Re: Integration problem Eclipse <> Sling 12

2023-07-20 Thread Konrad Windszus
Hi Juerg,
It would help, if you can try testing the latest SNAPSHOT as outlined in 
https://sling.apache.org/documentation/development/ide-tooling.html#update-site-installation
 (there is a p2 update site at https://nightlies.apache.org/sling/eclipse/)
The upcoming version has lots of issues fixed (including compatibility with 
newer Eclipse versions): 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/projects/SLING/versions/12342835

Let us know if you encounter issues not yet reported
Thanks,
Konrad

> On 20. Jul 2023, at 14:05, JCR  wrote:
> 
> On 18.07.23 16:06, JCR wrote:
>> Hello
>> 
>> I run Sling 12 docker oak-tar on an Ubuntu Server.
>> 
>> Connecting to it with Eclipse, I've seen the pretty weirdest thing ever. The 
>> Eclipse plugin 1.2.2, tested with  Eclipse versions 2020-03, 2021-03 and 
>> 2022-03 (on 2023-03, the plugin turned out to be not installable), both on 
>> Win11 and Ubuntu 22/04 clients, are far from working properly with the 
>> mentioned server instance.
>> 
>> Creating in Eclipse a folder and subsequently creating, say, a JSP and an 
>> HTL file, one seeming deletes the other upon saving it the Sling server.
>> For example, I have content.html and edit.jsp in the same folder. When 
>> saving content.html, then edit.jsp would disappear on the server. It takes 
>> an extra "Send to Sling Server..." cmd in Eclipse on edit.jsp in order to 
>> re-create it on the server.
>> 
>> No error reporting or any other indication of a problem is given... Hence, I 
>> frankly wonder what causes the problem.
>> 
>> Any hints or similar experiences out there?
>> 
>> Thanks,
>> Juerg
>> 
> Solved, but...
> 
> After testing several Eclipse versions and, testwise, connecting even to a 
> Sling11 instance, all these settings resulted in the same erratic behaviour 
> described above. Hence, I finally decided to remove the entire project from 
> eclipse and rebuild it. That solved the problem.
> 
> The cause for this is hard to identify as no error messages or the like were 
> given. But I must assume that it is a compatibility issue between Eclipse 
> 2023-03 and the Sling 1.2.2 plugin which was used to originally build the 
> project. The Sling plugin 1.2.2 has come into its years and compatibility 
> issues with Eclipse 2023-03 showed up at installation time already... So I 
> wonder who in the DEV community maintains the plugin, looks like it requires 
> an update urgently.
> 
> Best,
> Juerg
> 



Re: Integration problem Eclipse <> Sling 12

2023-07-20 Thread JCR

On 18.07.23 16:06, JCR wrote:

Hello

I run Sling 12 docker oak-tar on an Ubuntu Server.

Connecting to it with Eclipse, I've seen the pretty weirdest thing 
ever. The Eclipse plugin 1.2.2, tested with  Eclipse versions 2020-03, 
2021-03 and 2022-03 (on 2023-03, the plugin turned out to be not 
installable), both on Win11 and Ubuntu 22/04 clients, are far from 
working properly with the mentioned server instance.


Creating in Eclipse a folder and subsequently creating, say, a JSP and 
an HTL file, one seeming deletes the other upon saving it the Sling 
server.
For example, I have content.html and edit.jsp in the same folder. When 
saving content.html, then edit.jsp would disappear on the server. It 
takes an extra "Send to Sling Server..." cmd in Eclipse on edit.jsp in 
order to re-create it on the server.


No error reporting or any other indication of a problem is given... 
Hence, I frankly wonder what causes the problem.


Any hints or similar experiences out there?

Thanks,
Juerg


Solved, but...

After testing several Eclipse versions and, testwise, connecting even to 
a Sling11 instance, all these settings resulted in the same erratic 
behaviour described above. Hence, I finally decided to remove the entire 
project from eclipse and rebuild it. That solved the problem.


The cause for this is hard to identify as no error messages or the like 
were given. But I must assume that it is a compatibility issue between 
Eclipse 2023-03 and the Sling 1.2.2 plugin which was used to originally 
build the project. The Sling plugin 1.2.2 has come into its years and 
compatibility issues with Eclipse 2023-03 showed up at installation time 
already... So I wonder who in the DEV community maintains the plugin, 
looks like it requires an update urgently.


Best,
Juerg