[jQuery] Re: Safari 2.0.4 not passing the jQuery test

2008-06-22 Thread Jeff Kenny

I understand Safari's limitations, but saying it's compatible sets an
expectation that it (all of it) will work.

I consistently had Safari crash when trying to use the html() and
replaceWith() functions. If you're aware of Safari's issues and only
run the test suite in pieces, then it'd be nice if you could publish
what the pieces are so that we (the jQuery using public) know what we
should be looking out for.

Thanks for the reply, even if we disagree on compatible.  :-)
Jeff

On Jun 19, 9:43 am, John Resig [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Jeff -

 Safari2 has serious memory issues that are impossible to work around
 - simply loading and executing too much JavaScript will cause it to
 crash (as you see with the test suite). We do run the test suite
 againstSafari2 but in pieces to verify that it works as intended.
 Yes, we still supportSafari2.

 --John

 On Thu, Jun 19, 2008 at 12:12 AM, Jeff Kenny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

  I'm working on a site and the js is crashingSafari2.0.4, so I went
  back to check the compatibility page and it says it's supported. I ran
  the test page (http://jquery.com/test/) inSafari2.0.4 multiple
  times and it crashed EVERY time BUT at different places.

  So...my question is, is jQuery really compatible withSafari2.0.4 or
  should it be taken off the list of compatibility? In which case I'm a
  little screwed.


[jQuery] Re: Safari 2.0.4 not passing the jQuery test

2008-06-22 Thread Abba . Bryant

I believe you misinterpreted the statement by John.
The *entire* test suite passes in Safari. To overcome the memory
issues they need to break the test suite into multiple smaller sets of
tests and run those. If the entire suite is run it causes Safari to
crash due to the applications memory management problems.

On Jun 22, 6:29 am, Jeff Kenny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 I understand Safari's limitations, but saying it's compatible sets an
 expectation that it (all of it) will work.

 I consistently had Safari crash when trying to use the html() and
 replaceWith() functions. If you're aware of Safari's issues and only
 run the test suite in pieces, then it'd be nice if you could publish
 what the pieces are so that we (the jQuery using public) know what we
 should be looking out for.

 Thanks for the reply, even if we disagree on compatible.  :-)
 Jeff

 On Jun 19, 9:43 am, John Resig [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

  Jeff -

  Safari2 has serious memory issues that are impossible to work around
  - simply loading and executing too much JavaScript will cause it to
  crash (as you see with the test suite). We do run the test suite
  againstSafari2 but in pieces to verify that it works as intended.
  Yes, we still supportSafari2.

  --John

  On Thu, Jun 19, 2008 at 12:12 AM, Jeff Kenny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

   I'm working on a site and the js is crashingSafari2.0.4, so I went
   back to check the compatibility page and it says it's supported. I ran
   the test page (http://jquery.com/test/) inSafari2.0.4 multiple
   times and it crashed EVERY time BUT at different places.

   So...my question is, is jQuery really compatible withSafari2.0.4 or
   should it be taken off the list of compatibility? In which case I'm a
   little screwed.


[jQuery] Re: Safari 2.0.4 not passing the jQuery test

2008-06-19 Thread John Resig

Jeff -

Safari 2 has serious memory issues that are impossible to work around
- simply loading and executing too much JavaScript will cause it to
crash (as you see with the test suite). We do run the test suite
against Safari 2 but in pieces to verify that it works as intended.
Yes, we still support Safari 2.

--John


On Thu, Jun 19, 2008 at 12:12 AM, Jeff Kenny [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 I'm working on a site and the js is crashing Safari 2.0.4, so I went
 back to check the compatibility page and it says it's supported. I ran
 the test page ( http://jquery.com/test/ ) in Safari 2.0.4 multiple
 times and it crashed EVERY time BUT at different places.

 So...my question is, is jQuery really compatible with Safari 2.0.4 or
 should it be taken off the list of compatibility? In which case I'm a
 little screwed.