Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir, He loves ARR's music more!
the answer will come out after arr music release and this is most awaited film for me to prove who is ar rahman - Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Yahoo! Mobile. Try it now.
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir
Hey Guys Just chill I think i can comment on reasons to choose ARR over HJ for Hindi Ghajini... 1. Aamir Khan trusts ARR more than anyone else 2. Tamil Ghajini had 2 mesmarizing songs and rest were Ok sort of songs. 3. HJ's music had a lot of South Indian touch in Ghajini which may not be acceptable in Hindi. Remember what happened to Nayak songs. Great songs in South India but just a luke warm response in the north. Imagine Baba song which was re-used in Swades... It sounded better in Hindi than in Telugu/ Tamil. Some songs sound beautiful in South Indian languages... others in Hindi... some in both... ARR knows the pulse... The reason why most of the South Indian MDs could not succeed in North is this. MDs like HJ, Yuvvan although much more talented than many Hindi MDs could not build their empire because of this reason. Apart from ARR and SEL who know the pulse of audience...others find it difficult to establish themselves in Bollywood. godi_smile1 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: well i have read great things in this forum. great informations. but most funny is someone mentioned bollywood never encourages copy cats. is anu malik from hollywood? or anyother bolly composer for that matter. very sad that some people are fanatics here too. some asked not to talk about harris, vidyasagar or yuvan. but all are okay talking about rajnikant or gv prakash. - Bollywood, fun, friendship, sports and more... you name it, we have it.
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir, He loves ARR's music more!
Dear all Ar Fans, If Amir had said that he loved Harris Jayaraj's score for Ghajini, i dont think we all have to read too much , or to create too much of fuss ..Its true that Ghajini is a good musical score and also i dont think its any one's right to say only ARR can produce good music scores ...We all are exposed to many genere of music talents and i should say we all are blessed to hear a lot of music with great quality. I still feel like Harris should break into BollywoodThen only this true talents come out, he is playing within a limited scope ..He should come out and prove his true talent ... ARR on the other part has nothing to prove to anyone and i dont think as TRUE FANS we dont have to get panicked or infact for what.Sense of insecurity and all are of some one Fresh inot the scene not anymore for our ARR. come on guys... Mats --- || V i s h w e s h || <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > He is not a King he is an Emperor. > > Thineshan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > SIVAJI is already a reply to EVERYONE. I > haven't heard criticisms > from anyone except dumb HJ fans. If you guys watched > the movie, ull > know who the true kings are: ARR MD of Style, Rajini > Actor of Style, > and Shankar Director of Style! I hope Shankar now > realizes that > Anniyan is the worst mistake he ever did. Imagine if > ARR was given > the amazing an amazing opportunity like in Anniyan. > He would've > defintely rocked, well he rocks now with sivaji. > Enjoy dont talk > about other MDs here. Now I am totally convinced: > There is only one > musical king now and thats ARR. No if, buts, or > ands. period. > > > . > > > > > > " The search is more important than the > destination " > > - a r rahman - > > > - > Finding fabulous fares is fun. > Let Yahoo! FareChase search your favorite travel > sites to find flight and hotel bargains. Looking for people who are YOUR TYPE? Find them at in.groups.yahoo.com
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir
Though I agree to the point that he copies ARR style and a few of his compositions, we can't simply blame HJ. RHTDM failure was nothing to do with HJ. It was not presented properly to Hindi audience. Or they chose a wrong story to be remade. Minnale songs are awesome. No questions! I personally don't like HJ. I like Vidhyasagar & Bhardhwaj songs than HJ. When Ghajini songs were released, I just wanted to hate it without even listening. I loved talking something bad about those songs. But at the end, HJ became the winner. 'Oru Maalai Ila Veyil', is one of my all time favorites. I don't want to comment about Hindi Ghajini. There might be various reasons behind choosing ARR. ARR did 'Kadhalukku Mariyadhai' Hindi version. It did sound good. And Tamil version had its own peculiarity. Many movies go flop in the BO. We can't blame MD for that. 12B, Lesa Lesa had good songs. But they did not well in the BO. As you all know, this is true in case of ARR too. We get frustrated when the movie fails inspite of having good music. Due to this, good songs go unnoticed. Recent eg. SOK. Kankalal Kaithu Sei En Swasa Katre Swades Bose Kannathil Muthamittal What happened in 80s & 90s?. There were only 4 main singers. SPB, Yesudas, Chitra, & Janaki. Arr changed everything after 'Roja'. Now there are so many singers. We get to hear different voices. Think about the amount of singers, players & MDs (Ranjit Barot, Sridhar, Prakash, HJ, Rehana, ...) he has produced. That's what matters a lot. Being a sole winner, does do good for longer duration. So competition is good! BTW, I am happy to see ARR composing Ghajini coz we can get one more good album. If HJ had been chosen, he would have just dubbed Tamil songs to Hindi. But now we can expect an album that's going to be different from the original. So it's good us! More music! Kalimuthu On 6/21/07, manaf cp <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Yes man, this is the perfect reply. Hjs songs were good. But the fact is that he did not have his own style in music. One guy say that if amir select hj for ghajini hindi it would have been a break for him. One question to them, What happened to RHTDM (the hindi version of minnale)? Why couldnt he got break through? Were minnale songs very bad? But the fact is that he copies ARR in his every compositions. Bollywood will never encourage copycats. Hj stole ARRs own style. In my opinion Even if trying for variety tunes sometimes arr should have been done music in his own style. This is my personal opinion. Look IR, many MDs copied his style, but he did every compositions his own style in every time. No one (his copycats) could beat him. This doesnt mean hj beat ARR. What the point i want to express is that ARR must do music in his own style. Critics will call repeatation. Dont worry , we people like it very much. I hope that GHAJINI will be a reply to every one. Regards __Ready for the edge of your seat? Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. http://tv.yahoo.com/
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir, He loves ARR's music more!
He is not a King he is an Emperor. Thineshan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: SIVAJI is already a reply to EVERYONE. I haven't heard criticisms from anyone except dumb HJ fans. If you guys watched the movie, ull know who the true kings are: ARR MD of Style, Rajini Actor of Style, and Shankar Director of Style! I hope Shankar now realizes that Anniyan is the worst mistake he ever did. Imagine if ARR was given the amazing an amazing opportunity like in Anniyan. He would've defintely rocked, well he rocks now with sivaji. Enjoy dont talk about other MDs here. Now I am totally convinced: There is only one musical king now and thats ARR. No if, buts, or ands. period. . " The search is more important than the destination " - a r rahman - - Finding fabulous fares is fun. Let Yahoo! FareChase search your favorite travel sites to find flight and hotel bargains.
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir
Come on.. stop talking about other MD's in this group. On 6/21/07, manaf cp <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Yes man, this is the perfect reply. Hjs songs were good. But the fact is that he did not have his own style in music. One guy say that if amir select hj for ghajini hindi it would have been a break for him. One question to them, What happened to RHTDM (the hindi version of minnale)? Why couldnt he got break through? Were minnale songs very bad? But the fact is that he copies ARR in his every compositions. Bollywood will never encourage copycats. Hj stole ARRs own style. In my opinion Even if trying for variety tunes sometimes arr should have been done music in his own style. This is my personal opinion. Look IR, many MDs copied his style, but he did every compositions his own style in every time. No one (his copycats) could beat him. This doesnt mean hj beat ARR. What the point i want to express is that ARR must do music in his own style. Critics will call repeatation. Dont worry , we people like it very much. I hope that GHAJINI will be a reply to every one. Regards __Ready for the edge of your seat? Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. http://tv.yahoo.com/ -- Regards, Vasanth TT http://vasanth.tt.googlepages.com
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir, He loves ARR's music more!
well said buddy On 6/21/07, Thineshan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: SIVAJI is already a reply to EVERYONE. I haven't heard criticisms from anyone except dumb HJ fans. If you guys watched the movie, ull know who the true kings are: ARR MD of Style, Rajini Actor of Style, and Shankar Director of Style! I hope Shankar now realizes that Anniyan is the worst mistake he ever did. Imagine if ARR was given the amazing an amazing opportunity like in Anniyan. He would've defintely rocked, well he rocks now with sivaji. Enjoy dont talk about other MDs here. Now I am totally convinced: There is only one musical king now and thats ARR. No if, buts, or ands. period. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , manaf cp <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Yes man, this is the perfect reply. Hjs songs were > good. But the fact is that he did not have his own > style in music. One guy say that if amir select hj for > ghajini hindi it would have been a break for him. One > question to them, What happened to RHTDM (the hindi > version of minnale)? Why couldnt he got break through? > Were minnale songs very bad? But the fact is that he > copies ARR in his every compositions. Bollywood will > never encourage copycats. Hj stole ARRs own style. In > my opinion Even if trying for variety tunes sometimes > arr should have been done music in his own style. This > is my personal opinion. Look IR, many MDs copied his > style, but he did every compositions his own style in > every time. No one (his copycats) could beat him. This > doesnt mean hj beat ARR. What the point i want to > express is that ARR must do music in his own style. > Critics will call repeatation. Dont worry , we people > like it very much. I hope that GHAJINI will be a reply > to every one. > Regards > > > > > __ ___Ready for the edge of your seat? > Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. > http://tv.yahoo.com/ >
Re: [arr] Re: I love Harris Jayarajs music in Ghajini: Aamir
Yes man, this is the perfect reply. Hjs songs were good. But the fact is that he did not have his own style in music. One guy say that if amir select hj for ghajini hindi it would have been a break for him. One question to them, What happened to RHTDM (the hindi version of minnale)? Why couldnt he got break through? Were minnale songs very bad? But the fact is that he copies ARR in his every compositions. Bollywood will never encourage copycats. Hj stole ARRs own style. In my opinion Even if trying for variety tunes sometimes arr should have been done music in his own style. This is my personal opinion. Look IR, many MDs copied his style, but he did every compositions his own style in every time. No one (his copycats) could beat him. This doesnt mean hj beat ARR. What the point i want to express is that ARR must do music in his own style. Critics will call repeatation. Dont worry , we people like it very much. I hope that GHAJINI will be a reply to every one. Regards Ready for the edge of your seat? Check out tonight's top picks on Yahoo! TV. http://tv.yahoo.com/
