Re: OT: Stress testing tools - OpenSTA vs JMeter

2004-07-02 Thread Mark Drew
Nick
I have used OpenSTA a couple of times and it provides very good stress
testing logs, although I must admit I am a bit rusty on its workings
currently.

With regards to the server side you could enable CFperfmon to get
analysis from that.

The problem (or benefit) on multi-tierd systems is that each
application (db, web server, etc) all have their own log files, so you
can spit it out at each stage to see what is doing what. With
Coldfusion (I presume you are running it) you can at least see some of
this with the debug.

I am not sure of good server side reporting tools, apart from the ones
that come with Windows

Hope that helps a little

MD

On Fri, 2 Jul 2004 10:52:46 +0100, Nick de Voil [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
 Does anyone have a view on which of these is a better tool for stress
 testing a Java-based web app on a remote Linux server and/or on local
 Windows dev boxes? And why? Or is there a better free tool (eg MS WAS)?
 
 What I'd like to achieve is an integrated approach where we can generate
 HTTP requests on the client(s), and record the statuses and timings of the
 responses, but also somehow record/analyse what's happening inside the
 server (Apache, MySQL, JVM, JRun etc) at the same time. Or would it be more
 sensible to use different tools for these two jobs - finding problems vs
 investigating them?
 
 I'm looking to standardize on something for ongoing use as part of a
 development process, so I guess another important thing is the features for
 recording/storing/sharing reasonably complex scenario information.
 
 We're also considering moving to Eclipse/Ant/JUnit - any synergies there
 would be great, which seems to point towards JMeter...but OpenSTA appears a
 more finished application?
 
 Thanks
 
 Nick
 

 [Todays Threads] 
 [This Message] 
 [Subscription] 
 [Fast Unsubscribe] 
 [User Settings]
 [Donations and Support]




OT: Stress testing tools - OpenSTA vs JMeter

2004-07-02 Thread Nick de Voil
Does anyone have a view on which of these is a better tool for stress
testing a Java-based web app on a remote Linux server and/or on local
Windows dev boxes? And why? Or is there a better free tool (eg MS WAS)?

What I'd like to achieve is an integrated approach where we can generate
HTTP requests on the client(s), and record the statuses and timings of the
responses, but also somehow record/analyse what's happening inside the
server (Apache, MySQL, JVM, JRun etc) at the same time. Or would it be more
sensible to use different tools for these two jobs - finding problems vs
investigating them?

I'm looking to standardize on something for ongoing use as part of a
development process, so I guess another important thing is the features for
recording/storing/sharing reasonably complex scenario information.

We're also considering moving to Eclipse/Ant/JUnit - any synergies there
would be great, which seems to point towards JMeter...but OpenSTA appears a
more finished application?

Thanks

Nick
 [Todays Threads] 
 [This Message] 
 [Subscription] 
 [Fast Unsubscribe] 
 [User Settings]
 [Donations and Support]