Re: Legal question about a model

2004-01-14 Thread MJ Ray
On 2004-01-13 20:36:09 + Roland Marcus Rutschmann 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:


The software is totally under GPL but ships with a graphical 
head-model that 
is confined to the use with tempo itself. (And this model is needed)

Is there any other possibility than bringing it into non-free?


Convince them to place the model under a GPL-compatible free software 
licence.




Re: Re: Legal question about a model

2004-01-14 Thread Roland Marcus Rutschmann
Hi,

The software is totally under GPL but ships with a graphical head-model that 
 is confined to the use with tempo itself. (And this model is needed)
 Is there any other possibility than bringing it into non-free? 
 Convince them to place the model under a GPL-compatible free software
 licence.

That's not so easy. The author (or better his university) has licensed this 
model for the purpose of this program. So I'd had to either convince the 
company it was licensed from (which wants to make money with such models) or 
the university to pay more so this model can than be included in debian which 
I think is not very realistic.

I take the answer than as a complete No.

Regards,

Roland
 
-- 

Roland Marcus Rutschmann [EMAIL PROTECTED]
gpg-key: http://neuro.psychologie.uni-oldenburg.de/~rutschmann/ich/




pgpN3ZbgoENnr.pgp
Description: signature


Re: Legal question about a model

2004-01-14 Thread Anthony DeRobertis

On Jan 13, 2004, at 15:36, Roland Marcus Rutschmann wrote:


Unfortunatly there is a DFSG problem:
The software is totally under GPL but ships with a graphical 
head-model that

is confined to the use with tempo itself. (And this model is needed)
Is there any other possibility than bringing it into non-free?


You could separate the model out, put that in non-free, and put the GPL 
part in contrib. Hope that some day a free model comes along.




Legal question about a model

2004-01-13 Thread Roland Marcus Rutschmann
Hi,

I found a new very promissing software for graphical mapping of EEG at
http://tempo.sourceforge.net/

I contacted the author and filed an ITP. Preliminary debian packages at:
http://neuro.psychologie.uni-oldenburg.de/debian/dists/unstable/main/

Unfortunatly there is a DFSG problem:
The software is totally under GPL but ships with a graphical head-model that 
is confined to the use with tempo itself. (And this model is needed)
Is there any other possibility than bringing it into non-free?

I think this is like an icon that must only use with the original program or 
how is the legal view on this.

Regards,

Roland

-- 
Dr. Roland Marcus Rutschmann [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Dep. of Psychology, Univ. Oldenburg, Fak.4/A6, 26111 Oldenburg
Tel.: 0441 798 2836 Fax: +49 441 7985170,
http://neuro.psychologie.uni-oldenburg.de/~rutschmann


pgp37nvFhJvuZ.pgp
Description: signature