[Goanet] Manohar Parrikar - Response to Cedrico
From: Vidyadhar Gadgil [EMAIL PROTECTED] Vodyadhar wrote - But who is talking of BJP supporters or those who voted for them? The point is the party itself. That is no different from what it is in the rest of India. If they are different, let the BJP (Goa version) give a public statement condemning Narendra Modi and asking for action to be taken against all those responsible for the Gujarat carnage. Response - How conveniently are you forgetting the fact of 23 years back genocide of Sikhs which took place in November 1984 in which more than 4,000 Sikh men, women and children slaughtered by Congress hooligans. In Delhi alone, 2,733 Sikhs were burned alive, butchered or beaten to death. Women were raped while their terrified families pleaded for mercy, little or none of which was shown by the Congress flag-bearers. For three days and nights the killing and pillaging continued without the police, the civil administration and the Union Congress Government who was in power , which was then in direct charge of Delhi, lifting a finger in admonishment. It was the Congress cadres who were behind this genocide. Despite the constitution of innumerable high-power committees, police investigation teams and commissions these are few small fries who have been booked; the real culprits are still eluding the call of justice. The reality is that there has been no political will to prosecute the culprits. Did any Goa Congress leader condemn these killings ? Vidyadhar wrote – What is this your people and my people business? Here precisely is the problem with the Sangh Parivar -- the inability to think beyond communal identities. Response - You are grossly misinterpreting my sentence. My word ,”your people” meant people of your constituency. Don’t apply your own whimsical meanings to everything. I know Margao is a Hindu majority constituency. So there is no question of communal trail in my script. Vinay __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com
Re: [Goanet] Manohar Parrikar - Response to Cedrico
From: Vinay Natekar [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [Goanet] Manohar Parrikar - Response to Cedrico Gujrat incident is a blot on Humanity. I condemn Narendra Modi and those who were responsible for the carnage be it either Godhra train incident or the riots that followed after that. You can not compare Goan BJP supporters with those Gujaratis. The people who are voting for BJP in Goa are always Secular and voted for the stable and clean administration. Goan political scenario is totally different from rest of India. But who is talking of BJP supporters or those who voted for them? The point is the party itself. That is no different from what it is in the rest of India. If they are different, let the BJP (Goa version) give a public statement condemning Narendra Modi and asking for action to be taken against all those responsible for the Gujarat carnage. I am in possessions of various documents that were ccd to porikar when he was Cm when Digamber kamat was running riot with several catholic families in Margao. Response It is your people who have re elected him from Margao Constituency. What is this your people and my people business? Here precisely is the problem with the Sangh Parivar -- the inability to think beyond communal identities. -- Question everything -- Karl Marx
[Goanet] Manohar Parrikar - Response to Cedrico
Firstly, i debated long if i should stoop to your level in replying to non-entities like you. To me you dont count, i challenge you to have an indept knowledge of Goa's estwhile politics and political acumen to analyse the ground realities of politics, in Goa and the world over. I also challenge you to admit on this forum if you ever held any political post even in college level politics. Response Mr. Cedrico you are getting very personal here. I am not a politician neither contested any election. I just wanted to make it clear to you that liberty of expressing your opinion does not meant saying any drivel on the domain you are ignorant about sitting in Dubai. Your conceptions are only reflections of prejudiced rhetoric of opportunist politicians who spread fallacious rumors to create fear psychosis for their political gains. Gujrat incident is a blot on Humanity. I condemn Narendra Modi and those who were responsible for the carnage be it either Godhra train incident or the riots that followed after that. You can not compare Goan BJP supporters with those Gujaratis. The people who are voting for BJP in Goa are always Secular and voted for the stable and clean administration. Goan political scenario is totally different from rest of India. We do not have history of poll violence except few stray incidents for which you can not blame a single party. You are entitled to honour the people you think are saints and saviours, i am entitled to mine.By calling me a bluff...you think you gain immortality or martyer hood...maybe in the darbar of Porrikar! I am a neutral political analyst. I criticize in the same vein a Digamber kamat and a Porrikar as i know they have the same communial virus that runs in their blood. The BJP is a blot on a secular India and tried its best to destroy Goa and do a Gujarat here. The result was the resounding slap the electorate gave the BJP at the recent hustings. Response Neutral analyst do not air their bias view against any selective political party. Election results at a given time and place have no permanent immutable validity. Most of the times demagogues and despots successfully manage to manipulate the will of the people by using either muscle power or money earned by corruption and scandalous means Take my words a Party losing or winning elections does not make it good or bad. Gujarat have voted Modi by overwhelming majority and will repeat the feat in next elections too. It does not make the Gujarat leadership as right similarly Goan electorate rejecting Goa BJP unit in last elections does not make it bad either. I am in possessions of various documents that were ccd to porikar when he was Cm when Digamber kamat was running riot with several catholic families in Margao. Response It is your people who have re elected him from Margao Constituency. Leave that for another day. As long as Porrikar is associated with the RSS, and BJP...even if he changes his thick hide, nobody will believe him and to the Goan masses he is like the cat who told everyone about the sanyas it took at kashi, no sooner it saw a rat it pounced on it and devouvered it. Response The majority of MLAs from the current ruling party and their cronies are not originally from Congress Party. This herd of comrades have flocked together with one aim in common to heap the riches while sun shines. Parrikar have always remained loyal to BJP ever since joining it come hell or high waters and not mortgaged his loyalty for the sake of opportunism. I also pity you but actually people like you who chastise true Goan contemporary freedom fighters like Floriano and myself who are fighting for Goa's freedom from the clutches of communial and corrupt elements like your BJP...will go no where in life. And please refrain in calling people names on this forum, least i will feel that you are nothing better than the someone in Goa who would abuse anyone for a quarter of feni or a some cheap liquor that your master could have afforded to make you drink! You need to have some guts to call a spade a spade and write on GOANET, in the better interest of GOANS and GOA! Response You and your mentor Floriano better fight against corruption, nepotism and non performance by current Government because of lust and internal fighting. BJP is not in power now. Instead of digging dead from grave you better do something productive endeavor to have a check on malfunctioning of current Government if you do not trade yourself for bottle of imported drink which only the people from ruling party can afford to offer you. Vinay __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com
