Re: [vote] consolidate sandboxes
Brett Porter wrote: We'd previously been trying to get things out of trunk (since sandbox stuff isn't released, or branched, or anything like that until it gets moved out). Yup, I get that. But it would be convenient with the trunks externals. I'm not sure if that config is possible, but could certainly go through listing them all out if it was preferable to do /maven/*/sandbox. My preference was just to have one big sandbox for everything - no need to maintain the open permissions, externals, etc, and didn't see any advantage to splitting them. Okay. The advantage would be that you don't have to duplicate the top level projects in the sandbox. It's easy to find experimental stuff relating to the project it's meant to be for - that is, if you have the trunks checked out. For experimental scm's I'd go to trunks/scm/sandbox, for instance. But 1 sandbox is fine too - for completeness I just wanted to propose an alternative solution for the 2 reasons of consolidating them: cleaner acl, cleaner externals. Here's my vote then: +1. -- Kenney - Brett On 13/01/2007, at 1:00 AM, Kenney Westerhof wrote: Isn't it possible to have [:*/trunk/sandbox/] in the svn config? If so we could move all of '/maven/sandbox/(*)' in your proposal below to /maven/$1/trunk/sandbox/, so each trunk has a sandbox. Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Thought I'd put this to a vote in case others weren't following the proposal. Same as the previous proposal, so carrying over the +1 from Emmanuel, Dennis, Rahul, Trygve, Arnaud, Vincent S, Joakim, and myself unless they say otherwise. When we earlier opened the Maven sandbox to all ASF committers, I think it was the intention to do this for all sandboxes, but that wasn't the case in practice. To have a cleaner ACL, and cleaner externals on /trunks, I'd like to propose we consolidate the sandboxes. The structure would be: /maven/sandbox /maven /benchmark (from /sandbox) /maven-1.x-integration (from /sandbox) /shared /maven-artifact-tools (from /sandbox) /maven-repository-checker (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-jar (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-java-parser (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-license (from /sandbox) /plugins (as now) /other /acm (from /sandbox) /grafo (from /sandbox) /issue (from /sandbox) /marmalade (from /sandbox) /maven-dynamic-web (from /sandbox) /maven-metamorphosis (from /sandbox) /reports (from /sandbox) /ssh-tester (from /sandbox) /taxonomy (from /sandbox) /wiki (from /sandbox) /wagon /wagon-scm (from /sandbox) /scm (from /scm/trunk/sandbox) /surefire (from /surefire/trunk/sandbox) /doxia (from /doxia/trunk/sandbox) /continuum (from /continuum/sandbox) /archiva (from /archiva/sandbox) /maven-1-plugins (from /maven-1/plugins-sandbox) Cheers, Brett - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[vote] consolidate sandboxes
Hi, Thought I'd put this to a vote in case others weren't following the proposal. Same as the previous proposal, so carrying over the +1 from Emmanuel, Dennis, Rahul, Trygve, Arnaud, Vincent S, Joakim, and myself unless they say otherwise. When we earlier opened the Maven sandbox to all ASF committers, I think it was the intention to do this for all sandboxes, but that wasn't the case in practice. To have a cleaner ACL, and cleaner externals on /trunks, I'd like to propose we consolidate the sandboxes. The structure would be: /maven/sandbox /maven /benchmark (from /sandbox) /maven-1.x-integration (from /sandbox) /shared /maven-artifact-tools (from /sandbox) /maven-repository-checker (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-jar (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-java-parser (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-license (from /sandbox) /plugins (as now) /other /acm (from /sandbox) /grafo (from /sandbox) /issue (from /sandbox) /marmalade (from /sandbox) /maven-dynamic-web (from /sandbox) /maven-metamorphosis (from /sandbox) /reports (from /sandbox) /ssh-tester (from /sandbox) /taxonomy (from /sandbox) /wiki (from /sandbox) /wagon /wagon-scm (from /sandbox) /scm (from /scm/trunk/sandbox) /surefire (from /surefire/trunk/sandbox) /doxia (from /doxia/trunk/sandbox) /continuum (from /continuum/sandbox) /archiva (from /archiva/sandbox) /maven-1-plugins (from /maven-1/plugins-sandbox) Cheers, Brett - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
RE: [vote] consolidate sandboxes
+1 -Original Message- From: Brett Porter [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, January 12, 2007 3:05 AM To: Maven Developers List Subject: [vote] consolidate sandboxes Hi, Thought I'd put this to a vote in case others weren't following the proposal. Same as the previous proposal, so carrying over the +1 from Emmanuel, Dennis, Rahul, Trygve, Arnaud, Vincent S, Joakim, and myself unless they say otherwise. When we earlier opened the Maven sandbox to all ASF committers, I think it was the intention to do this for all sandboxes, but that wasn't the case in practice. To have a cleaner ACL, and cleaner externals on /trunks, I'd like to propose we consolidate the sandboxes. The structure would be: /maven/sandbox /maven /benchmark (from /sandbox) /maven-1.x-integration (from /sandbox) /shared /maven-artifact-tools (from /sandbox) /maven-repository-checker (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-jar (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-java-parser (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-license (from /sandbox) /plugins (as now) /other /acm (from /sandbox) /grafo (from /sandbox) /issue (from /sandbox) /marmalade (from /sandbox) /maven-dynamic-web (from /sandbox) /maven-metamorphosis (from /sandbox) /reports (from /sandbox) /ssh-tester (from /sandbox) /taxonomy (from /sandbox) /wiki (from /sandbox) /wagon /wagon-scm (from /sandbox) /scm (from /scm/trunk/sandbox) /surefire (from /surefire/trunk/sandbox) /doxia (from /doxia/trunk/sandbox) /continuum (from /continuum/sandbox) /archiva (from /archiva/sandbox) /maven-1-plugins (from /maven-1/plugins-sandbox) Cheers, Brett - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [vote] consolidate sandboxes
Isn't it possible to have [:*/trunk/sandbox/] in the svn config? If so we could move all of '/maven/sandbox/(*)' in your proposal below to /maven/$1/trunk/sandbox/, so each trunk has a sandbox. Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Thought I'd put this to a vote in case others weren't following the proposal. Same as the previous proposal, so carrying over the +1 from Emmanuel, Dennis, Rahul, Trygve, Arnaud, Vincent S, Joakim, and myself unless they say otherwise. When we earlier opened the Maven sandbox to all ASF committers, I think it was the intention to do this for all sandboxes, but that wasn't the case in practice. To have a cleaner ACL, and cleaner externals on /trunks, I'd like to propose we consolidate the sandboxes. The structure would be: /maven/sandbox /maven /benchmark (from /sandbox) /maven-1.x-integration (from /sandbox) /shared /maven-artifact-tools (from /sandbox) /maven-repository-checker (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-jar (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-java-parser (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-license (from /sandbox) /plugins (as now) /other /acm (from /sandbox) /grafo (from /sandbox) /issue (from /sandbox) /marmalade (from /sandbox) /maven-dynamic-web (from /sandbox) /maven-metamorphosis (from /sandbox) /reports (from /sandbox) /ssh-tester (from /sandbox) /taxonomy (from /sandbox) /wiki (from /sandbox) /wagon /wagon-scm (from /sandbox) /scm (from /scm/trunk/sandbox) /surefire (from /surefire/trunk/sandbox) /doxia (from /doxia/trunk/sandbox) /continuum (from /continuum/sandbox) /archiva (from /archiva/sandbox) /maven-1-plugins (from /maven-1/plugins-sandbox) Cheers, Brett - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [vote] consolidate sandboxes
We'd previously been trying to get things out of trunk (since sandbox stuff isn't released, or branched, or anything like that until it gets moved out). I'm not sure if that config is possible, but could certainly go through listing them all out if it was preferable to do /maven/*/ sandbox. My preference was just to have one big sandbox for everything - no need to maintain the open permissions, externals, etc, and didn't see any advantage to splitting them. - Brett On 13/01/2007, at 1:00 AM, Kenney Westerhof wrote: Isn't it possible to have [:*/trunk/sandbox/] in the svn config? If so we could move all of '/maven/sandbox/(*)' in your proposal below to /maven/$1/trunk/sandbox/, so each trunk has a sandbox. Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Thought I'd put this to a vote in case others weren't following the proposal. Same as the previous proposal, so carrying over the +1 from Emmanuel, Dennis, Rahul, Trygve, Arnaud, Vincent S, Joakim, and myself unless they say otherwise. When we earlier opened the Maven sandbox to all ASF committers, I think it was the intention to do this for all sandboxes, but that wasn't the case in practice. To have a cleaner ACL, and cleaner externals on /trunks, I'd like to propose we consolidate the sandboxes. The structure would be: /maven/sandbox /maven /benchmark (from /sandbox) /maven-1.x-integration (from /sandbox) /shared /maven-artifact-tools (from /sandbox) /maven-repository-checker (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-jar (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-java-parser (from /sandbox) /maven-shared-license (from /sandbox) /plugins (as now) /other /acm (from /sandbox) /grafo (from /sandbox) /issue (from /sandbox) /marmalade (from /sandbox) /maven-dynamic-web (from /sandbox) /maven-metamorphosis (from /sandbox) /reports (from /sandbox) /ssh-tester (from /sandbox) /taxonomy (from /sandbox) /wiki (from /sandbox) /wagon /wagon-scm (from /sandbox) /scm (from /scm/trunk/sandbox) /surefire (from /surefire/trunk/sandbox) /doxia (from /doxia/trunk/sandbox) /continuum (from /continuum/sandbox) /archiva (from /archiva/sandbox) /maven-1-plugins (from /maven-1/plugins-sandbox) Cheers, Brett - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
