Re: RE: All 0's MAC Root Bridge [7:48578]

2002-07-12 Thread Priscilla Oppenheimer

Kim Graham wrote:
 
 Sorry for being so vague, it was first thing in the morning,
 just getting my first cup of coffee and rubbing the sleep out
 of my eyes.  (Yes, I need a life if I wake up thinking about
 these questions.)
 
 This is a 6513.
 
 That is what I thought.  The BID is the MAC address on the
 card, hence why I am curious as to how this has come about. :)
 
 Here is the header output of the show  spantree command, the
 second 6513 shows spanning tree as disabled:
 
 VLAN 1
 Spanning tree mode  PVST+
 Spanning tree type  ieee
 Spanning tree enabled
 
 Designated Root 00-00-00-00-00-00
 Designated Root Priority0
 Designated Root Cost0
 Designated Root Port1/0
 Root Max Age   0  sec   Hello Time 0  sec   Forward Delay 0  sec
 
 Bridge ID MAC ADDR  00-00-00-00-00-00
 Bridge ID Priority  32769  (bridge priority: 32768, sys
 ID ext: 1)
 Bridge Max Age 20 sec   Hello Time 2  sec   Forward Delay 15 sec
 
 All the ports show as VLAN1.
 --
 
 As my curiosity grew I checked Per-VLAN.
 Our closests are configured to look at one of the core switches
 as the root bridge, the other core as the secondary root
 bridge.  I went to one of the closets and received the same
 output as above for show spantree.
 But if I issue show spantree  I receive the information
 that shows me which device it uses as the root bridge.
 
 Would it be safe to say then that due to PVST+ the MAC address
 comes out as all zero's when you issue show spantree without
 a VLAN designation?

I guess so. Thanks for discovering this for us. It's pretty strange, but on
the other hand it sort of makes sense. When you do PVST, the MAC address is
different for each VLAN. If you don't specify a VLAN, the output doesn't
know what to say, I guess.

 
 Kim
 
  
  From: Priscilla Oppenheimer 
  Date: 2002/07/11 Thu PM 03:20:41 EDT
  To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Subject: RE: All 0's MAC Root Bridge [7:48578]
  
  Kim Graham wrote:
   
   The other day I was delving a bit into spanning tree and I
 came
   across something that puzzled me.
   
   Searching out which device was the root bridge I found the
 MAC
   address (BID) on the root bridge to be all zero's.  (show
   spantree snippets).
   
   Spanning tree mode  PVST+
   Spanning tree type  ieee
   Designated Root 00-00-00-00-00-00
   Bridge ID MAC ADDR  00-00-00-00-00-00
   
   Without finishing chapter 7 (Spanning Tree) in my LAN
 switching
   book I am puzzled as to whether this is a preset MAC
 address or
   self assigned.
  
  The Bridge ID MAC address is preassigned to the switch by the
 manufacturer.
  The address would be one of the many assigned to the
 supervisor or backplane
  in Cisco's case, depending on the switch model. Which model
 are you using?
  
  Seeing all zeroes is extremely strange, as you know, since
 you're asking
  this question! ;-)
  
  A few things I'm wondering about:
  
  What state was the spanning tree in? Was it still converging?
 Did the outpu
  continue to say this weirness, or did it change after a while?
  For which VLAN were you displaying this information? I notice
 that you're
  doing Per-VLAN Spanning Tree. Could this info be for a VLAN
 that doesn't
  actually exist or for a VLAN where spanning tree is disabled?
 Can you send
  us your config?
   
  I guess the bottom line is that we need more info from you.
  
  Priscilla
  
   
   Any thoughts?  Why or how did this occur?
   
   Kim
 
 




Message Posted at:
http://www.groupstudy.com/form/read.php?f=7i=48705t=48578
--
FAQ, list archives, and subscription info: http://www.groupstudy.com/list/cisco.html
Report misconduct and Nondisclosure violations to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: RE: All 0's MAC Root Bridge [7:48578]

2002-07-11 Thread Kim Graham

Sorry for being so vague, it was first thing in the morning, just getting my
first cup of coffee and rubbing the sleep out of my eyes.  (Yes, I need a
life if I wake up thinking about these questions.)

This is a 6513.

That is what I thought.  The BID is the MAC address on the card, hence why I
am curious as to how this has come about. :)

Here is the header output of the show  spantree command, the second 6513
shows spanning tree as disabled:

VLAN 1
Spanning tree mode  PVST+
Spanning tree type  ieee
Spanning tree enabled

Designated Root 00-00-00-00-00-00
Designated Root Priority0
Designated Root Cost0
Designated Root Port1/0
Root Max Age   0  sec   Hello Time 0  sec   Forward Delay 0  sec

Bridge ID MAC ADDR  00-00-00-00-00-00
Bridge ID Priority  32769  (bridge priority: 32768, sys ID ext: 1)
Bridge Max Age 20 sec   Hello Time 2  sec   Forward Delay 15 sec

All the ports show as VLAN1.
--

As my curiosity grew I checked Per-VLAN.
Our closests are configured to look at one of the core switches as the root
bridge, the other core as the secondary root bridge.  I went to one of the
closets and received the same output as above for show spantree.
But if I issue show spantree  I receive the information that shows me which
device it uses as the root bridge.

Would it be safe to say then that due to PVST+ the MAC address comes out as
all zero's when you issue show spantree without a VLAN designation?

Kim

 
 From: Priscilla Oppenheimer 
 Date: 2002/07/11 Thu PM 03:20:41 EDT
 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Subject: RE: All 0's MAC Root Bridge [7:48578]
 
 Kim Graham wrote:
  
  The other day I was delving a bit into spanning tree and I came
  across something that puzzled me.
  
  Searching out which device was the root bridge I found the MAC
  address (BID) on the root bridge to be all zero's.  (show
  spantree snippets).
  
  Spanning tree mode  PVST+
  Spanning tree type  ieee
  Designated Root 00-00-00-00-00-00
  Bridge ID MAC ADDR  00-00-00-00-00-00
  
  Without finishing chapter 7 (Spanning Tree) in my LAN switching
  book I am puzzled as to whether this is a preset MAC address or
  self assigned.
 
 The Bridge ID MAC address is preassigned to the switch by the manufacturer.
 The address would be one of the many assigned to the supervisor or
backplane
 in Cisco's case, depending on the switch model. Which model are you using?
 
 Seeing all zeroes is extremely strange, as you know, since you're asking
 this question! ;-)
 
 A few things I'm wondering about:
 
 What state was the spanning tree in? Was it still converging? Did the outpu
 continue to say this weirness, or did it change after a while?
 For which VLAN were you displaying this information? I notice that you're
 doing Per-VLAN Spanning Tree. Could this info be for a VLAN that doesn't
 actually exist or for a VLAN where spanning tree is disabled? Can you send
 us your config?
  
 I guess the bottom line is that we need more info from you.
 
 Priscilla
 
  
  Any thoughts?  Why or how did this occur?
  
  Kim




Message Posted at:
http://www.groupstudy.com/form/read.php?f=7i=48626t=48578
--
FAQ, list archives, and subscription info: http://www.groupstudy.com/list/cisco.html
Report misconduct and Nondisclosure violations to [EMAIL PROTECTED]