Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

Jira task to move flexunit sources 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-6152 is still open.. It might help 
to speed up the migration if you vote for this task.

Thx
Cyrill

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Alex Harui]

On 4/14/13 6:52 AM, "Michael A. Labriola" 
wrote:

>> My understanding is that, from a donation standpoint, it is ok to have
>> binaries in the donation as long as you legally have the right to donate
>> them.  Then, at some point, the binaries "must" be removed because >Apache is
>> all about source.
> 
> 
> Right, that's my point. We don't have permission to donate those two binaries.
Does Git have a "remove from repo and history"?  SVN doesn't.  This article
implies that it does:

http://dalibornasevic.com/posts/2-permanently-remove-files-and-folders-from-
a-git-repository
-- 
Alex Harui
Flex SDK Team
Adobe Systems, Inc.
http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>Are those in adobe's jira? Tried to find them but without succes.

Side note, we also have a build setup and all scripts to donate:

http://flexunit.digitalprimates.net:8080/

Mike

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>Is that branch (with removed harmcrest dependencies) also in github.. because 
>as far as I can see there is only one branch (master) in github.

Correct. We only leave master under the main github repo and contributors work 
in their own forks. That was out model

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

> There were only a few open issues. We will need to recreate as they were 
> apparently lost when Adobe's jira moved.

>>Are those in adobe's jira? Tried to find them but without succes.

Correct, that's what  I said. They were lost when Adobe moved

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>My understanding is that, from a donation standpoint, it is ok to have 
>binaries in the donation as long as you legally have the right to donate them. 
> Then, at some point, the binaries "must" be removed because >Apache is all 
>about source.


Right, that's my point. We don't have permission to donate those two binaries. 

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

> There were only a few open issues. We will need to recreate as they were 
> apparently lost when Adobe's jira moved.

Are those in adobe's jira? Tried to find them but without succes.

Cyrill

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

Infra task to import  git repo is created. 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-6152

Sent from my iPhone

On 14.04.2013, at 11:20, "Michael A. Labriola"  
wrote:

>> Just to double check: The sources on
>> https://github.com/flexunit/flexunit are the most up-to-date?
> 
> Yes, those are the most current now getting back into this, we do have a 
> bit of complexity. Sorry, its been a while since I thought about this.
> 
> Right now the version in git references the FlexUnit .9 swc and the 
> hamcrest.swc. Adobe hasn't donated FlexUnit .9 so we really can't just 
> include that and although there was talk of moving hamcrest here, that hasn't 
> happened. A long while ago, I made a version that removed these dependencies. 
> We probably need to move that branch as our master however, that brings 
> up a larger question.
> 
> If we move the entire repo, then that would mean there is a copy of both of 
> these binaries in the history of the repo are we violating anything by 
> doing this?
> 
> Mike
> 
> 

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Alex Harui]

On 4/13/13 8:20 PM, "Michael A. Labriola" 
wrote:

> If we move the entire repo, then that would mean there is a copy of both of
> these binaries in the history of the repo are we violating anything by
> doing this?
> 
My understanding is that, from a donation standpoint, it is ok to have
binaries in the donation as long as you legally have the right to donate
them.  Then, at some point, the binaries "must" be removed because Apache is
all about source.

-- 
Alex Harui
Flex SDK Team
Adobe Systems, Inc.
http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

> Right now the version in git references the FlexUnit .9 swc and the 
> hamcrest.swc. Adobe hasn't donated FlexUnit .9 so we really can't just 
> include that and although there was talk of moving hamcrest here, that hasn't 
> happened. A long while ago, I made a version that removed these dependencies. 
> We probably need to move that branch as our master however, that brings 
> up a larger question.

Is that branch (with removed harmcrest dependencies) also in github..
because as far as I can see there is only one branch (master) in
github.

> If we move the entire repo, then that would mean there is a copy of both of 
> these binaries in the history of the repo are we violating anything by 
> doing this?

Good question.. in flex sdk were also a few binaries that have been
removed only after donation.. so it's probably allright but I'm not
sure.

Cyrill

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>Just to double check: The sources on
>https://github.com/flexunit/flexunit are the most up-to-date?

Yes, those are the most current now getting back into this, we do have a 
bit of complexity. Sorry, its been a while since I thought about this.

Right now the version in git references the FlexUnit .9 swc and the 
hamcrest.swc. Adobe hasn't donated FlexUnit .9 so we really can't just include 
that and although there was talk of moving hamcrest here, that hasn't happened. 
A long while ago, I made a version that removed these dependencies. We probably 
need to move that branch as our master however, that brings up a larger 
question.

If we move the entire repo, then that would mean there is a copy of both of 
these binaries in the history of the repo are we violating anything by 
doing this?

Mike

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

Just to double check: The sources on
https://github.com/flexunit/flexunit are the most up-to-date?

Cyrill

On Sun, Apr 14, 2013 at 4:29 AM, Michael A. Labriola
 wrote:
>>Beside the source code there is also documentation wiki, asdoc, open issues 
>>(are there open issues? :)) we might bring over to apache. Did you plan to 
>>donate those too to Apache.
>
> Yes in all cases. Much of it is already checked into git. I sent links to the 
> few things that can also come over that were not.
>
> Mike
>

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>Beside the source code there is also documentation wiki, asdoc, open issues 
>(are there open issues? :)) we might bring over to apache. Did you plan to 
>donate those too to Apache.

Yes in all cases. Much of it is already checked into git. I sent links to the 
few things that can also come over that were not.

Mike

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

http://flexunit.org/
http://tutorials.digitalprimates.net/

There are some open pull requests in gtihub that I haven't applied as I wasn't 
sure how to handle post donation. There were only a few open issues. We will 
need to recreate as they were apparently lost when Adobe's jira moved.

Mike


-Original Message-
From: Cyrill Zadra [mailto:cyrill.za...@gmail.com] 
Sent: Saturday, April 13, 2013 4:49 AM
To: dev@flex.apache.org
Subject: Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

Hi Mike

Beside the source code there is also documentation wiki, asdoc, open issues 
(are there open issues? :)) we might bring over to apache. Did you plan to 
donate those too to Apache.

Cyrill

On Sat, Apr 13, 2013 at 2:03 PM, Alex Harui  wrote:
> I would vote for flex-flexunit
>
>
> On 4/12/13 5:43 PM, "Cyrill Zadra"  wrote:
>
>> Ok ..I'll try to :-).
>>
>> Where is FlexUnit supposed to land? In utilities repo or in a own 
>> repo named "flex-flexunit" or just "flex-unit"?
>>
>> Cyrill
>>
>> On 13.04.2013, at 02:19, "Michael A. Labriola" 
>> 
>> wrote:
>>
>>>> OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this 
>>>> happen?
>>>
>>> Help please.
>>>
>
> --
> Alex Harui
> Flex SDK Team
> Adobe Systems, Inc.
> http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui
>

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

Hi Mike

Beside the source code there is also documentation wiki, asdoc, open
issues (are there open issues? :)) we might bring over to apache. Did
you plan to donate those too to Apache.

Cyrill

On Sat, Apr 13, 2013 at 2:03 PM, Alex Harui  wrote:
> I would vote for flex-flexunit
>
>
> On 4/12/13 5:43 PM, "Cyrill Zadra"  wrote:
>
>> Ok ..I'll try to :-).
>>
>> Where is FlexUnit supposed to land? In utilities repo or in a own repo named
>> "flex-flexunit" or just "flex-unit"?
>>
>> Cyrill
>>
>> On 13.04.2013, at 02:19, "Michael A. Labriola" 
>> wrote:
>>
 OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this 
 happen?
>>>
>>> Help please.
>>>
>
> --
> Alex Harui
> Flex SDK Team
> Adobe Systems, Inc.
> http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui
>

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Alex Harui]

I would vote for flex-flexunit


On 4/12/13 5:43 PM, "Cyrill Zadra"  wrote:

> Ok ..I'll try to :-).
> 
> Where is FlexUnit supposed to land? In utilities repo or in a own repo named
> "flex-flexunit" or just "flex-unit"?
> 
> Cyrill
> 
> On 13.04.2013, at 02:19, "Michael A. Labriola" 
> wrote:
> 
>>> OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this happen?
>> 
>> Help please.
>> 

-- 
Alex Harui
Flex SDK Team
Adobe Systems, Inc.
http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

The FlexUnit sources on https://github.com/flexunit/flexunit.git are
uptodate? Or is it a local git repo you mentioned?

On Sat, Apr 13, 2013 at 8:43 AM, Cyrill Zadra  wrote:
> Ok ..I'll try to :-).
>
> Where is FlexUnit supposed to land? In utilities repo or in a own repo named 
> "flex-flexunit" or just "flex-unit"?
>
> Cyrill
>
> On 13.04.2013, at 02:19, "Michael A. Labriola"  
> wrote:
>
>>> OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this happen?
>>
>> Help please.
>>

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

Ok ..I'll try to :-). 

Where is FlexUnit supposed to land? In utilities repo or in a own repo named 
"flex-flexunit" or just "flex-unit"?

Cyrill

On 13.04.2013, at 02:19, "Michael A. Labriola"  
wrote:

>> OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this happen?
> 
> Help please.
> 

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this happen?

Help please.

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Alex Harui]

On 4/12/13 10:49 AM, "Michael A. Labriola" 
wrote:

>>> Now that we moved to git .. is there anything else that prevents the
>>> donation of FlexUnit? Can I help here out to make it happen?
>> I would imagine Mike L would be pleased if you helped him out by requesting
>> the git repo from Infra.  I'm not sure how Git-to-Git migration works.   Is
>> there an export/import capability that Infra runs?
> 
> We could literally give them the repo and they could stick it on a server.
> Since git is file system based, they shouldn't need more than that
OK, do you want Cyrill's help or do you have the cycles to make this happen?

-- 
Alex Harui
Flex SDK Team
Adobe Systems, Inc.
http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>> Now that we moved to git .. is there anything else that prevents the 
>> donation of FlexUnit? Can I help here out to make it happen?
>I would imagine Mike L would be pleased if you helped him out by requesting
>the git repo from Infra.  I'm not sure how Git-to-Git migration works.   Is
>there an export/import capability that Infra runs?

We could literally give them the repo and they could stick it on a server. 
Since git is file system based, they shouldn't need more than that

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Alex Harui]

On 4/12/13 9:40 AM, "Cyrill Zadra"  wrote:

> Now that we moved to git .. is there anything else that prevents the
> donation of FlexUnit? Can I help here out to make it happen?
I would imagine Mike L would be pleased if you helped him out by requesting
the git repo from Infra.  I'm not sure how Git-to-Git migration works.   Is
there an export/import capability that Infra runs?

> 
> Cyrill
> 
> On Tue, Feb 19, 2013 at 6:25 AM, Michael A. Labriola
>  wrote:
>>> How is the Flexunit donation making progress?
>> 
>> It's not.
>> 
>> Technically FlexUnit was already donated. All of the forms have been filled
>> out and approved, however, the last discussion suggested that we wait until
>> we were on git to move over the code, therefore it is in a permanent holding
>> pattern.
>> 
>> Mike
>> 

-- 
Alex Harui
Flex SDK Team
Adobe Systems, Inc.
http://blogs.adobe.com/aharui

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Cyrill Zadra]

Now that we moved to git .. is there anything else that prevents the
donation of FlexUnit? Can I help here out to make it happen?

Cyrill

On Tue, Feb 19, 2013 at 6:25 AM, Michael A. Labriola
 wrote:
>>How is the Flexunit donation making progress?
>
> It's not.
>
> Technically FlexUnit was already donated. All of the forms have been filled 
> out and approved, however, the last discussion suggested that we wait until 
> we were on git to move over the code, therefore it is in a permanent holding 
> pattern.
>
> Mike
>

RE: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Michael A. Labriola]

>How is the Flexunit donation making progress? 

It's not.

Technically FlexUnit was already donated. All of the forms have been filled out 
and approved, however, the last discussion suggested that we wait until we were 
on git to move over the code, therefore it is in a permanent holding pattern.

Mike

Re: [Mentor] & [PPMC] FlexUnit

[Sebastian Mohr]

Hi,

How is the Flexunit donation making progress? 
Our website [1] states the following:

"We use FlexUnit for unit testing. FlexUnit is in the initial phases of being 
donated to the Apache Flex project,  more information will be posted here as it 
becomes available."


Sincerely Yours,
Sebastian Mohr

[1] http://flex.apache.org/dev-sourcecode.html



On Aug 22, 2012, at 8:25 PM, Michael A. Labriola  
wrote:

> 
> I have prepared the Software Grant and scrubbed the code base for FlexUnit to 
> the point where I believe I can contribute it to the project. I will likely 
> submit most of the modules upon approval and then need to engage in a 
> discussion with Adobe before I can donate the last module or two, however, we 
> would have a functional framework. The use of FlexUnit was already marked as 
> a [Decision] earlier in our discussions.
> 
> First a procedure question, do I file the software grant immediately and then 
> work on IP clearance with the PPMC or the reverse?
> 
> Second, FlexUnit has both a full wiki of documentation and courseware. I 
> would like to donate those too. How do we go about donating something like a 
> book?
> 
> Third, I have refactored FlexUnit to have only transient dependencies on 
> other projects which are now optional, but it will mean the build and setup 
> process is more complicated, so looking for volunteers to work with me on 
> this.
> 
> Fourth, for the Adobe folks, FlexUnit 4.x can run older FlexUnit tests by 
> wrapping the older version of FlexUnit (version .9) which is still Adobe's. 
> Wondering if Adobe would donate that older version to make things easier.
> 
> Mike
> 
> 
> digital primates (r)
> 
> Michael Labriola
> labri...@digitalprimates.net
> 
> tel:  +1.773.693.7800 x206
> fax: +1.773.409.9251