RE: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-15 Thread Carsten Ziegeler


Reinhard Poetz wrote:
 
 As Michael Gerzabek and I are the committers of this patch some words:
 Yes, we are already using it successfully at some of our customers :-)

Great!

 
 There remains only one problem:
 ---
 In order to build our sources, JCo.jar (SAP Java Connector) is absolutly 
 necessary. As JCo.jar is copyright-protected by SAP I can only offer 
 following 'workaround':
 
 - case1: JCo.jar is not available
   -- during the build of Cocoon our prebuild web3-core.jar is taken
   and the source files are ignored
 
 - case2: JCo.jar is available
   -- during the build of Cocoon our prebuild web3-core.jar is ignored
   and the source files are compiled
 
 
 What do you think? Is it an acceptable solution?
 
I suggest to follow the procedure all other optional components use:
- There is no prebuild jar
- The build system checks, if the required jar (JCo.jar) is available.
  Only if this is the case, the source is compiled

This is done for many components, for example the xmldb stuff or
batik etc.

If you need any help here, I can setup the build system for you.

 Regards,
 Reinhard
 
 PS: We improved some of the classes. If you like to include the 
 connectivity-tool (web3-core) we will provide the new patch.
 
Sounds good! Yes, a new patch would be good, perhaps together
with the above mentioned changes ? ;)

Regards
Carsten

-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Nicola Ken Barozzi

Carsten Ziegeler wrote:
 Hi Team,
 
 I think we should vote on some patches we have in bugzilla.

Thanks Carsten, we need this :-)

 I will try to apply patch 10505, [PATCH] Splitting JVM 1.3 and 1.4 Avalon
 binaries,
 to the 2.0.3 branch asap, in order to get the next release out by monday.

:-D

 And here is the list of patches we could apply for 2.1-dev:
 
 10284:[PATCH] CachingPoint caching algorithm
 This patch seems to make sense - we already discussed it.

+1


 9075:[PATCH] Contribution of SAP R/3(r) connectivity components
 Adding the possibility to access SAP from Cocoon is IMHO a very usefull
 feature. Is someone already using it?

+1

 10540:[PATCH] Make CInclude support select=xpath attribute
 This patch was discussed recently - what's the status?

+0

 And now the patches I don't have information on, perhaps someone of
 you could add it?
 9521:[PATCH] Mozilla script support for simple-xml2html.xsl

+1 it makes the prettydocs view better for mozilla

 9728:[PATCH] CocoonServlet getClassPath() enhancements Tomcat4

It changes classpath behaviour, -1
I'd be +0 if it's possible to enable it via config.

 10208:[PATCH]/[RT] Aggregation and Error Conditions (file not foun

+1

 10411:[PATCH] upgrade POI/HSSF Serilizer to latest development rel

+1

 10429:[PATCH]ParameterSelector:new User doc, overview + examples

+1 with docs review

You forgot:

8614  Enh Oth All [EMAIL PROTECTED] NEW  [PATCH] configurable 
component manager

+1

6879  Enh Oth All [EMAIL PROTECTED] NEW  [PATCH] Cache improvement 
using ESI invalidation protocol

abstain


-- 
Nicola Ken Barozzi   [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 - verba volant, scripta manent -
(discussions get forgotten, just code remains)
-


-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Stephan Michels


On Thu, 11 Jul 2002, Nicola Ken Barozzi wrote:

 Carsten Ziegeler wrote:
  Hi Team,
 
  I think we should vote on some patches we have in bugzilla.

 Thanks Carsten, we need this :-)

  I will try to apply patch 10505, [PATCH] Splitting JVM 1.3 and 1.4 Avalon
  binaries,
  to the 2.0.3 branch asap, in order to get the next release out by monday.

 :-D

+1

  And here is the list of patches we could apply for 2.1-dev:
 
  10284:[PATCH] CachingPoint caching algorithm
  This patch seems to make sense - we already discussed it.

 +1

+0


  9075:[PATCH] Contribution of SAP R/3(r) connectivity components
  Adding the possibility to access SAP from Cocoon is IMHO a very usefull
  feature. Is someone already using it?

 +1

-0. Does these components also work, if the SAP doesn't exits? Perhaps
there should be a condition in the build.xml.

  10540:[PATCH] Make CInclude support select=xpath attribute
  This patch was discussed recently - what's the status?

 +0

+1. That makes really sense. But the CachingCInclude should also be
patched, and also the docs ;-)

  And now the patches I don't have information on, perhaps someone of
  you could add it?
  9521:[PATCH] Mozilla script support for simple-xml2html.xsl

 +1 it makes the prettydocs view better for mozilla

+1. Mozilla is my default browser.

  9728:[PATCH] CocoonServlet getClassPath() enhancements Tomcat4

 It changes classpath behaviour, -1
 I'd be +0 if it's possible to enable it via config.

  10208:[PATCH]/[RT] Aggregation and Error Conditions (file not foun

 +1

+0

  10411:[PATCH] upgrade POI/HSSF Serilizer to latest development rel

 +1

+0

  10429:[PATCH]ParameterSelector:new User doc, overview + examples

 +1 with docs review

+0

 You forgot:

 8614  Enh Oth All [EMAIL PROTECTED] NEW  [PATCH] configurable
 component manager

 +1

+0

 6879  Enh Oth All [EMAIL PROTECTED] NEW  [PATCH] Cache improvement
 using ESI invalidation protocol

 abstain

+0


-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Sylvain Wallez

Nicola Ken Barozzi wrote:

 Carsten Ziegeler wrote:

 Hi Team,

 I think we should vote on some patches we have in bugzilla.


 Thanks Carsten, we need this :-)

 I will try to apply patch 10505, [PATCH] Splitting JVM 1.3 and 1.4 
 Avalon binaries, to the 2.0.3 branch asap, in order to get the next 
 release out by monday.


 :-D


+1000

 And here is the list of patches we could apply for 2.1-dev:

 10284:[PATCH] CachingPoint caching algorithm
 This patch seems to make sense - we already discussed it.


 +1


+1. What about my proposal about explicitely defining cache points in 
the sitemap ?

 9075:[PATCH] Contribution of SAP R/3(r) connectivity components
 Adding the possibility to access SAP from Cocoon is IMHO a very 
 usefull feature. Is someone already using it?


 +1


+1, even if not using. It's also great from the Cocoon marketing POV.

 10540:[PATCH] Make CInclude support select=xpath attribute
 This patch was discussed recently - what's the status?


 +0


-0. What about having a good XInclude and deprecate CInclude ?

 And now the patches I don't have information on, perhaps someone of 
 you could add it?
 9521:[PATCH] Mozilla script support for simple-xml2html.xsl


 +1 it makes the prettydocs view better for mozilla


+1

 9728:[PATCH] CocoonServlet getClassPath() enhancements Tomcat4


 It changes classpath behaviour, -1
 I'd be +0 if it's possible to enable it via config.


-0.5, as it is too much Tomcat-specific and AFAIK, we don't have 
classpath problems on Tomcat.

 10208:[PATCH]/[RT] Aggregation and Error Conditions (file not foun


 +1


Don't know

 10411:[PATCH] upgrade POI/HSSF Serilizer to latest development rel


 +1


+1

 10429:[PATCH]ParameterSelector:new User doc, overview + examples


 +1 with docs review


+1

 You forgot:

 8614  Enh Oth All [EMAIL PROTECTED] NEW  [PATCH] configurable 
 component manager

 +1 


+1

 6879  Enh Oth All [EMAIL PROTECTED] NEW  [PATCH] Cache improvement 
 using ESI invalidation protocol

 abstain


-1. Comments on the patch show that this patch requires more thinking.

Sylvain

-- 
Sylvain Wallez
  Anyware Technologies  Apache Cocoon
  http://www.anyware-tech.com   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]




-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




RE: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Reinhard Poetz

  9075:[PATCH] Contribution of SAP R/3(r) connectivity components
  Adding the possibility to access SAP from Cocoon is IMHO a very 
  usefull feature. Is someone already using it?
 
 
  +1

As Michael Gerzabek and I are the committers of this patch some words:
Yes, we are already using it successfully at some of our customers :-)

- the example comes with it's own sub-sitemap
- we will add a 'welcome'-page with some instructions how you can
  set up  a connection to an SAP-R/3-system
  - add JCo.jar (available at http://service.sap.com/connectors --
if you have a SAP-system you have access to this site)
  - enter the correct logon-parameters in the configuration file

  -- that's it

There was a question: What happens if there is any SAP-system available?

  -- As long as you only watch the welcome-page and don't click on
  the example - nothing

  -- The connection to SAP-R/3 is established at the first time you
  call a pipeline using our RFC-transformer


There remains only one problem:
---
In order to build our sources, JCo.jar (SAP Java Connector) is absolutly 
necessary. As JCo.jar is copyright-protected by SAP I can only offer 
following 'workaround':

- case1: JCo.jar is not available
  -- during the build of Cocoon our prebuild web3-core.jar is taken
  and the source files are ignored

- case2: JCo.jar is available
  -- during the build of Cocoon our prebuild web3-core.jar is ignored
  and the source files are compiled


What do you think? Is it an acceptable solution?

Regards,
Reinhard

PS: We improved some of the classes. If you like to include the 
connectivity-tool (web3-core) we will provide the new patch.






-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Diana Shannon


On Thursday, July 11, 2002, at 02:26  AM, Carsten Ziegeler wrote:

 Hi Team,

 I think we should vote on some patches we have in bugzilla.

 And here is the list of patches we could apply for 2.1-dev:



 10429:[PATCH]ParameterSelector:new User doc, overview + examples

Already applied against 2.1-dev and 2.0.3 yesterday. Sorry, I forgot to 
close it in Bugzilla.

Diana


-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Michael Melhem



On Thu, 11 Jul 2002, Sylvain Wallez wrote:

 Nicola Ken Barozzi wrote:

  Carsten Ziegeler wrote:
 
  Hi Team,
 
  I think we should vote on some patches we have in bugzilla.
 
 
  Thanks Carsten, we need this :-)
 

  And here is the list of patches we could apply for 2.1-dev:
 
  10284:[PATCH] CachingPoint caching algorithm
  This patch seems to make sense - we already discussed it.
 
 
  +1
 

 +1. What about my proposal about explicitely defining cache points in
 the sitemap ?

Yes,  I can see cases where explicit cache points might be useful. Once the above 
patch is appliedit can be easly extended to handle explicit cache points..if we 
decide to go down that path.

Regrards,
Michael Melhem


 --
 Sylvain Wallez
   Anyware Technologies  Apache Cocoon
   http://www.anyware-tech.com   mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]




 -
 To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Ivelin Ivanov


From: Carsten Ziegeler [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Hi Team,

 I think we should vote on some patches we have in bugzilla.

 10540:[PATCH] Make CInclude support select=xpath attribute
 This patch was discussed recently - what's the status?

This patch makes sence. Andy is merging CInclude and XInclude as we
discussed before. Same code base, but support for 2 namespaces : W3C
XInclude and the cocoon/cinclude.
I plan to apply it, although still having problems getting 2.1 working.

Can get past this error, when trying to access any page:

ERROR   (2002-07-06) 15:48.53:878   [sitemap] (/cocoon/samples/welcome)
HttpProcessor[8080][4]/PipelineNode: Error while processing pipeline at
file:/D:/cvs/xml-cocoon2/src/webapp/samples/sitemap.xmap:223:17
org.apache.cocoon.ProcessingException: Lookup of transformer for role 'xslt'
failed.: org.apache.avalon.framework.component.ComponentException:
UnnamedSelector: ComponentSelector could not find the component for hint:
xslt
 at
 at
org.apache.cocoon.components.pipeline.AbstractProcessingPipeline.addTransfor
mer(AbstractProcessingPipeline.java:270)





Ivelin




-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Andrew C. Oliver



10540:[PATCH] Make CInclude support select=xpath attribute
This patch was discussed recently - what's the status?
  

status is:

I'm going to submit another patch (hopefully tonight - current day time 
is morning) which makes the
if statement a bit more clear.  (There was no else, and it was 
questioned, it functions as intended but
if it was questioned, then its not clear ;-) and I'm a code quality nut 
;-) )

Once thats done, this is definitely a 2.1 and not a 2.0.3

Following the application of this patch, I'll submit another patch (as 
time permits) which combines the
CInclude and XInclude code-bases.  I'll use CInclude as the basis as it 
seems to be better (and more
efficient) code in my opinion, while making it operate on the XInclude 
namespace as well.

10411:[PATCH] upgrade POI/HSSF Serilizer to latest development rel
  

+1 (I inteded this for 2.1 and not 2.0.3)

10429:[PATCH]ParameterSelector:new User doc, overview + examples

Carsten


-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]


  





-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [vote]: Applying patches

2002-07-11 Thread Andrew C. Oliver



10540:[PATCH] Make CInclude support select=xpath attribute
This patch was discussed recently - what's the status?
  

new patch is ready (apply the latest and not the earlier versions)  fire 
away.


-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]