Fw: Depot

2004-10-31 Thread Adam R. B. Jack
Sent from wrong account...

- Original Message - 
From: Adam Jack [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: Depot Development [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Sunday, October 31, 2004 6:26 AM
Subject: Depot


 Folks

 Sorry I've been offline a while, I've had other priorities to take care
of.

 I will be sad to let Depot go, but I suspect it is time. I am starting to
 believe that without a lot more community drive (or just outright
individual
 stubbornness to continue) that something like a version/repository idea is
 too much to pull off. Further, I suspect that Javasoft ought be handling
it,
 not other groups. Also, I do suspect we tried to do too much (and yes, I
 probably was over enthusiastic and helped over engineer some parts) so
 couldn't keep up with it. That, and (for me) the transition into
incubation
 caused too much environment awkwardness, and I lost momentum.

 Whatever the case, long and the short is that we didn't seem to build on a
 simple use case, we didn't use it first and code it second. Basically it
 stagnated underneath us. I don't think I'll ever quite understand why, but
 despite technical merits (IMHO) something just didn't spark others. Maybe
 marketing, maybe star alignment, definitely community.

 That all said, I really really struggle with this. So much effort, so much
 good stuff, so close. Gak! I hate letting go.

 regards,

 Adam




Re: Fw: Depot

2004-10-31 Thread Niclas Hedhman
On Sunday 31 October 2004 22:54, Adam R. B. Jack wrote:

 Whatever the case, long and the short is that we didn't seem to build on
 a simple use case, we didn't use it first and code it second. Basically
 it stagnated underneath us. I don't think I'll ever quite understand why,
 but despite technical merits (IMHO) something just didn't spark others.
 Maybe marketing, maybe star alignment, definitely community.

You might add; too many can't wait for it too be ready, so roll your own.
And once you get something operational, it is hard to jump in to Depot and 
'start over' again.


Cheers
Niclas
-- 
   +--//---+
  / http://www.bali.ac/
 / http://niclas.hedhman.org / 
+--//---+