Bug#320024: Processed: Combine fai-cd bugs
Hi, On Monday 17 October 2005 01:18, the BTS wrote: merge 329547 320024 Bug#320024: fai-cd does not work with sarge Bug#329547: fai-cd: sources.list should be configurable Merged 320024 329547. Aehm, I'm not so sure if this was a good idea: 320024 could be fixed within sarge, where 329547 maybe not. (If we only wanted to fix the issues in sid, merging is certainly a good idea.) regards, Holger pgpsXPvq1wvvk.pgp Description: PGP signature
Bug#320024: Processed: Combine fai-cd bugs
Hi, On Monday 17 October 2005 01:18, the BTS wrote: merge 329547 320024 Bug#320024: fai-cd does not work with sarge Bug#329547: fai-cd: sources.list should be configurable Merged 320024 329547. Aehm, I'm not so sure if this was a good idea: 320024 could be fixed within sarge, where 329547 maybe not. (If we only wanted to fix the issues in sid, merging is certainly a good idea.) But properly fixing #320024 certainly demands a solution similar to my suggestion, which is #329547. Thus I'd say this merge was not that wrong; but if it was, anyone is free to unmerge these bugs. Regards, Michael signature.asc Description: Digital signature
Bug#320024: Processed: Combine fai-cd bugs
Hi, no need to cc: on mails to the fai-BTS, i'm subscribed to the package fai... ;-) On Monday 17 October 2005 16:55, you wrote: But properly fixing #320024 certainly demands a solution similar to my suggestion, which is #329547. As said: maybe we dont want to properly fix #320024, because a proper fix (as is required by #329547) might not be accepted in sarge. And if Thomas now uploads a 2.8.4.1 which fixes #320024, #329547 will also be closed. (Or maybe #320024 does not gets closed as the bugs are merged, not 100% sure.) That's all I wanted to say. Thus I'd say this merge was not that wrong; but if it was, anyone is free to unmerge these bugs. I never said it was wrong. I only said it might be wrong depending on our target ;) regards, Holger pgptmVCFnHqT3.pgp Description: PGP signature
Bug#320024: Processed: Combine fai-cd bugs
[...] As said: maybe we dont want to properly fix #320024, because a proper fix (as is required by #329547) might not be accepted in sarge. And if Thomas now uploads a 2.8.4.1 which fixes #320024, #329547 will also be closed. (Or maybe #320024 does not gets closed as the bugs are merged, not 100% sure.) IMHO we should try to find a proper fix and try to get it accepted by the Stable Release Managers - if they don't accept that, we should first unmerge those bug reports. Would that be fine? Regards, Michael signature.asc Description: Digital signature
Bug#320024: Processed: Combine fai-cd bugs
convinced that I need to send this through here... On Mon, 2005-10-17 at 16:55 +0200, Michael Tautschnig wrote: Hi, On Monday 17 October 2005 01:18, the BTS wrote: merge 329547 320024 Bug#320024: fai-cd does not work with sarge Bug#329547: fai-cd: sources.list should be configurable Merged 320024 329547. Aehm, I'm not so sure if this was a good idea: 320024 could be fixed within sarge, where 329547 maybe not. (If we only wanted to fix the issues in sid, merging is certainly a good idea.) But properly fixing #320024 certainly demands a solution similar to my suggestion, which is #329547. Thus I'd say this merge was not that wrong; but if it was, anyone is free to unmerge these bugs. Michael, not quite. This is all a bit complex because of the exact wording that is used in the bugreports: Fixing 320024 just puts testing instead of stable into the sources list. But that's not enought to get to a working FAI cd. Fixing 329547 so the worst symptom is gone, namely, the fai cd cannot install a system properly, is only taking contrib and non-free out of line 214 in fai-cd. This, again, does not fix 329547 as requested in it's title sources.list should be configurable - sources list won't get any more configurable by removing main and contrib from line 214. Possible solutions extend 320024, so it's clear that there is more broken than just using testing instead of stable, namely contrib and non-free in the same line won't result in a working cd for now. When we fix this, the bad symtom of 329547 is gone. So we set 329547 back to wishlist level and can make it real nice sometime. I'd like to do the bugfixing and testing and checking in to svn work, who does the bts stuff? :) Henning -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of unsubscribe. Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Bug#320024: Processed: Combine fai-cd bugs
[...] I'd like to do the bugfixing and testing and checking in to svn work, who does the bts stuff? :) BTS: Done. 'til soon, Michael signature.asc Description: Digital signature
