Re: Fingerings get crushed if key is removed. Bug?
or add \override Fingering.add-stem-support = ##t HTH Stephen ___ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
Re: Fingerings get crushed if key is removed. Bug?
On 24.02.2016 17:14, Pierre-Luc Gauthier wrote: Greetings, Just documenting an oddity. If you remove the key (on line 11) the piano fingerings get crushed into the beams. Rather strange… Should I file a bug report ? No, I think this is ‘expected behaviour’ in some way: Without the key signature, the music expression with the fingerings ends up on a different Voice than the music, so collision resolving doesn’t work. Try enclosing the right and left hand parts with \new Voice, then there will be no problem. Best, Simon ___ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
Fingerings get crushed if key is removed. Bug?
Greetings, Just documenting an oddity. If you remove the key (on line 11) the piano fingerings get crushed into the beams. Rather strange… Should I file a bug report ? Have a good day -- Pierre-Luc Gauthier %%% http://lilybin.com/z6ukgb/6 %%% \version "2.18.2" \language "english" global = { % Try and remove the key bellow. \key c \major % If the key is not there, the fingerings get crushed up \time 6/4 } right = \relative c' { \global << { c8 cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c1. c8 b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c1. } { s8-1 \repeat unfold 2 { \repeat unfold 2 {s-3 s-1} s-2 \repeat unfold 3 {s-3 s-1} s-2 } s1 s4. s8-2 \repeat unfold 2 { \repeat unfold 3 {s-1 s-3} s-2 \repeat unfold 2 {s-1 s-3} s-2 } } >> } left = \relative c, { \global << { c8 cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c1. c8 b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c1. } { \repeat unfold 2 { \repeat unfold 2 {s8-1 s-3} s-2 \repeat unfold 3 {s-1 s-3} s-2 } s1.-1 s8-1 \repeat unfold 2 { s-2 \repeat unfold 3 {s-3 s-1} s-2 \repeat unfold 2 {s-3 s-1} } } >> } scoreContent = { \new PianoStaff << \new Staff \right \new Staff { \clef bass \left } >> } \score { \scoreContent \layout { } \midi { } } \version "2.18.2" \language "english" global = { % Try and remove the key bellow. \key c \major % If the key is not there, the fingerings get crushed up \time 6/4 } right = \relative c' { \global << { c8 cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c1. c8 b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c1. } { s8-1 \repeat unfold 2 { \repeat unfold 2 {s-3 s-1} s-2 \repeat unfold 3 {s-3 s-1} s-2 } s1 s4. s8-2 \repeat unfold 2 { \repeat unfold 3 {s-1 s-3} s-2 \repeat unfold 2 {s-1 s-3} s-2 } } >> } left = \relative c, { \global << { c8 cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c cs d ds e f fs g gs a as b c1. c8 b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c b bf a af g gf f e ef d df c1. } { \repeat unfold 2 { \repeat unfold 2 {s8-1 s-3} s-2 \repeat unfold 3 {s-1 s-3} s-2 } s1.-1 s8-1 \repeat unfold 2 { s-2 \repeat unfold 3 {s-3 s-1} s-2 \repeat unfold 2 {s-3 s-1} } } >> } scoreContent = { \new PianoStaff << \new Staff \right \new Staff { \clef bass \left } >> } \score { \scoreContent \layout { } \midi { } }___ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user