Re: Strange Authorization problem
Hi Sebb, Does it look to you like a bug? Should I report it in bugzilla? Has any body else experienced this problem? Matt m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Changing the server variable name in different thread group seems to have fixed the problem. Looks like some concurrency problem in JMeter sebb wrote: I was referring to any/all variables that may be duplicated in the thread groups. You should be able to use an editor to change the relevant instances of the variables directly in the JMX files. E.g. save one threadgroup to a separate file, and edit that. Delete the original threadgroup and re-import. [Backup the JMX files first!] Or just create a smaller test case - this would be useful anyway when reporting a bug. S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: I have not tried that. It will be a big change for me, as these two groups are large and are replicas of each other, so every soap call users server variable. I am assuming you are referring to variable called server Let me try that if you think that might be the bug Matt sebb wrote: What happens if you use different variable names for the two thread groups? S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.
Re: Strange Authorization problem
It does look like a bug to me. Yes, please report it in Bugzilla, and if you have a simple test-case please attach that (create the bug first, then you can add attachments). S. On 01/11/05, m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Sebb, Does it look to you like a bug? Should I report it in bugzilla? Has any body else experienced this problem? Matt m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Changing the server variable name in different thread group seems to have fixed the problem. Looks like some concurrency problem in JMeter sebb wrote: I was referring to any/all variables that may be duplicated in the thread groups. You should be able to use an editor to change the relevant instances of the variables directly in the JMX files. E.g. save one threadgroup to a separate file, and edit that. Delete the original threadgroup and re-import. [Backup the JMX files first!] Or just create a smaller test case - this would be useful anyway when reporting a bug. S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: I have not tried that. It will be a big change for me, as these two groups are large and are replicas of each other, so every soap call users server variable. I am assuming you are referring to variable called server Let me try that if you think that might be the bug Matt sebb wrote: What happens if you use different variable names for the two thread groups? S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.
Strange Authorization problem
I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com
Re: Strange Authorization problem
Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.
Re: Strange Authorization problem
What happens if you use different variable names for the two thread groups? S. On 31/10/05, m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Strange Authorization problem
I have not tried that. It will be a big change for me, as these two groups are large and are replicas of each other, so every soap call users server variable. I am assuming you are referring to variable called server Let me try that if you think that might be the bug Matt sebb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What happens if you use different variable names for the two thread groups? S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.
Re: Strange Authorization problem
I was referring to any/all variables that may be duplicated in the thread groups. You should be able to use an editor to change the relevant instances of the variables directly in the JMX files. E.g. save one threadgroup to a separate file, and edit that. Delete the original threadgroup and re-import. [Backup the JMX files first!] Or just create a smaller test case - this would be useful anyway when reporting a bug. S. On 31/10/05, m mat [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I have not tried that. It will be a big change for me, as these two groups are large and are replicas of each other, so every soap call users server variable. I am assuming you are referring to variable called server Let me try that if you think that might be the bug Matt sebb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What happens if you use different variable names for the two thread groups? S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: Strange Authorization problem
Changing the server variable name in different thread group seems to have fixed the problem. Looks like some concurrency problem in JMeter sebb [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I was referring to any/all variables that may be duplicated in the thread groups. You should be able to use an editor to change the relevant instances of the variables directly in the JMX files. E.g. save one threadgroup to a separate file, and edit that. Delete the original threadgroup and re-import. [Backup the JMX files first!] Or just create a smaller test case - this would be useful anyway when reporting a bug. S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: I have not tried that. It will be a big change for me, as these two groups are large and are replicas of each other, so every soap call users server variable. I am assuming you are referring to variable called server Let me try that if you think that might be the bug Matt sebb wrote: What happens if you use different variable names for the two thread groups? S. On 31/10/05, m mat wrote: Hi Any pointers on this? Thanks Matt m mat wrote: I have two thread groups structured as follows Th Grp 1 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server1 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server1/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls Th Grp 2 -User Def Variables ---Server=Server2 -HTTP Authorizaton Manager --Base URL =http://server2/folder1/glue --User Name =uid --Password =pwd HTTP HeaderManager --Name= --Value=JSESSIONID=${cookee} Bunch of SOAP calls The problem is: a. All calls get made to the server that is in the second thread group - server2 in this case. If I put server2 in th grp 1 and servere 1 in th grp 2, all calls get made to server 1. My understanding is that the user defined variables should be able to override the server name with in the thread group. As that variable gets used when calling the SOAP calls. b. Some calls do not get passed authorization information. The server therefore rejects these calls. I have not been able to establish a pattern as to which calls get authorization information and which do not . Can you please help me with what is going on? Thanks Matt Nop Lists wrote: well, this is exactly what is broken :-( the behaviour I described appears when loading files using the file open dialog in the listener... On 10/31/05, sebb wrote: You need to load JTL files using the file open dialog in the listener. On 26/10/05, Nop Lists wrote: Hello, trying to load various results files created in the recent days into an aggregate report I keep getting the error (in the aggregate report) Error loading result file - see log file. The logfile does not provide much more information. It says: 2005/10/26 15:32:32 INFO - jmeter.visualizers.gui.AbstractVisualizer: getting new collector 2005/10/26 15:32:32 WARN - jmeter.reporters.ResultCollector: File load failure, trying old data format. I am using JMeter 2.1.1. The top of the jtl file looks like this: threadName=Thread Gruppe 1-1 label=Login Request time=1412 responseMessage=OK responseCode=200 success=true error=false failure=false/ error=false failure=false/ Can anybody advise me how to load the JTL files? Thanks Nop - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] __ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Yahoo! FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click.