[Cooker] 3C905b driver problem

2000-11-06 Thread Guillaume Rousse

3C905b ethernet card uses by default 3c59x module. Using it where
moderate payload (15 simultaneous local ftp connections), i encountered
severe problems (lag, timeout, etc...). Local network topology can be
responsable in part, but i also found this in /var/log/kernel/info :
Nov  6 11:35:17 agathe kernel: eth0: Transmit error, Tx status register
82.
Nov  6 11:36:57 agathe last message repeated 59 times
Nov  6 11:38:22 agathe last message repeated 99 times
Nov  6 11:53:09 agathe last message repeated 12 times
Nov  6 11:54:11 agathe last message repeated 2105 times
etc...
Switching to 3c90x module (the one created by 3Com) solved the problem.
At least it stopped the error messages :-)
Maybe this last should becomes the default driver ?

-- 
Guillaume Rousse

Murphy's law : If anything can go wrong, it will.
O'Tool's commentary : Murphy was an optimist.




Re: [Cooker] 3C905b driver problem

2000-11-06 Thread Florin Grad


Hi yall,

I'm using 2 of these cards on my pc here and it works with no prb using
the 3c59x module...


 3C905b ethernet card uses by default 3c59x module. Using it where
 moderate payload (15 simultaneous local ftp connections), i encountered
 severe problems (lag, timeout, etc...). Local network topology can be
 responsable in part, but i also found this in /var/log/kernel/info :
 Nov  6 11:35:17 agathe kernel: eth0: Transmit error, Tx status register
 82.
 Nov  6 11:36:57 agathe last message repeated 59 times
 Nov  6 11:38:22 agathe last message repeated 99 times
 Nov  6 11:53:09 agathe last message repeated 12 times
 Nov  6 11:54:11 agathe last message repeated 2105 times
 etc...
 Switching to 3c90x module (the one created by 3Com) solved the problem.
 At least it stopped the error messages :-)
 Maybe this last should becomes the default driver ?

-- 
Florin  http://www.linux-mandrake.com




Re: [Cooker] 3C905b driver problem

2000-11-06 Thread Brian J. Murrell

from the quill of Guillaume Rousse [EMAIL PROTECTED] on
scroll [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 3C905b ethernet card uses by default 3c59x module. Using it where
 moderate payload (15 simultaneous local ftp connections), i
 encountered
 severe problems (lag, timeout, etc...). Local network topology can be
 responsable in part, but i also found this in /var/log/kernel/info :
 Nov  6 11:35:17 agathe kernel: eth0: Transmit error, Tx status
 register
 82.

That sounds like a hardware/network problem.  A quick search of the net
finds a really good explanation of exactly what the driver is telling
you:

http://www.beowulf.org/listarchives/linux-vortex-bug/1999/10/att-0004/01-TX-problem.txt

 Switching to 3c90x module (the one created by 3Com) solved the
 problem.
 At least it stopped the error messages :-)
 Maybe this last should becomes the default driver ?

NOO!  That driver is very bad.  When I used to work in the IT
department at TurboLinux I used to change all of our machines from the
3com driver to the Donald Becker driver.  The 3com driver:

o hung the machine for 5-10 seconds when configuring interfaces
o paniced machines when used too many times to reconfigure interfaces
o did not support altering the MTU (in source even) to over 1500 for
  802.1Q routers

b.



-- 
Brian J. Murrell




Re: [Cooker] 3C905b driver problem

2000-11-06 Thread Guillaume Rousse

"Brian J. Murrell" a écrit :
 That sounds like a hardware/network problem.  A quick search of the net
 finds a really good explanation of exactly what the driver is telling
 you:
 
 
http://www.beowulf.org/listarchives/linux-vortex-bug/1999/10/att-0004/01-TX-problem.txt
That supports my primray idea the local network was a piece of shit...
My brillant idea of Mandrake network install to students was a fiasco
:-(

  Switching to 3c90x module (the one created by 3Com) solved the
  problem.
  At least it stopped the error messages :-)
  Maybe this last should becomes the default driver ?
 
 NOO!  That driver is very bad.  When I used to work in the IT
 department at TurboLinux I used to change all of our machines from the
 3com driver to the Donald Becker driver.  The 3com driver:
 
 o hung the machine for 5-10 seconds when configuring interfaces
 o paniced machines when used too many times to reconfigure interfaces
 o did not support altering the MTU (in source even) to over 1500 for
   802.1Q routers
Ok, thanks for the info. Now i know how to choose :-)

-- 
Guillaume Rousse

Murphy's law : If anything can go wrong, it will.
O'Tool's commentary : Murphy was an optimist.