Re: Package configuration at installtime (was Re: Debian VS. Red Hat)

2000-09-14 Thread Jonathan D. Proulx
On Wed, Sep 13, 2000 at 02:53:56PM -0400, Fraser Campbell wrote:
:Jonathan D. Proulx wrote:

:: some glowing things about install time configuration in debian

: some love hate things about the same

:At work we use almost exclusively RedHat because of the kickstart install
:option.  I can make a kickstart file, put configuration information in the
:post install (of the kickstart) and with one press of the button, RedHat is
:installed, configured and running.  That is not exaggerating (for those who
:haven't done it, press enter at the boot prompt, it installs ... press
:enter when it's done and it reboots and works.

I'm truthfully in the same situation, although I've been less
successful with kickstart.  I'd say it's a beautiful thing 85-90% of
the time (which is damned good)

I keep telling my self that installation is not really the most time
consuming thing I'm going to do with a given system (security
monitoring and remediation is :( but this is why I've not pushed for a
policy change to debian (unlike a lot of places users can install what
ever they want so we have RH, Debian, Slackware, SuSe, and some home
brewed stuff just on the GNU/Linux side (then there's BSD's, Sun's,
DEC's Wins Macs.))

I think there's a flag to make dpkg accept all default settings (been
meaning to check that man page), so yes a silencer would be a good
thing too.

For the system I'm sitting at though I like the controll.

-Jon



Re: Package configuration at installtime (was Re: Debian VS. Red Hat)

2000-09-13 Thread Joey Hess
Fraser Campbell wrote:
 It would be extremely useful if dpkg had a --default-config option or
 something like that ... some way to ensure that packages install with
 absolutely no prompting.  Is there any way to do this now?  If there were
 it would be very easy to script a Debian install similar to kickstart.

Debconf addresses this on the package level, and the upcoming debian
installer rewrite will address this on the install level.

-- 
see shy jo