RE: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-07-03 Thread Jason Hawryluk






Thanks for responding, 
My initial worry was not that all my questions are not getting answered. It was 
more like if Adobe wants to get into the dev realm and be active in convincing 
existing MS dev people to make a switch to Flex from the upcoming WPF/e and WPF 
platforms, their community support and involvement needs to be greater then that 
of MS on a per dev basis. The product is only 20% of the work effort to see a 
real success, the other 80% is execution, and actions required to get a user 
base that makes future development worth while.
 
Convincing developers 
to change platforms will be much harder then convincing designers. MS has to 
convince the designers, and Adobe need to convince the developers. Adobes task 
is much greater.
 
I’m afraid that the 
post came off as someone whining cause his questions don’t get answered which 
was not at all the intent.
 
I frequent the MS 
channle9 and MS forums often as I use their products, there is no talk about 
Flex/Apollo only WPF/Ajax/WPFE. I’m an avid tech blog reader, tech magazine 
reader, all around anything tech, and see no mention or little thereof of Flex. 
I heard the first time of Flex 1.5 last June? How long has it been out? I’m a 
dev that’s always looking for new technology to solve problems, so how is this 
possible.
 
This worries me too the 
core about the future of Flex. It’s a viable platform, and very powerful, 
however Macromedia has/had a reputation in the Dev world (animations etc..) 
Adobe has a rep in the Dev world (it’s just for designers). So how can Adobe 
hope to unclench the Dev world that MS fights so much to protect? It takes much 
more then a superior product to make it happen. MS is a PR machine. Unless Adobe 
gets very involved (very being an understatement) how does Adobe hope to 
accomplish this? The only way is better execution combined with superior 
involvement/support, and then hope that the word of mouth becomes viral. 

 
To become viral you 
need the story which Flex has, and the people to spread that. The story of Flex 
is not getting out there enough. 
 
I believe that Flex has 
the potential to stop MS WPF/e in it’s tracks, but the buck starts here, not in 
6 months, and not in 2.
 
Anyway enough rambling, 
I’ll just continue to do my part where I can to ensure my investment pay’s 
off.
 
Again my apologies if 
it came off the wrong way.
 
Jason
 
 

  -Message d'origine-De : 
  flexcoders@yahoogroups.com [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]De la part 
  de Gordon SmithEnvoyé : vendredi 23 juin 2006 
  08:10À : flexcoders@yahoogroups.comObjet : RE: 
  [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the 
  community
  
  My understanding is that Adobe support engineers don't generally start 
  supporting products until they are released (and therefore the product is 
  stable). It's up to the development team to support alpha, beta, and GMC 
  releases and we do that to the best of our abilities as we have spare time. 
  We're currently helping to train the Flex support engineers to take over this 
  work since we are about to release.Also, some of us are paying a bit 
  more attention to the "official" adobe.com forums and a bit less to 
  flexcoders, but we try to monitor multiple places if possible.Finally, 
  we're also missing Matt Chotins's contribution... he got promoted to 
  Product Manager.- Gordon-Original Message-From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]ups.com 
  [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]ups.com] 
  On Behalf Of Jason HawrylukSent: Thursday, June 22, 2006 7:58 AMTo: [EMAIL PROTECTED]ups.comSubject: 
  RE: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the 
  communityIf they would confirm it's a bug then yes I agree, If they 
  read them all howhard is it to respond with a simple it's a bug, should be 
  able to do that,try looking into here or this. The questions asked are not 
  consideredtrivial in my mind, it's not like I've ever asked how to build a 
  cellrenderer or anything (not that that's bad). It's rare I do not have 
  the helpup at the same time as flex, I refer to it very often.I 
  feel the post has been taken in a critical sense. I want to see 
  Flexsucceed as much as the next person, however to think that a strong 
  communitycan be built without considerable contributions from the maker, 
  is kind ofhard to imagine. Where would Java be today if Sun did spend a 
  considerableeffort, and expense in its community building?"A 
  couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it. " May 
  havebeen out of line :)Anyway thanks for the 
  input.Jason-Message d'origine-De : [EMAIL PROTECTED]ups.com 
  [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]ups.com]De 
  lapart de Tom ChivertonEnvoyé : jeudi 22 juin 2006 10:56À : [EMAIL PROTECTED]ups.comObjet 
  : Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, andbuilding the 
  communityOn Thursday 22 June 2006 09:16, sourcecoder

RE: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-07-03 Thread Jack W. Caldwell





Judah:
 
I only found one Flex book(Nov. 2006) and the three AS3 
book(Aug. 2006, Sept. 2006, & Oct. 2006)
 
What are the other Flex 2 book's and which one is coming 
out next week?
 
Thanks,
 
Jack


From: flexcoders@yahoogroups.com 
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of judahSent: 
Thursday, June 22, 2006 3:24 PMTo: 
flexcoders@yahoogroups.comSubject: Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. 
Unanswered questions, and building the community


I'd give it a bit more time. Having a beta schedule makes it difficult 
with the full release coming up. On the betas I've been on the support 
and questiong answering has always been spotty. This is because the 
state the program is in. Bugs need to be queued, tested and then 
confirmed before an answer can be given. Features are still floating 
around. Once they get out of beta I think things will settle 
down.Personally, I think they are doing a great job, but I know you've 
had questions unanswered. The solution may be to wait and see until after 
Flex 2 is released, reword the question over and over breaking it down, 
or on the Adobe side have additional community TSR's (technical support 
reps) on this list (which if they do add more I hope they'll announce 
it). I've been to Barnes & Nobles every week checking and I know of at 
least 3 new Flex 2 books coming out and two ActionScript 3 books in the 
next few months. One is coming out next week. These will hopefully 
answer a lot of questions.Best 
Regards,Judahsourcecoderia wrote:> IMHO a community is not at 
all built this way, any answer is better > then no answer. For developers 
we ask a question if it goes without > response we think either they are 
ignoring the question, can't be > bothered, or it's a bug. Since the 
first thought is that they can't > be bothered we continue to try and 
find a solution to the problem, > until completely frustrated. 
>> Theses things are very important (to me at least) when choosing 
to > switch from a dot net development environment to something such as 
> flex. I've been working with flex for a year now, and of course I'm 
> very happy with it, however I feel that the community involvement 
> from adobe is rather lacking. >> You can't hope to build 
a solid community that supports it self, we > are not the experts, you 
are. We need your help, and you need our > help. But; the communication, 
and participation in the building of > the community has to work both 
way's. I've answered far more > questions then I have had answered, I 
participated in the alpha > testing, I've reported bug's in this forum. 
All this I'm very willing > to do, and continue doing. However your 
community support people > could at least take the time and read the 
question, and either > confirm it as a bug, not possible, or give an idea 
of where to look. >> I'm not unhappy with Flex, I'm rather 
impressed and energized. > Learning a new language, and platform is 
difficult, and time > consuming. >> Why are there no 
tutorials except the few you have done to get people > up to speed, where 
is all the learn by example stuff, tips, general > community building. 
Surly you can invest in some full time community > support 
personnel.>> Flex is moving Adobe into a developer realm, as 
apposed to the > designer realm. I think if you hope to convince the 
developer realm > (a more demanding task) community involvement from 
Abode needs to be > greatly increased. A couple blog entries a week will 
not do it. A > couple of questions answered here, and there will not do 
it. We need > to see that your behind us, that you want to help us 
succeed with > your product, that you continue to listen, and that you're 
doing > everything humanly possible to help get us up to speed. 
>> Flex has the potential to be more then just some other 
platform. In > order to go head to head with MS, and unlock the dedicated 
developer > community they've built, you need to greatly increase your 
community > involvement.>> Hopefully in posting this I've 
not managed to get on the spam/ignore > list of all Adobe support 
:)>>> Here are some example things with no response, I'm 
sure if asked, > every person in this forum could repost at least 1 or 2 
unanswered > questions. Any answer is better then none.>> 
Garbage collection and removeChild [Flex 2 beta 3]?>> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/40262>>> 
E4X Interpreter:>> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/40342?> 
threaded=1&var=1&p=1>> I can't get a xml chain to 
bind here.>> [Bindable]> public var boundtarget:XML = 
new XML> 
(Jason);> 
private var owatch:ChangeWatcher;> > private fu

RE: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-06-22 Thread Gordon Smith
My understanding is that Adobe support engineers don't generally start 
supporting products until they are released (and therefore the product is 
stable). It's up to the development team to support alpha, beta, and GMC 
releases and we do that to the best of our abilities as we have spare time. 
We're currently helping to train the Flex support engineers to take over this 
work since we are about to release.

Also, some of us are paying a bit more attention to the "official" adobe.com 
forums and a bit less to flexcoders, but we try to monitor multiple places if 
possible.

Finally, we're also missing Matt Chotins's contribution... he got promoted to 
Product Manager.

- Gordon


-Original Message-
From: flexcoders@yahoogroups.com [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Jason 
Hawryluk
Sent: Thursday, June 22, 2006 7:58 AM
To: flexcoders@yahoogroups.com
Subject: RE: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the 
community

If they would confirm it's a bug then yes I agree, If they read them all how
hard is it to respond with a simple it's a bug, should be able to do that,
try looking into here or this. The questions asked are not considered
trivial in my mind, it's not like I've ever asked how to build a cell
renderer or anything (not that that's bad). It's rare I do not have the help
up at the same time as flex, I refer to it very often.

I feel the post has been taken in a critical sense. I want to see Flex
succeed as much as the next person, however to think that a strong community
can be built without considerable contributions from the maker, is kind of
hard to imagine. Where would Java be today if Sun did spend a considerable
effort, and expense in its community building?

"A couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it. " May have
been out of line :)

Anyway thanks for the input.

Jason

-Message d'origine-
De : flexcoders@yahoogroups.com [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] la
part de Tom Chiverton
Envoyé : jeudi 22 juin 2006 10:56
À : flexcoders@yahoogroups.com
Objet : Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and
building the community


On Thursday 22 June 2006 09:16, sourcecoderia wrote:
> bothered, or it's a bug. Since the first thought is that they can't
> be bothered we continue to try and find a solution to the problem,
> until completely frustrated.

There is an official (read $$$) support channel, and there are unofficial
support channels (like here).
Here is provided by community members and a few people from Adobe, basically
(as I see it) on a best effort basis.
This is not the place to report bugs (though it's useful to report them here
too for everyone to see).

> questions then I have had answered, I participated in the alpha
> testing, I've reported bug's in this forum. All this I'm very willing
> to do, and continue doing. However your community support people
> could at least take the time and read the question, and either
> confirm it as a bug, not possible, or give an idea of where to look.

I agree with you right up to the last bit - Adobe should not have to respond
to every single post. Just rest assured they really do read them all.

> Why are there no tutorials except the few you have done to get people
> up to speed, where is all the learn by example stuff, tips, general
> community building. Surly you can invest in some full time community
> support personnel.

I'm sure there will be a ton of this e.g. DevNet articles, later this month.
Assuming Adobe really are planning the Flex2 release announcement for
CFUNITED.

> A
> couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it.

I think thats rather on the low side :-)

> questions. Any answer is better then none.

I've said before that I try and go back over no-child posts older than a few
days and say at least *something*, but sometimes it's over my head, doesn't
have a simple cut'n'paste test case, or just a case of needing to read the
manual (hell, it's got a search button !) in which case I've got tired of
saying the latter :-)

Overall, Adobe are certainly going in the same good, open, direction MM
were -
and I'm, sure there is more to come.

--
Tom Chiverton



This email is sent for and on behalf of Halliwells LLP.

Halliwells LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and
Wales under registered number OC307980 whose registered office address is at
St James's Court Brown Street Manchester M2 2JF.  A list of members is
available for inspection at the registered office. Any reference to a
partner in relation to Halliwells LLP means a member of Halliwells LLP.
Regulated by the Law Society.

CONFIDENTIALITY

This email is intended only for the use of the addressee named above and may
be confide

Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-06-22 Thread judah
I'd give it a bit more time. Having a beta schedule makes it difficult 
with the full release coming up. On the betas I've been on the support 
and questiong answering has always been spotty. This is because the 
state the program is in. Bugs need to be queued, tested and then 
confirmed before an answer can be given. Features are still floating 
around. Once they get out of beta I think things will settle down.

Personally, I think they are doing a great job, but I know you've had 
questions unanswered. The solution may be to wait and see until after 
Flex 2 is released, reword the question over and over breaking it down, 
or on the Adobe side have additional community TSR's (technical support 
reps) on this list (which if they do add more I hope they'll announce 
it). I've been to Barnes & Nobles every week checking and I know of at 
least 3 new Flex 2 books coming out and two ActionScript 3 books in the 
next few months. One is coming out next week. These will hopefully 
answer a lot of questions.

Best Regards,
Judah

sourcecoderia wrote:
> IMHO a community is not at all built this way, any answer is better 
> then no answer. For developers we ask a question if it goes without 
> response we think either they are ignoring the question, can't be 
> bothered, or it's a bug. Since the first thought is that they can't 
> be bothered we continue to try and find a solution to the problem, 
> until completely frustrated. 
>
> Theses things are very important (to me at least) when choosing to 
> switch from a dot net development environment to something such as 
> flex. I've been working with flex for a year now, and of course I'm 
> very happy with it, however I feel that the community involvement 
> from adobe is rather lacking. 
>
> You can't hope to build a solid community that supports it self, we 
> are not the experts, you are. We need your help, and you need our 
> help. But; the communication, and participation in the building of 
> the community has to work both way's. I've answered far more 
> questions then I have had answered, I participated in the alpha 
> testing, I've reported bug's in this forum. All this I'm very willing 
> to do, and continue doing. However your community support people 
> could at least take the time and read the question, and either 
> confirm it as a bug, not possible, or give an idea of where to look. 
>
> I'm not unhappy with Flex, I'm rather impressed and energized. 
> Learning a new language, and platform is difficult, and time 
> consuming. 
>
> Why are there no tutorials except the few you have done to get people 
> up to speed, where is all the learn by example stuff, tips, general 
> community building. Surly you can invest in some full time community 
> support personnel.
>
> Flex is moving Adobe into a developer realm, as apposed to the 
> designer realm. I think if you hope to convince the developer realm 
> (a more demanding task) community involvement from Abode needs to be 
> greatly increased. A couple blog entries a week will not do it. A 
> couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it. We need 
> to see that your behind us, that you want to help us succeed with 
> your product, that you continue to listen, and that you're doing 
> everything humanly possible to help get us up to speed. 
>
> Flex has the potential to be more then just some other platform. In 
> order to go head to head with MS, and unlock the dedicated developer 
> community they've built, you need to greatly increase your community 
> involvement.
>
> Hopefully in posting this I've not managed to get on the spam/ignore 
> list of all Adobe support :)
>
>
> Here are some example things with no response, I'm sure if asked, 
> every person in this forum could repost at least 1 or 2 unanswered 
> questions. Any answer is better then none.
>
> Garbage collection and removeChild [Flex 2 beta 3]?
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/40262
>
>
> E4X Interpreter:
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/40342?
> threaded=1&var=1&p=1
>
> I can't get a xml chain to bind here.
>
> [Bindable]
> public var boundtarget:XML = new XML
> (Jason);
> private var owatch:ChangeWatcher;
>   
> private function Init_TargetBinding():void{
>   //build the array for the property chain
>   owatch = BindingUtils.bindProperty(text1, "text",this,
> [ "boundtarget","namex"]);
>   trace(owatch.isWatching());
> }
>
> 
>
> as well as being able to do the below
>
> BindingUtils.bindProperty( txtField, "text", this, 
> ["xdata","item","(@id=='3456')","description"] );
>
>
>
> Bug confirmation please ? Felx 2.0 b3
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/39228
>
> FileReference upload bytes FB2
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/35364
>
>
> Still problems with Tree, and drag and drop Flex 2.0 b3
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/37927
>
> Cursor questions Flex 2.0 B3
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/

RE: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-06-22 Thread Jason Hawryluk
If they would confirm it's a bug then yes I agree, If they read them all how
hard is it to respond with a simple it's a bug, should be able to do that,
try looking into here or this. The questions asked are not considered
trivial in my mind, it's not like I've ever asked how to build a cell
renderer or anything (not that that's bad). It's rare I do not have the help
up at the same time as flex, I refer to it very often.

I feel the post has been taken in a critical sense. I want to see Flex
succeed as much as the next person, however to think that a strong community
can be built without considerable contributions from the maker, is kind of
hard to imagine. Where would Java be today if Sun did spend a considerable
effort, and expense in its community building?

"A couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it. " May have
been out of line :)

Anyway thanks for the input.

Jason

-Message d'origine-
De : flexcoders@yahoogroups.com [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] la
part de Tom Chiverton
Envoyé : jeudi 22 juin 2006 10:56
À : flexcoders@yahoogroups.com
Objet : Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and
building the community


On Thursday 22 June 2006 09:16, sourcecoderia wrote:
> bothered, or it's a bug. Since the first thought is that they can't
> be bothered we continue to try and find a solution to the problem,
> until completely frustrated.

There is an official (read $$$) support channel, and there are unofficial
support channels (like here).
Here is provided by community members and a few people from Adobe, basically
(as I see it) on a best effort basis.
This is not the place to report bugs (though it's useful to report them here
too for everyone to see).

> questions then I have had answered, I participated in the alpha
> testing, I've reported bug's in this forum. All this I'm very willing
> to do, and continue doing. However your community support people
> could at least take the time and read the question, and either
> confirm it as a bug, not possible, or give an idea of where to look.

I agree with you right up to the last bit - Adobe should not have to respond
to every single post. Just rest assured they really do read them all.

> Why are there no tutorials except the few you have done to get people
> up to speed, where is all the learn by example stuff, tips, general
> community building. Surly you can invest in some full time community
> support personnel.

I'm sure there will be a ton of this e.g. DevNet articles, later this month.
Assuming Adobe really are planning the Flex2 release announcement for
CFUNITED.

> A
> couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it.

I think thats rather on the low side :-)

> questions. Any answer is better then none.

I've said before that I try and go back over no-child posts older than a few
days and say at least *something*, but sometimes it's over my head, doesn't
have a simple cut'n'paste test case, or just a case of needing to read the
manual (hell, it's got a search button !) in which case I've got tired of
saying the latter :-)

Overall, Adobe are certainly going in the same good, open, direction MM
were -
and I'm, sure there is more to come.

--
Tom Chiverton



This email is sent for and on behalf of Halliwells LLP.

Halliwells LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and
Wales under registered number OC307980 whose registered office address is at
St James's Court Brown Street Manchester M2 2JF.  A list of members is
available for inspection at the registered office. Any reference to a
partner in relation to Halliwells LLP means a member of Halliwells LLP.
Regulated by the Law Society.

CONFIDENTIALITY

This email is intended only for the use of the addressee named above and may
be confidential or legally privileged.  If you are not the addressee you
must not read it and must not use any information contained in nor copy it
nor inform any person other than Halliwells LLP or the addressee of its
existence or contents.  If you have received this email in error please
delete it and notify Halliwells LLP IT Department on 0870 365 8008.

For more information about Halliwells LLP visit www.halliwells.com.

We are pleased to announce that Halliwells LLP has been voted AIM Lawyer of
the Year at the 2005 Growth Company Awards




--
Flexcoders Mailing List
FAQ: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/files/flexcodersFAQ.txt
Search Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexcoders%40yahoogroups.com
Yahoo! Groups Links












 Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ~--> 
Great things are happening at Yahoo! Groups.  See the new email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/TISQkA/hOaOAA/yQLSAA/nhFolB/TM
--

Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-06-22 Thread Tom Chiverton
On Thursday 22 June 2006 09:16, sourcecoderia wrote:
> bothered, or it's a bug. Since the first thought is that they can't
> be bothered we continue to try and find a solution to the problem,
> until completely frustrated.

There is an official (read $$$) support channel, and there are unofficial 
support channels (like here).
Here is provided by community members and a few people from Adobe, basically 
(as I see it) on a best effort basis. 
This is not the place to report bugs (though it's useful to report them here 
too for everyone to see).

> questions then I have had answered, I participated in the alpha
> testing, I've reported bug's in this forum. All this I'm very willing
> to do, and continue doing. However your community support people
> could at least take the time and read the question, and either
> confirm it as a bug, not possible, or give an idea of where to look.

I agree with you right up to the last bit - Adobe should not have to respond 
to every single post. Just rest assured they really do read them all.

> Why are there no tutorials except the few you have done to get people
> up to speed, where is all the learn by example stuff, tips, general
> community building. Surly you can invest in some full time community
> support personnel.

I'm sure there will be a ton of this e.g. DevNet articles, later this month. 
Assuming Adobe really are planning the Flex2 release announcement for 
CFUNITED.

> A
> couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it. 

I think thats rather on the low side :-)

> questions. Any answer is better then none.

I've said before that I try and go back over no-child posts older than a few 
days and say at least *something*, but sometimes it's over my head, doesn't 
have a simple cut'n'paste test case, or just a case of needing to read the 
manual (hell, it's got a search button !) in which case I've got tired of 
saying the latter :-)

Overall, Adobe are certainly going in the same good, open, direction MM were - 
and I'm, sure there is more to come.

-- 
Tom Chiverton



This email is sent for and on behalf of Halliwells LLP.

Halliwells LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and 
Wales under registered number OC307980 whose registered office address is at St 
James's Court Brown Street Manchester M2 2JF.  A list of members is available 
for inspection at the registered office. Any reference to a partner in relation 
to Halliwells LLP means a member of Halliwells LLP. Regulated by the Law 
Society.

CONFIDENTIALITY

This email is intended only for the use of the addressee named above and may be 
confidential or legally privileged.  If you are not the addressee you must not 
read it and must not use any information contained in nor copy it nor inform 
any person other than Halliwells LLP or the addressee of its existence or 
contents.  If you have received this email in error please delete it and notify 
Halliwells LLP IT Department on 0870 365 8008.

For more information about Halliwells LLP visit www.halliwells.com.

We are pleased to announce that Halliwells LLP has been voted AIM Lawyer of the 
Year at the 2005 Growth Company Awards



 Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ~--> 
Yahoo! Groups gets a make over. See the new email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/XISQkA/lOaOAA/yQLSAA/nhFolB/TM
~-> 

--
Flexcoders Mailing List
FAQ: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/files/flexcodersFAQ.txt
Search Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/flexcoders%40yahoogroups.com 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 





Re: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. Unanswered questions, and building the community

2006-06-22 Thread Jean-Luc ESSER





Hello Sourcecodia,
 
Just my own 0.02 here:
 
The way i see a community is that it is a 
community. I mean that Adobe has not the entire responsability of answering one 
and every question posted in this forum.
Myself, i had a few questions which have never been 
answered, well, then what ? I ask again, i reformulate... But in no ways i'm 
gonna complain about Adobe.
If you need help, or have questions which need to 
be adressed in a professional and timely way, go buy a Gold Support at Adobe, 
and i assure you that you'll get what you want. And it will be worth your 
money.
 
I'm trying myself to build the french community 
around Flex, and i'm working on an everyday basis with Adobe France, i can 
assure you that their implication in developping the community is 
total.
 
Keep in mind that Flex is due out next week, they 
have a planning to respect, a lot of work to do, abunch of things to finish for 
the launch date, i'm sure that you'll be impressed by Adobe's commitment to 
the community after Flex is released.
 
Let's take Cairngorm for instance. Steven always 
claimed that they are doing all they can to get Cairngorm and all the docs ready 
for Flex release. And they will.
 
We all appreciate (as developpers) your commitment 
to the beta's and your postings to this list. But please give us and Adobe the 
time for building this community. It's all new for them. They have been in 
the community thing for only a few months.
 
I am not affiliated with Adobe in any ways, i am 
just throwing in my two cents as an enthousiastic french 
developper.
 
Best,
Jean-Luc.
 
 

  - Original Message - 
  From: 
  sourcecoderia 
  To: flexcoders@yahoogroups.com 
  Sent: Thursday, June 22, 2006 10:16 
  AM
  Subject: [flexcoders] Please Adobe. 
  Unanswered questions, and building the community
  
  
  IMHO a community is not at all built this way, any answer is better 
  then no answer. For developers we ask a question if it goes without 
  response we think either they are ignoring the question, can't be 
  bothered, or it's a bug. Since the first thought is that they can't be 
  bothered we continue to try and find a solution to the problem, until 
  completely frustrated. Theses things are very important (to me at 
  least) when choosing to switch from a dot net development environment to 
  something such as flex. I've been working with flex for a year now, and of 
  course I'm very happy with it, however I feel that the community 
  involvement from adobe is rather lacking. You can't hope to build 
  a solid community that supports it self, we are not the experts, you are. 
  We need your help, and you need our help. But; the communication, and 
  participation in the building of the community has to work both way's. 
  I've answered far more questions then I have had answered, I participated 
  in the alpha testing, I've reported bug's in this forum. All this I'm very 
  willing to do, and continue doing. However your community support people 
  could at least take the time and read the question, and either confirm 
  it as a bug, not possible, or give an idea of where to look. I'm not 
  unhappy with Flex, I'm rather impressed and energized. Learning a new 
  language, and platform is difficult, and time consuming. Why are 
  there no tutorials except the few you have done to get people up to speed, 
  where is all the learn by example stuff, tips, general community building. 
  Surly you can invest in some full time community support 
  personnel.Flex is moving Adobe into a developer realm, as apposed to 
  the designer realm. I think if you hope to convince the developer realm 
  (a more demanding task) community involvement from Abode needs to be 
  greatly increased. A couple blog entries a week will not do it. A 
  couple of questions answered here, and there will not do it. We need 
  to see that your behind us, that you want to help us succeed with your 
  product, that you continue to listen, and that you're doing everything 
  humanly possible to help get us up to speed. Flex has the potential to 
  be more then just some other platform. In order to go head to head with 
  MS, and unlock the dedicated developer community they've built, you need 
  to greatly increase your community involvement.Hopefully in 
  posting this I've not managed to get on the spam/ignore list of all Adobe 
  support :)Here are some example things with no response, I'm sure if 
  asked, every person in this forum could repost at least 1 or 2 unanswered 
  questions. Any answer is better then none.Garbage collection and 
  removeChild [Flex 2 beta 3]?http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/40262E4X 
  Interpreter:http://groups.yahoo.com/group/flexcoders/message/40342?threaded=1&var=1&p=1I 
  can't get a xml chain to bind here.[Bindable]public var 
  boundtarget:XML = new 
  XML(Jason);private 
  var owatch:ChangeWatcher;private function 
  Init_TargetBinding():void{//build the array for the property 
  c