Re: [Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
Ian Blenke wrote: Brian West wrote: I would use the latest CVS for one. And try again. Unfortunately, I've tried numerous times to get a current CVS trunk snapshot to talk to *anything*, to no avail. Even getting my Grandstream phones to register with it was an apparent excersize in futility. Dropping back to 0.4.0 *immediately* worked with the same configs. Ok, I've managed to get my Grandstream phones working correctly. With G.711/ulaw and 8 voice frames per packet, they work fine. Until I hard-coded all negotiable codecs to ulaw/alaw and upped the default setting of 1 voice frame per packet, I was getting no voice. Joy. Anyway, the BudgeTone 100's (1.0.3.78) are working fine with Asterisk now, using today's CVS snapshot. Back to the problem at hand: I simply cannot get the IAX/IAX2 registration to "work". Honestly, I'm a bit lost. I'm still getting the same errors: WARNING[14351]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4852 (find_cache): Unable to generate call for 'privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/local' WARNING[14351]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4972 (iax_exists): Unable to make DP cache WARNING[14351]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4852 (find_cache): Unable to generate call for 'privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/local' WARNING[14351]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4994 (iax_canmatch): Unable to make DP cache along with an apparent Registration Refused: NOTICE[9226]: File chan_iax2.c, Line 4341 (socket_read): Registration of 'privatepbx' rejected: Registration Refused on the Public PBX box, I'm getting the following: NOTICE[7176]: File chan_iax2.c, Line 2860 (register_verify): Host privatepbx failed RSA authentication with inkeys 'privatepbx' Now this is the weird part, I can start asterisk with -i or run "init keys" and the keys appear to load just fine: PrivatePBX *CLI> show keys Key Name TypeStatus Sum privatepbx PUBLIC [Loaded] 7ace809ae1c70b1bf4e50586f2d228e9 privatepbx PRIVATE [Loaded] 4288d8b63dd77228ac9a9ceebba335c8 publicpbx PUBLIC [Loaded] 115599073563eec2fd3cfc5e1891ed27 iaxtel PUBLIC [Loaded] d919b3ef03eb4dc54c8fee86bfeeada1 PrivatePBX *CLI> show keys Key Name TypeStatus Sum publicpbx PUBLIC [Loaded] 115599073563eec2fd3cfc5e1891ed27 publicpbx PRIVATE [Loaded] b2b4484bbd90e93ac8e17a05251b561d iaxtel PUBLIC [Loaded] d919b3ef03eb4dc54c8fee86bfeeada1 publicpbx PUBLIC [Loaded] 7ace809ae1c70b1bf4e50586f2d228e9 also, the initial IAX registration appears to work! PrivatePBX *CLI> iax show registry Host UsernamePerceivedRefresh State x.x.x.x:5036 privatepbx y.y.y.y:5036 60 Registered *CLI> iax2 show registry Host UsernamePerceivedRefresh State x.x.x.x:4569 privatepbx y.y.y.y:4569 60 Registered but here's the weird part: if I check back on these registrations periodically, I will see IAX or IAX2 as Rejected, apparently randomly: *CLI> iax show registry Host UsernamePerceivedRefresh State x.x.x.x:5036 privatepbx y.y.y.y:5036 60 Registered *CLI> iax2 show registry Host UsernamePerceivedRefresh State x.x.x.x:5036 privatepbx y.y.y.y:5036 60 Rejected On the other side, I see the registration: PublicPBX *CLI> iax show peers Name/Username HostMask Port Status privatepbxy.y.y.y (D) 255.255.255.255 5036 Unmonitored Gah. In debug mode, I see initial REGREJ messages often when I reload, yet if I wait a bit, I seem to see REJACK messages after a while - but nothing deterministic. Tx-Frame Retry[000] -- Seqno: 01 Type: IAX Subclass: REGREQ Timestamp: 00066ms Callno: 00014 DCall: 00193 [x.x.x.x:5036] Rx-Frame Retry[N/A] -- Seqno: 01 Type: IAX Subclass: ACK Timestamp: 00066ms Callno: 00193 DCall: 00014 [x.x.x.x:5036] Rx-Frame Retry[N/A] -- Seqno: 01 Type: IAX Subclass: REGREJ Timestamp: 00045ms Callno: 00193 DCall: 00014 [x.x.x.x:5036] and then a few frames later: Rx-Frame Retry[No] -- OSeqno: 001 ISeqno: 002 Type: IAX Subclass: REGACK Timestamp: 00061ms SCall: 4 DCall: 1 [66.152.21.108:4569] USERNAME: privatepbx REFRESH : 60 APPARENT ADDRES : IPV4 y.y.y.y:4569 I'm slowly beginning to study these IAX frames to decypher their meanings... This is my current setup, perhaps you can point out what I'm doing wrong (the same diagram from my earlier email stands): PrivatePBX ;iax.conf: [general] ; This appears to work. register => privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED] ;extension.conf: [local] ; Neither of these seem to work. switch => IAX2/privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/local ;switch => IAX/privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/local PublicPBX
Re: [Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
Chris Albertson wrote: I would also like to see a more structured release program. It's kind of scary to tell people that they should "just use the latest CVS code". For testing and development, this isn't a bad thing - as long as the trunk codebase generally *compiles* and *runs* more often than not. I've had no problems compiling the latest snapshots, but running it seems to lead me down a path of frustration - nothing seemed to work as the 0.4.0 release did. For production, a stable release cycle really would be nice. Particularly with a patch history along the stable tree until a next release (0.4.1, 0.4.2, etc, until the 0.5.0 development tree is deemed adequate for a feature freeze to 0.5.0). That's where consultants earn their money. They should be preforming some kind of quality control. You build the code, get it to work, test it and ONLY then install it at a customer's site for final testing. If you don't have a consultent then you do this kind of work yourself. In the OpenSource world, consultants typically implement stable releases of packages - typically for bug reporting if for no other reason. It's difficult to explain to someone why your CVS checkout from 3 months ago exhibits some unexpected flaw - who out there is going to have the same snapshot installed to compare notes? You are right. It would be stupid to install a new untested CVS download on a working PBX system. Granted. It would also be stupid to dictate a code-fork of the Asterisk source base just to have a "stable" reference tree. I'm partial to the Mozilla approach. New development in trunk, branch stable releases with fixes rolled back into trunk as appropriate. How many folks are running 2.6.0preX series Linux kernels on their production servers? This isn't much different, really. I don't mind rolling in a half dozen backports to patch up a 2.4 tree to something I can use, and *depend* on. In the end, I'm really just happy to have something of Asterisk's quality in the OpenSource community. Despite a few minor quirks, 0.4.0 really does seem to work quite well. -- - Ian C. Blenke <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> (This message bound by the following: http://www.nks.net/email_disclaimer.html) ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
Re: [Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
> I would also like to see a more structured release > program. It's kind > of scary to tell people that they should "just use > the latest CVS code". That's where consultants earn their money. They should be preforming some kind of quality control. You build the code, get it to work, test it and ONLY then install it at a customer's site for final testing. If you don't have a consultent then you do this kind of work yourself. You are right. It would be stupid to install a new untested CVS download on a working PBX system. = Chris Albertson Home: 310-376-1029 [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cell: 310-990-7550 Office: 310-336-5189 [EMAIL PROTECTED] KG6OMK __ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software http://sitebuilder.yahoo.com ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
Re: [Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
On Wed, 2003-08-20 at 11:09, Ian Blenke wrote: > Brian West wrote: > > I would use the latest CVS for one. And try again. > > Unfortunately, I've tried numerous times to get a current CVS trunk > snapshot to talk to *anything*, to no avail. Even getting my Grandstream > phones to register with it was an apparent excersize in futility. > Dropping back to 0.4.0 *immediately* worked with the same configs. > > I'll give it a go again with today's snapshot and see if I can get > *anything* to work again. > > Is there any hope for a 0.5.0 release on the horizon? I would also like to see a more structured release program. It's kind of scary to tell people that they should "just use the latest CVS code". Steve ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
Re: [Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
Brian West wrote: I would use the latest CVS for one. And try again. Unfortunately, I've tried numerous times to get a current CVS trunk snapshot to talk to *anything*, to no avail. Even getting my Grandstream phones to register with it was an apparent excersize in futility. Dropping back to 0.4.0 *immediately* worked with the same configs. I'll give it a go again with today's snapshot and see if I can get *anything* to work again. Is there any hope for a 0.5.0 release on the horizon? -- - Ian C. Blenke <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> (This message bound by the following: http://www.nks.net/email_disclaimer.html) ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
Re: [Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
I would use the latest CVS for one. And try again. bkw On Wed, 20 Aug 2003, Ian Blenke wrote: > I'm attempting to get two Asterisk 0.4.0 PBXes to communicate with one > another using IAX/IAX2 trunks. > > I've managed to get a semi-functional NAT Firewall working as a PBX > (with Asterisk running directly on the firewall itself), but there are > issues with bind()ing to various interfaces which is causing outbound > SIP issues. > > To get around these issues, the idea is to do something like this: > > Internet > | >--- > | | > | Public PBX > | > NAT Firewall > | > >|| | > Private PBX Phone Phone ... > > > This way we can run private Asterisk PBXes behind NATting firewalls that > register with a central "public" Asterisk PBX using IAX/IAX2. The phones > can merrily run SIP to the local Private PBX without worrying about NAT > headaches or outbound proxies. > > I've managed to get the PBXes to mutually register correctly: > >Public PBX: > > *CLI> iax show users > Username Secret Authen Def.Context A/C > privatepbxrsadefault No > >Private PBX: > > *CLI> iax show registry > Host Username PerceivedRefresh State > x.x.x.x:5036 privatepbx x.x.x.x:5036 60 Registered > > *CLI> iax2 show registry > Host Username PerceivedRefresh State > x.x.x.x:4569 privatepbx x.x.x.x:4569 60 Registered > > On the Public PBX, I added: > > iax.conf: > > [privatepbx] > type=friend > host=dynamic > ;trunk=yes ;<-- doesn't work without a zap interface for timing > context=outgoing > auth=rsa > inkeys=privatepbx > outkeys=publicpbx > qualify=yes > > extension.conf: > > [outgoing] > include => iaxtel ; IAXTEL > include => fwd ; fwd.pulver.com > include => iptel; iptel.org > include => sipphone ; SIPPhone.com > include => commx; CommunicationsXchange.com > > On the Private PBX, I've added what I think are the appropriate sections: > > iax.conf: > > [general] > register => privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > extension.conf: > > [outgoing] > switch => IAX/privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing > ;exten => s,1,Dial(IAX/privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing,20,tr) > > Whenever I try to route an outbound call, however, I get the following > errors on the private PBX: > > WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4837 (find_cache): Unable to > generate call for 'privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing' > WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4957 (iax_exists): Unable to make > DP cache > WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4837 (find_cache): Unable to > generate call for 'privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing' > WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4979 (iax_canmatch): Unable to > make DP cache > > No IAX traffic appears to go out in response to this.. so I'm guessing I > have another problem. > > Can anyone help point me in the right direction? > > -- > - Ian C. Blenke <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > (This message bound by the following: > http://www.nks.net/email_disclaimer.html) > > > ___ > Asterisk-Users mailing list > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users > ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
[Asterisk-Users] IAX <> IAX trunking... DP cache?
I'm attempting to get two Asterisk 0.4.0 PBXes to communicate with one another using IAX/IAX2 trunks. I've managed to get a semi-functional NAT Firewall working as a PBX (with Asterisk running directly on the firewall itself), but there are issues with bind()ing to various interfaces which is causing outbound SIP issues. To get around these issues, the idea is to do something like this: Internet | --- | | | Public PBX | NAT Firewall | || | Private PBX Phone Phone ... This way we can run private Asterisk PBXes behind NATting firewalls that register with a central "public" Asterisk PBX using IAX/IAX2. The phones can merrily run SIP to the local Private PBX without worrying about NAT headaches or outbound proxies. I've managed to get the PBXes to mutually register correctly: Public PBX: *CLI> iax show users Username Secret Authen Def.Context A/C privatepbxrsadefault No Private PBX: *CLI> iax show registry Host Username PerceivedRefresh State x.x.x.x:5036 privatepbx x.x.x.x:5036 60 Registered *CLI> iax2 show registry Host Username PerceivedRefresh State x.x.x.x:4569 privatepbx x.x.x.x:4569 60 Registered On the Public PBX, I added: iax.conf: [privatepbx] type=friend host=dynamic ;trunk=yes ;<-- doesn't work without a zap interface for timing context=outgoing auth=rsa inkeys=privatepbx outkeys=publicpbx qualify=yes extension.conf: [outgoing] include => iaxtel; IAXTEL include => fwd ; fwd.pulver.com include => iptel ; iptel.org include => sipphone ; SIPPhone.com include => commx ; CommunicationsXchange.com On the Private PBX, I've added what I think are the appropriate sections: iax.conf: [general] register => privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED] extension.conf: [outgoing] switch => IAX/privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing ;exten => s,1,Dial(IAX/privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing,20,tr) Whenever I try to route an outbound call, however, I get the following errors on the private PBX: WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4837 (find_cache): Unable to generate call for 'privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing' WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4957 (iax_exists): Unable to make DP cache WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4837 (find_cache): Unable to generate call for 'privatepbx:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/outgoing' WARNING[15376]: File chan_iax.c, Line 4979 (iax_canmatch): Unable to make DP cache No IAX traffic appears to go out in response to this.. so I'm guessing I have another problem. Can anyone help point me in the right direction? -- - Ian C. Blenke <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> (This message bound by the following: http://www.nks.net/email_disclaimer.html) ___ Asterisk-Users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
