raakkamma by the way? It doesn't matter when the yahoo ID created and when a person joins this group, look at the point he's trying to say..Take the good ones and leave the bad ones,man!!! Are you trying to say that you have no other things to do than checking the history of others' Yahoo account?? Here is a good piece of advice to you...You can be a good music lover..No doubt about it..But if you want to comment on music learn some sangeetham please...Or at least have basics of it...Try to have wide dimension in music.. Have a nice day --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi > grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that > too an old song and we did not even notice. > Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will praise > u just for the sake of it. But just stop here. > so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so > futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song from. > but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever a song by this name. > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" wrote: > > > > hai guys!i am arr fan from south africa. > > just wanna tell u guys that a.r rahman copied the song kamma karaile > > (godfather) from adi ennethi rakkema(old movie).I am also arr fan but > > we must be open minded and not saying that everything he did is > > correct.that shows that we are true arr fan. > > > Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
u dont think u r to good MR.RAYRAI2k.Before u comment about anything pls think first.dont talk rubish.what is ur problem if i created my account before posting that message.I am a.r rahman fan and i only buy original arr cd.but i found there is similarity on that two songs. if u really wanna listen to the ennedi rakkema pls go to this web http://www.musicindiaonline.com/s?q=t.m.s&i=26&f=all&s=&o=225 Ennadi Rakkamma Movie Name : Pattikkada Pattanama (1972) Singer : Sounderarajan T M Music Director : Viswanathan M S Lyrics : Kannadasan Year : 1972 the same part is: kamma karaile :kammakaraile umma kudekkava summa nee veluttukattu enne di rakkama: adi ennadi rakkamma pallaku paduttu en nenju kulungguraadi rayrai,do u need anymore explaination? --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "rayrai2k" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi > grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that > too an old song and we did not even notice. > Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will praise > u just for the sake of it. But just stop here. > so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so > futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song from. > but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever a song by this name. > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" wrote: > > > > hai guys!i am arr fan from south africa. > > just wanna tell u guys that a.r rahman copied the song kamma karaile > > (godfather) from adi ennethi rakkema(old movie).I am also arr fan but > > we must be open minded and not saying that everything he did is > > correct.that shows that we are true arr fan. > > > Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
[arr] Re: a r rahman copied in godfather??????????????????
You create a yahoo ID today and very soon u bcame a memeber of thsi grp and in moments u cmment from SA that BOSS has copied in GF that too an old song and we did not even notice. Shud I praise u r genius, if you want just praise the grp will praise u just for the sake of it. But just stop here. so do u mean to say adi ennethi rakkema(old movie) was done so futuristic, our great boy dont remember which movie is this song from. but pulled a song. I wonder if there is ever a song by this name. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "arrfanz" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > hai guys!i am arr fan from south africa. > just wanna tell u guys that a.r rahman copied the song kamma karaile > (godfather) from adi ennethi rakkema(old movie).I am also arr fan but > we must be open minded and not saying that everything he did is > correct.that shows that we are true arr fan. > Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
