Re: Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
Thanks Pablo and Brian! We're moving into development phase and we'll be ready for some code reviews. Jakub will be tagging you on those! On 2020/11/06 18:08:25, Brian Hulette wrote: > Feel free to triage some reviews to me Pablo :) > For larger questions about dividing up contributions and code architecture > questions (items 2 and 3) - I think dev@ threads or the slack channel would > be a good place to discuss anything that can't happen in a GitHub review. > It's good for such discussions to be public and archived. > > Brian > > On Thu, Nov 5, 2020 at 12:45 PM Pablo Estrada wrote: > > > For code review / changes / merges, committers are all that's necessary, > > and I am happy to help with anything that requires extra PMC privileges > > (also happy to do code reviews). > > > > You can mention me in PRs, and I'm happy to try and triage to other active > > committers. > > Best > > -P. > > > > > > On Thu, Nov 5, 2020 at 12:02 PM Gris Cuevas wrote: > > > >> The reason why I was asking a PMC member was to minimize dependencies in > >> permissions needed for code/reviews, commits, etc. > >> > >> I don't have full visibility to confirm that any committer could help > >> here. If that is the case then we can cast a broader net. > >> > >> Even if I am a committer, I can't help the team since I don't have enough > >> bandwidth nor extensive experience developing websites. > >> > >> On 2020/11/04 17:27:53, Austin Bennett > >> wrote: > >> > And, @Griselda Cuevas -- not meaning to change focus > >> of > >> > thread. It seemed you might have the ability to cast a wider net. > >> But, I > >> > also might be off on the differences in roles/rights/responsibilities. > >> > > >> > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 9:26 AM Austin Bennett < > >> whatwouldausti...@gmail.com> > >> > wrote: > >> > > >> > > To understand differences in PMC vs committer --> would like to > >> understand > >> > > why a committer doesn't suffice for the listed requests (and @Griselda > >> > > Cuevas you are a committer, but it seems you'd > >> > > potentially just want another committer to also review). > >> > > > >> > > It seems the website is less about shifting the direction of the > >> project > >> > > or exposing APIs that we may feel compelled to support long term, > >> which is > >> > > why I naively assume PMC not especially needed (and it does look like > >> this > >> > > is being done with full visibility to PMC at a high level). > >> > > > >> > > > >> > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 8:35 AM Gris Cuevas wrote: > >> > > > >> > >> Hi folks, > >> > >> > >> > >> We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we > >> > >> need a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the > >> following: > >> > >> - Review of contribution > >> > >> - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide > >> contributions > >> > >> to make them easier to review/edit > >> > >> - Code architecture questions > >> > >> > >> > >> And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone > >> > >> volunteer to help us with this? > >> > >> > >> > >> Gris > >> > >> > >> > > > >> > > >> > > >
Re: Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
Feel free to triage some reviews to me Pablo :) For larger questions about dividing up contributions and code architecture questions (items 2 and 3) - I think dev@ threads or the slack channel would be a good place to discuss anything that can't happen in a GitHub review. It's good for such discussions to be public and archived. Brian On Thu, Nov 5, 2020 at 12:45 PM Pablo Estrada wrote: > For code review / changes / merges, committers are all that's necessary, > and I am happy to help with anything that requires extra PMC privileges > (also happy to do code reviews). > > You can mention me in PRs, and I'm happy to try and triage to other active > committers. > Best > -P. > > > On Thu, Nov 5, 2020 at 12:02 PM Gris Cuevas wrote: > >> The reason why I was asking a PMC member was to minimize dependencies in >> permissions needed for code/reviews, commits, etc. >> >> I don't have full visibility to confirm that any committer could help >> here. If that is the case then we can cast a broader net. >> >> Even if I am a committer, I can't help the team since I don't have enough >> bandwidth nor extensive experience developing websites. >> >> On 2020/11/04 17:27:53, Austin Bennett >> wrote: >> > And, @Griselda Cuevas -- not meaning to change focus >> of >> > thread. It seemed you might have the ability to cast a wider net. >> But, I >> > also might be off on the differences in roles/rights/responsibilities. >> > >> > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 9:26 AM Austin Bennett < >> whatwouldausti...@gmail.com> >> > wrote: >> > >> > > To understand differences in PMC vs committer --> would like to >> understand >> > > why a committer doesn't suffice for the listed requests (and @Griselda >> > > Cuevas you are a committer, but it seems you'd >> > > potentially just want another committer to also review). >> > > >> > > It seems the website is less about shifting the direction of the >> project >> > > or exposing APIs that we may feel compelled to support long term, >> which is >> > > why I naively assume PMC not especially needed (and it does look like >> this >> > > is being done with full visibility to PMC at a high level). >> > > >> > > >> > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 8:35 AM Gris Cuevas wrote: >> > > >> > >> Hi folks, >> > >> >> > >> We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we >> > >> need a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the >> following: >> > >> - Review of contribution >> > >> - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide >> contributions >> > >> to make them easier to review/edit >> > >> - Code architecture questions >> > >> >> > >> And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone >> > >> volunteer to help us with this? >> > >> >> > >> Gris >> > >> >> > > >> > >> >
Re: Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
For code review / changes / merges, committers are all that's necessary, and I am happy to help with anything that requires extra PMC privileges (also happy to do code reviews). You can mention me in PRs, and I'm happy to try and triage to other active committers. Best -P. On Thu, Nov 5, 2020 at 12:02 PM Gris Cuevas wrote: > The reason why I was asking a PMC member was to minimize dependencies in > permissions needed for code/reviews, commits, etc. > > I don't have full visibility to confirm that any committer could help > here. If that is the case then we can cast a broader net. > > Even if I am a committer, I can't help the team since I don't have enough > bandwidth nor extensive experience developing websites. > > On 2020/11/04 17:27:53, Austin Bennett > wrote: > > And, @Griselda Cuevas -- not meaning to change focus > of > > thread. It seemed you might have the ability to cast a wider net. But, > I > > also might be off on the differences in roles/rights/responsibilities. > > > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 9:26 AM Austin Bennett < > whatwouldausti...@gmail.com> > > wrote: > > > > > To understand differences in PMC vs committer --> would like to > understand > > > why a committer doesn't suffice for the listed requests (and @Griselda > > > Cuevas you are a committer, but it seems you'd > > > potentially just want another committer to also review). > > > > > > It seems the website is less about shifting the direction of the > project > > > or exposing APIs that we may feel compelled to support long term, > which is > > > why I naively assume PMC not especially needed (and it does look like > this > > > is being done with full visibility to PMC at a high level). > > > > > > > > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 8:35 AM Gris Cuevas wrote: > > > > > >> Hi folks, > > >> > > >> We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we > > >> need a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the > following: > > >> - Review of contribution > > >> - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide > contributions > > >> to make them easier to review/edit > > >> - Code architecture questions > > >> > > >> And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone > > >> volunteer to help us with this? > > >> > > >> Gris > > >> > > > > > >
Re: Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
The reason why I was asking a PMC member was to minimize dependencies in permissions needed for code/reviews, commits, etc. I don't have full visibility to confirm that any committer could help here. If that is the case then we can cast a broader net. Even if I am a committer, I can't help the team since I don't have enough bandwidth nor extensive experience developing websites. On 2020/11/04 17:27:53, Austin Bennett wrote: > And, @Griselda Cuevas -- not meaning to change focus of > thread. It seemed you might have the ability to cast a wider net. But, I > also might be off on the differences in roles/rights/responsibilities. > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 9:26 AM Austin Bennett > wrote: > > > To understand differences in PMC vs committer --> would like to understand > > why a committer doesn't suffice for the listed requests (and @Griselda > > Cuevas you are a committer, but it seems you'd > > potentially just want another committer to also review). > > > > It seems the website is less about shifting the direction of the project > > or exposing APIs that we may feel compelled to support long term, which is > > why I naively assume PMC not especially needed (and it does look like this > > is being done with full visibility to PMC at a high level). > > > > > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 8:35 AM Gris Cuevas wrote: > > > >> Hi folks, > >> > >> We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we > >> need a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the following: > >> - Review of contribution > >> - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide contributions > >> to make them easier to review/edit > >> - Code architecture questions > >> > >> And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone > >> volunteer to help us with this? > >> > >> Gris > >> > > >
Re: Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
And, @Griselda Cuevas -- not meaning to change focus of thread. It seemed you might have the ability to cast a wider net. But, I also might be off on the differences in roles/rights/responsibilities. On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 9:26 AM Austin Bennett wrote: > To understand differences in PMC vs committer --> would like to understand > why a committer doesn't suffice for the listed requests (and @Griselda > Cuevas you are a committer, but it seems you'd > potentially just want another committer to also review). > > It seems the website is less about shifting the direction of the project > or exposing APIs that we may feel compelled to support long term, which is > why I naively assume PMC not especially needed (and it does look like this > is being done with full visibility to PMC at a high level). > > > On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 8:35 AM Gris Cuevas wrote: > >> Hi folks, >> >> We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we >> need a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the following: >> - Review of contribution >> - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide contributions >> to make them easier to review/edit >> - Code architecture questions >> >> And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone >> volunteer to help us with this? >> >> Gris >> >
Re: Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
To understand differences in PMC vs committer --> would like to understand why a committer doesn't suffice for the listed requests (and @Griselda Cuevas you are a committer, but it seems you'd potentially just want another committer to also review). It seems the website is less about shifting the direction of the project or exposing APIs that we may feel compelled to support long term, which is why I naively assume PMC not especially needed (and it does look like this is being done with full visibility to PMC at a high level). On Wed, Nov 4, 2020 at 8:35 AM Gris Cuevas wrote: > Hi folks, > > We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we need > a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the following: > - Review of contribution > - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide contributions to > make them easier to review/edit > - Code architecture questions > > And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone > volunteer to help us with this? > > Gris >
Looking for a PMC member to help with website development
Hi folks, We're going to move into development phase for the new website and we need a point of contact in the PMC who could help us with the following: - Review of contribution - Input on implementation questions such as how to divide contributions to make them easier to review/edit - Code architecture questions And other questions that come up from the development, would anyone volunteer to help us with this? Gris
